4 ms·
I think a comment on the reddit thread about this is somewhat appropriate, though I don't mean the imply the same harshness: > Godfather of AI - I have concern
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I think a comment on the reddit thread about this is somewhat appropriate, though I don't mean the imply the same harshness:
> Godfather of AI - I have concerns.
> Reddit - This old guy doesn't know shit. Here's my opinion that will be upvoted by nitwits.
Point being, if you're saying that the guy who literally wrote the paper on back propagation is "fear mongering", but who is now questioning the value of his life's work, then I suggest you take a step back and re-examine why you think he may have these concerns in the first place.
- mhh__ 4y agoThere's a big jump from backprop to what we have now, Hinton mainly does the AI equivalent of fundamental physics not applications.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThis is just flat-out wrong. You make it sound like Hinton hasn't done much since his famous back propagation paper, or that he hasn't been intimately involved in productizing some of his research. Hinton's startup, DNNresearch Inc., which made breakthroughs in machine vision (particularly around identifying objects in images and image classifications), was acquired by Google in 2013, specifically to help with image search (and also, obviously, for the talent of the team). Hinton's cofounders in that startup were Alex Krizhevsky (of AlexNet fame) and Ilya Sutskever, current Chief Scientist at OpenAI.
- mhh__ 4y agoI aim to make it sound like Hinton isn't in the cutting edge of LLM research - not that he is somehow incapable of it, but rather that anyone who isn't at OpenAI at the moment is probably in the dark. The most recent thing I have seen of him on my feed for example was a paper into the fundamentals of learning (The forward-forward paper), for example.
- signa11 4y agoi think you mean “deep learning” there ? back-propagation existed way before that.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI didn't say he invented it, and for some reason I see lots of comments wanting to nitpick over the details of his contributions. I'll just copy the relevant sentence from his Wikipedia article, which I think is a very fair assessment: > With David Rumelhart and Ronald J. Williams, Hinton was co-author of a highly cited paper published in 1986 that popularised the backpropagation algorithm for training multi-layer neural networks, although they were not the first to propose the approach.
- int_19h 4y agoI think there are two distinct points here that need to be clearly separated. When Hinton gives an estimate on how fast things are going to move and how far they can go, that is the part where his background gives his estimates much higher credibility than any random person on the Internet. But how dangerous that level is to humanity as a whole is a separate question, and one that he is not an expert on.