3 ms·
> A sense of morality or just any connection to what's... normal? Regular reminder that what is moral, what is normal, and what is legal are three separate que
by pjc50 4y ago
> A sense of morality or just any connection to what's... normal?
Regular reminder that what is moral, what is normal, and what is legal are three separate questions with time- and culture-specific answers.
This stuff is "abnormal" only because it's new and no norms have been established. Using an AI for anything cannot be a "normal" act because it's so new. This is the possibly dark side of "disruptive".
The more relevant question is: is it harmful? And you might construct an argument that leading people into delusional beliefs is harmful.
(of course, then the free speech absolutists turn up and say that by definition nothing Replika says can be harmful because it's just speech, and it would be morally wrong to intervene in the conversation between a company and its users)
- aww_dang 4y agohttps://www.citizen.co.za/entertainment/celebrity-news/americans-think-wakanda-and-zamunda-are-real/ https://www.citizen.co.za/entertainment/celebrity-news/ameri... >Since Marvel’s Black Panther and Coming 2 America have both taken the internet by storm since they premiered, it may come as no surprise that many Americans think Wakanda and Zamunda are real. To what extent are purveyors of fantasy responsible for consumers' lack of discernment?
- throwaway22032 4y agoI'm pretty sure that it will never be considered normal to have a sexual relationship with a bot outside of some extremely niche communities which are considered bizarre by wider society. You're at work and people are chatting about their family, or the girls/guys they find hot at the club, or that they're enjoying single life or whatever, and then Dave tells you he's married his chatbot. Like, really though. What happens next in that conversation? This isn't some sort of college philosophy debate, let's be real here.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoPeople would have made the same argument 30 years ago but with Dave being into guys. Societal norms often change unpredictably, but I for one strive to not end up on the "bigot" side of history.
- bavell 4y agoI don't think having romantic relationships with inanimate objects or non-humans will ever be normalized, for obvious reasons.
- DangitBobby 4y agoIt's not obvious to me.
- jjgreen 4y agoWait, not even motorbikes ??
- ben_w 4y agoFor AI, it seems at least as likely to be normalised as the generally accepted parasocial relationship between celebrities and their audiences. For non-humans… I'm expecting, by 2100, arbitrary biological re-engineering to be possible, to the extent that it renders meaningless the current boundaries between human and non-human in both body and mind — the idea of hooking up with a centaur or a dragon might be pretty niche fantasy today, but when you know the former is Dave and he has an interest in crochet and organic farming, and the latter is Tiffany your sysadmin and she's a regular at her local LARP event, it changes things. Some people clearly hate this, judging by the anti-transhumanism conspiracy theories, even though it's not actually possible today — but are they representative?