4 ms·
> They already know and/or could trivially find out. 100% agree here. Today the US goverment, I won't attempt to speak towards any other government, has way to
by _heimdall 4y ago
> They already know and/or could trivially find out.
100% agree here. Today the US goverment, I won't attempt to speak towards any other government, has way too much power and ability to collect inflammation in it's citizens. We've allowed the government to assume that powers but we could also take that power away. If the government owns the bank there's literally no way to do that.
Healthcare here is a whole other massively broken system. In general yes I think it's a fair generalization that we would prefer to pay extra to avoid large governments, historically at least since we've done a really poor job keeping our federal government small for the last 80 years. It makes sense given our country's history though, and personally I'd rather pay a little more to a corporation than save a few bucks at the expense of living under a much more powerful centralized authority.
- pbz 4y ago> I'd rather pay a little more to a corporation It's hardly "a little more" though. We're spending almost twice as much and get almost half as little back. Objectively speaking the capitalist market has failed in this area. We have to first accept this fact before we can find any solutions. If we keep thinking "government is bad" and "private industry is good" we're only allowing further exploitation and pain; and for what? We need to be data/solution driven.
- abfan1127 4y agothe banking industry has been heavily subsidized by FDIC, the Fed, and bailouts. This corporate socialization is certainly worse than either fully capitalist or fully centralized.
- largepeepee 4y agoThat is modern capitalism at its finest. Privatize the gains, socialize the losses.
- _heimdall 4y agoThat's really not capitalism at all.
- largepeepee 4y agoThat is how capitalism works in reality.
- SoftTalker 4y agoThe healthcare marketplace is hardly capitalist. It's deeply influenced by government policy and spending, as most healthcare expenditure is for the old, and it goes through Medicare.
- LordDragonfang 4y agoIf the US healthcare market isn't capitalist, then no country's healthcare system is. It's rare to find a way to "no true Scotsman" as hard as communists, but you've managed it. But to address your point: contrary to what you're implying, Medicare spending is actually lower on average relative to spending on 65+'s in other countries; in e.g. the NHS, they're 18% of the population and 40% of the spending[1]. i.e. per-person spending is much higher in retirees. Contrast this with the US where per-medicare-enrollee spending (13k) is almost the same as the average spending (12.5k), because the non-socialized (capitalist) part of the market pays so much more than in other developed countries, that it doesn't bring down the average despite the younger cohorts having many fewer health problems. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/feb/01/ageing-britain-two-fifths-nhs-budget-spent-over-65s https://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/feb/01/ageing-brita...
- astrange 4y ago> If the US healthcare market isn't capitalist, then no country's healthcare system is. Yes. That said, developing countries are most likely to have one. If the government caps the number of doctors and hospitals in the country, like the US does with residencies and certificate of need laws, it's not very market-driven.
- pbz 4y agoThe government does not cap the number of doctors. There's no law that you can only have X doctors. What it caps is the amount of social help it's willing to subsidize. This is like complaining that the government is not "socialist" enough and therefore socialism is bad.
- 4y ago
- robocat 4y ago> Objectively speaking the capitalist market has failed in this area Objectively speaking the non-capitalist systems have failed in this area too. The UK’s NHS is not capitalist and it is surely isn’t succeeding better than the US healthcare system. You can find countries where “socialist” healthcare works, but you can also find capitalist healthcare that works.
- Matl 4y ago> Objectively speaking the non-capitalist systems have failed in this area too. The UK’s NHS is not capitalist and it is surely isn’t succeeding better than the US healthcare system. The NHS has been effectively privatized as much as the Conservatives could get away with. It is constantly underfunded. It is not an example of a system the government wants to make work. In fact making it not work is the goal. Yet when a family member of mine needed a life saving operation, they got it promptly and it didn't send them into any debt, whereas in contrast there's something like 50k preventable deaths a year in the U.S. due to lack of healthcare and people of poor means actively avoid visiting the hospital, so the NHS still works better for the vast majority. Yes, for us in the tech industry and for elective procedures it's not so great, but that also perhaps isn't what regular people need.
- robocat 4y ago> 50k preventable deaths I love that term. If you prevent death one day, only for them to die the next, is that one preventable death? What if you do that five days in a row? Death is not preventable. Extra years of quality life, I can get on board with. Especially because it sounds more manipulable, so you are more wary about it’s meaning. To put 50k/annum in perspective, 3.5 million people died in the USA in 2021. It’s a difficult area to come up with numbers for: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34045778 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34045778 > people of poor means Don’t poor people get some free healthcare in the US - although relatively how good that care is compared with other countries I don’t know. I thought it was the middle class that lose everything.
- _heimdall 4y agoFord twice as much I assume you're referencing healthcare specifically. Or healthcare system is horribly broken and in a terrible middle ground of government overreach and corruption while still technically being a private system. That's just about the worst example we could look at at which point twice as much doesn't sound nearly as bad for a worst case.
- Nullabillity 4y agoThose corporations are already powerful centralized authorities! The difference is that they don't even have to pretend to be beholden to the public like the government is.
- bombcar 4y agoExactly! If the government starts doing things to you there are legal recourses. If your bank decides you can’t have an account anymore, there’s not much you can do.
- hollerith 4y agoBecause a government would never freeze the funds in your bank account. Oh wait: that is what Canadian government did to tractor-trailer protesters a few years ago.
- JetSpiegel 4y agoThey frozen the funds held by private banks. So what's the value-add of banks, again?
- _heimdall 4y agoAs long as they are technically separate we have the chance to separate the two again, removing corruption and capture. If the industries are moved into the government officially we really have given up that fight and have to accept whatever they give us. I assume it will be cake.
- webnrrd2k 4y agoI just want to point out that ”to collect inflammation in it's citizens" is an great typo!
- I-M-S 4y ago"The West, so afraid of strong government, now has no government, only financial power."