3 ms·
> You can't legislate morality, and you can't prop up business models that require people to behave contrary to their nature. That cuts both ways. Expecting th
by Silhouette 15y ago
> You can't legislate morality, and you can't prop up business models that require people to behave contrary to their nature.
That cuts both ways. Expecting the same quantity and quality of work to enjoy without a system that compensates the people who worked hard to produce it is also expecting something contrary to human nature. You can get so far with volunteer works, but ultimately we've all got rent to pay/kids to feed/etc.
> Copyright enforcement is completely infeasible.
Of course it's not.
Sure, there will always be a few people who know enough to work around it. And sure, you can always exploit the analogue hole by literally recording poor quality video off your computer screen with an old camcorder or something similar if you've got such kit lying around.
But you could block the overwhelming majority of copyright infringement pretty easily if you were willing to impose severe enough restrictions and to make examples of those who tried to work around those restrictions. It's just that most of us really wouldn't like the collateral damage that such policies would cause.
- icebraining 15y agoThat cuts both ways. Expecting the same quantity and quality of work to enjoy without a system that compensates the people who worked hard to produce it is also expecting something contrary to human nature. You can get so far with volunteer works, but ultimately we've all got rent to pay/kids to feed/etc. Oh, the same old fallacy. How does that fit in with the studies that shows that "pirates" buy a lot[1], with the year over year MPAA record profits[2] or with a game company getting $1000000 before the game was even made? [1]: http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20110727/16233815292/another-day-another-study-that-says-pirates-are-best-customers-this-time-hadopi.shtml http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20110727/16233815292/anothe... http://news.cnet.com/2100-1023-898813.html http://news.cnet.com/2100-1023-898813.html [2]: http://www.zeropaid.com/news/92692/piracy-who-mpaa-celebrates-5th-consecutive-year-of-record-profits/ http://www.zeropaid.com/news/92692/piracy-who-mpaa-celebrate...
- Silhouette 15y ago> How does that fit in with the studies that shows that "pirates" buy a lot Correlation does not imply causation. > with the year over year MPAA record profits Most of the artists in the world do not work for Hollywood. > or with a game company getting $1000000 before the game was even made? That is tiny by modern AAA game standards. Also, not everyone has the advantages the people with the successful Kickstarter project had. The basic problem with the whole argument that copyright isn't necessary and people make can money from content in other ways is always the same: nothing in today's copyright law prevents someone using alternative business models if they really do provide a better incentive, yet hardly anyone does.
- icebraining 15y agoCorrelation does not imply causation. Which is fine, since I never implied that file sharing caused sales. The study shows that people still buy even if they pirate a lot. Causation is irrelevant. Most of the artists in the world do not work for Hollywood. Again, I never implied they did. The claim was that by removing copyright protection, you'd be reduced to volunteer work. The fact that Hollywood has record profits despite increasing file sharing implies that the claim is false, since Hollywood is professional. That is tiny by modern AAA game standards. Again, the claim was that professional works would disappear, not AAA games alone. Personally, I couldn't care less about most of them.
- Silhouette 15y agoI think perhaps you're reading things into earlier posts that are not there, and then attacking strawmen without realising it. My claims, as you put it, would be that: (a) without some form of effective incentive for people to create and share works, you are necessarily reduced to volunteer efforts, and (b) while volunteer effort does produce valuable works, there is little evidence to suggest that such efforts alone would produce a similar quantity and quality of work to what we enjoy today. These points are relevant because if we're talking about a technology that potentially renders the current legal incentive scheme, copyright, unenforceable, then those who currently produce works using business models built around that scheme have a legitimate concern that they will no longer be able to exercise their legal rights in the that situation. Since no-one has yet demonstrated a more productive system that is viable on the same scale, that will give Big Media lobbyists a very strong argument that copyright enforcement is necessary to protect the supply of new and high quality works and that all these draconian proposals they keep asking for are the only solution. And that will lead to another round of SOPA/PIPA/ACTA, but with more politicians on-board. That is worrying because if we don't reach the point this time where serious international copyright reform is on the cards in a way that is both socially acceptable and economically credible, that could be game over for the free Internet as we know it for at least a generation. The wheels of legal systems turn slowly, particularly where international agreements are concerned, and once the lobbyists have got what they want and the popular revolt has died down, we'll be stuck with whatever was left.
- sp332 15y agoMusic piracy has been going on since they copied sheet music with pen & paper in the 17th century (yes, they were called "pirates" all the way back then). You don't need tech know-how to run a photocopier like some of our teachers did when we didn't have enough textbooks. It's not "a few people" with special skills. Also, I need to point out that Copyright is not the only way to make a living. People really will give artists money without a threat of jail time. It's completely unnecessary.
- Silhouette 15y ago> It's not "a few people" with special skills. Not today, but it would be if (for example) content were only available for streaming via end-to-end locked down hardware and possession of any hardware that wasn't authorised for use in the pipeline and duly locked down carried jail time. As I said, if you don't think that's a plausible target for the Big Media lobbyists, or that enough politicians could buy into it to actually pass those laws, you're not paying attention. > Also, I need to point out that Copyright is not the only way to make a living. No, it's not. But the number of people involved in content production who make the kind of money required to fund major projects through non-traditional business models is almost statistically indistinguishable from 0 when you stack those people up against global content production industries as a whole.