9 ms·
> I think we ought to consider a system where the Government or Fed provides the core functionality of “let me put $X in an account so I can use $X in the futur
by pjc50 4y ago
> I think we ought to consider a system where the Government or Fed provides the core functionality of “let me put $X in an account so I can use $X in the future” for free and banks compete based on value added
This is simple, straightforward, and disintermediatory, so I imagine everyone involved will fight to the death to prevent it happening.
- _heimdall 4y agoThere is a real trade-off there when the government has direct access to and control of citizens' bank accounts. The idea that the government would know specifically how much we spend, where we spend it, and could deny transactions sounds pretty distopian to me. With that said, as closely tied our government and the major banks are there might not be much functional difference from power they have today.
- jen20 4y agoIf you use cash, the “government” does not know where you spend it. If you use a credit card, it’s a virtual certainty that they do already.
- _heimdall 4y agoFor cash transactions, I believe anything over $600 is supposed to be reported now. The limit used to be $10k but was raised recently. With credit cards, the government shouldn't know as they shouldn't be involved, but they almost certainly do because overreach. Congress could always pass a law to block that or an individual could sue and claim something similar to illegal search. As soon as the government is the bank there's no way to bifricate the two, the deal is done.
- zamnos 4y ago> The implementation of the Internal Revenue Service's "$600 rule" is being postponed until next year https://www.cnbc.com/amp/select/irs-600-reporting-rule-delayed/ https://www.cnbc.com/amp/select/irs-600-reporting-rule-delay... (From Feb 2023)
- _heimdall 4y agoDidn't realize that got delayed, thanks! Guess that's good for this year but doesn't help long term.
- HideousKojima 4y ago>Congress could always pass a law to block that or an individual could sue and claim something similar to illegal search. Nah, we'd see any lawsuits over violations of such a law get blocked due to standing issues or state secrets privilege, much like the lawsuits over the illegal and unconstitutional surveillance performed by the NSA.
- _heimdall 4y agoWhether the system would allow a new law to protect our rights is a bit of a different issue. Structurally such a law could only exist if the government doesn't already own the bank.
- reaperman 4y agoGovernment knows your credit card transactions not necessarily just due to generic overreach but also specifically "Third party doctrine". Various companies sell your near-realtime transaction data and it's generally available to data brokers and it's not clear why the government shouldn't be able to buy your data from data brokers.
- opportune 4y agoI’m not certain it’s being done for 100% of bills, but it would be easy to track any single bill between being withdrawn from an atm/bank and re-entering one by noting the serial number and account number as it comes and goes. Exchanges will certainly happen between withdrawals and deposits, but still your privacy is only preserved when neither of your counterparties withdraw/deposit the bill
- unethical_ban 4y agoTell me how much harder and less reliable it is to track billions of individual serialized objects over time vs. a database transaction.
- techdragon 4y agoI always just assumed that somewhere in the banknotes lifecycle those serial numbers are all getting written into a database… I kind of assumed that based on examples where the government was able to trace where large amounts of cash had come from and what it got spent on when doing major crime investigations or things like DB Cooper and how confidently they proclaim that none of the cash (that wasn’t “lost” and then found by various searches or the public over the years) was ever spent. I assumed it was probably part of obligatory regulations to do with money laundering or something equivalent and thus they all had to do it.
- Matl 4y ago> The idea that the government would know specifically how much we spend, where we spend it, and could deny transactions sounds pretty distopian to me. Non American here. They already know and/or could trivially find out. There's no more barrier to them finding out now then there would be if there was some new, nominally independent government entity involved. That is to say a very thin wall preventing what you describe. I sometimes get the feeling we oftentimes allow for market absurdities to supposedly prevent the government from doing something that it regularly already does today, just as long as there's a 'business' somewhere in the chain. Americans seem willing to pay more to private business and thus actually part with more of their money than they otherwise would, as long as on paper they're not giving the money to 'the government' see i.e. healthcare.
- _heimdall 4y ago> They already know and/or could trivially find out. 100% agree here. Today the US goverment, I won't attempt to speak towards any other government, has way too much power and ability to collect inflammation in it's citizens. We've allowed the government to assume that powers but we could also take that power away. If the government owns the bank there's literally no way to do that. Healthcare here is a whole other massively broken system. In general yes I think it's a fair generalization that we would prefer to pay extra to avoid large governments, historically at least since we've done a really poor job keeping our federal government small for the last 80 years. It makes sense given our country's history though, and personally I'd rather pay a little more to a corporation than save a few bucks at the expense of living under a much more powerful centralized authority.
- pbz 4y ago> I'd rather pay a little more to a corporation It's hardly "a little more" though. We're spending almost twice as much and get almost half as little back. Objectively speaking the capitalist market has failed in this area. We have to first accept this fact before we can find any solutions. If we keep thinking "government is bad" and "private industry is good" we're only allowing further exploitation and pain; and for what? We need to be data/solution driven.
- karmelapple 4y agoHow about in North Dakota, which had a state-owned bank? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_of_North_Dakota https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_of_North_Dakota
- _heimdall 4y agoAt least in the US, a state-owned bank is a very different animal from a federally owned bank. States don't have the power to control the currency itself, don't control the collection of three-letter agencies, and in general are meant to have more leeway to try new things than the federal government.
- lxgr 4y ago> There is a real trade-off there when the government has direct access to and control of citizens' bank accounts. Narrow banking and central bank accounts for individuals aren’t the same thing. In fact, most CDBC projects see a role for commercial banks as KYC, fraud prevention, user interface etc. providers. – just not money creation.
- sangnoir 4y ago> The idea that the government would know specifically how much we spend, where we spend it, and could deny transactions sounds pretty distopian to me. That boat has sailed. Private enterprises collect spending information[0], associate it with your identity and sell the aggregated data to anyone willing to pay. The FBI is on the record as willing to be pay for this data. This dystopia has the "free market/small government" seal of approval. 0. Which is why every retailer badgers you into joining their rewards program based or your phone number and/or email.
- wintogreen74 4y agoThis is already happening. Banks report all transactions above a very low threshold under various justifications and laws, plus the government is always going to be the front-of-the-line creditor and can trivially find out your entire net worth at will. We could at least look to cut out rent seekers on the baseline services and make banks compete on performance and value-add. As a customer and shareholder of banks I feel like I'm getting ripped off on both ends.
- datavirtue 4y ago...and it would be easier to directly monitor the government and control the bank instead of having a level of indirection like we do now. This level of indirection requires regulators who are always behind because of the extra layer.
- mywittyname 4y ago"The government" already has this level of access. Not only that, but its control extends beyond the country's borders too; the government can seize, freeze or otherwise access the accounts of Americans (and non-Americans) in almost any bank across the globe. The only bank accounts that it can't do this to would be under the control of an even more repressive government (Russia, China, Iran). Most of this information is for sale anyway.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> simple, straightforward, and disintermediatory It requires re-working the financial system from the ground up, and commitment to that new vision, because there isn't a graceful way to ease from fractional reserve to narrow banking or public accounts at the Fed, and there isn't a simple way back to our status quo from it.
- RandomLensman 4y agoFor money storage that existed in some large countries up until the end of the GFC (e.g., German Bundesbank offered some deposits to retail). I don't think that would need much retooling rather than a change in risks for banks to manage. Edit: I think technically the deposits where with the federal finance agency, i.e., lending to the federal republic. Don't think that matters for the discussion here.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> don't think that would need much retooling rather than a change in risks for banks to manage In a crisis, it would make the narrow/public bank the natural place to drain deposits. (Similar to our SIFIs today.) As such, narrow banking would mean the end of commercial checking. That means we need to find non-bank providers of all the asset-side services, from lending to trade finance, banks currently provide. That's the re-tooling.
- RandomLensman 4y agoIt didn't work like that in 2007/8 in Germany. Deposits didn't just all go to the Bundesbank/Finanzagentur. Maybe you need different banks in the mix, e.g., more coops. For lending, some alternatives exist already, same for trade finance. I think the delta to the current state would be surprisingly small.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> didn't work like that in 2007/8 in Germany Do you have a source on the scope of what they did? > some alternatives exist already, same for trade finance. I think the delta to the current state would be surprisingly small The delta is tens of trillions of dollars. By no means insurmountable. But you don't want that changeover happening unexpectedly in a crisis.
- DougN7 4y agoI fear banking would become like government run healthcare or health insurance. I’m not quite sure what it would look like, but it wouldn’t be great.
- opportune 4y agoThe Fed and Gov already have stuff like this (TreasuryDirect), and like some fintech are just thin UX wrappers around ugly consumer bank interfaces or even I-bonds, you could have the same with these accounts. There is no profit motive and it’s a very technically simple offering that the Fed already supports or will soon support with FedNow: I have a table of people and balances, and I only support transactions between the two. If a bank can’t figure out how to compete with 0% interest with no value add to attract deposits, IMO they shouldn’t exist.
- User23 4y agoThe important social function that modern banks perform isn’t attracting depositors, it’s creating deposits AKA originating loans. Regional and local banks are far more likely to originate loans to local residents, especially for unique purposes. If somebody in flyover country wants a loan to start a business, it basically has to be a cookie cutter franchise or a large existing customer for a big coastal syndicate bank to even look at it. This is one reason, although not the only one, why outfits like Dollar General are eating the downscale retail market when it used to be local general stores.
- opportune 4y agoYes, I know that, but why should I as an individual risk my deposits in a bank? Before digital payments took off it was entirely feasible for a regular person to be what we’d now call unbanked or underbanked. I’m pretty sure my grandfather was greatly underbanked well into the 90s and aughts. I’m sure many banked because they didn’t want to keep track of all their cash physically hanging around, but banks had to actually compete against “stuff it under your mattress” by passing on rates and other ways of providing value. The advent of online banking and digital payments added enough value that there was really no reason to continue to be unbanked or underbanked for most people. But IMO banks have begun to take depositors for granted by offering poor interest rates and exposing us to more risk than necessary (certainly more than justifies checking or savings rates). With the recent spat of bank failures roughly coinciding with crypto, which also provides online banking and digital payment functionality, the Fed/banks need to recognize that there is a real risk that depositors will opt back out of traditional banking. I think a shift off the dollar and onto crypto would be much worse (personally, but also for banking) than the Fed offering a path to digital mattress stuffing of the USD, because at least with that they can still influence monetary policy and keep people on the dollar. I also suspect, but have no data, that our shift towards structurally low rates and high asset prices over the last half century was partially influenced by banks’ relative share of the monetary supply increasing so much that too many deposits are stuck chasing yield/credit is too accessible for activities perceived as low risk: so if some deposits shift onto a Fed narrow bank, banks will at least find it easier to loan and offer interest at higher rates. But even beside that, I as an individual should not be obligated to deposit my money into a banking system that gives me poor risk:reward - and when better options exist, I might not. So the banks and Fed better figure out something better than crypto or a fireproof safe.
- gizmo686 4y agoPostal banking. Available in the US between 1911 and 1967. It was mostly killed by the FDIC, which allowed private banks access to what was its competative advantage. There's a proposal to revive the postal banking service in Congress every year or so; but thus far none have gone anywhere.
- maxwell 4y agoHuh, wonder why. Oh yeah, the bipartisan bribes. https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/visa-inc/summary?id=D000029689 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/visa-inc/summary?id=D000029... https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/mastercard-inc/summary?id=D000022099 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/mastercard-inc/summary?id=D... https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/jpmorgan-chase-co/summary?id=D000000103 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/jpmorgan-chase-co/summary?i... https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/bank-of-america/summary?id=D000000090 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/bank-of-america/summary?id=... https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/citigroup-inc/summary?id=d000000071 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/citigroup-inc/summary?id=d0... https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/wells-fargo/summary?id=D000019743 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/wells-fargo/summary?id=D000...
- mrguyorama 4y agoThere's also the very one-sided action to kill the post office entirely. Even with zero bribes, republicans want public services gutted and turned into private profits.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fdr 4y agoIt's not that simple for The Fed or the Federal Government, as they have to take over all the tedious affairs in banking (like KYC, among many smaller tasks), so I suspect they'll be reluctant. But that doesn't mean it would be a bad thing to talk them into it.
- kachnuv_ocasek 4y agoBut they could still allow for narrow banks to exist which would intermediate these “nuisances” while passing through all deposits to Fed reserves.
- rocqua 4y agoThere have been attempts to start a bank that would just do this. The FED refused to give those banks a banking license. If they would give that license, then the 'narrow bank' gets the job of KYC, customer service, and everything else. But the funds remain safe at the FED. Problem is, this takes a lot of money out of the economy if it catches on. That likely will reduce investment, and damage the economy. So regulators dislike narrow banking.
- fdr 4y agoThis sounds to me pretty close to a treasury money market fund, doesn't it? Money market funds are not insured for some nominal amount, but among the most common in practice have significant repurchase agreements with The Fed and hold short-dated treasury debt, but this plus your brokerage it's pretty close to the narrow bank idea. I suppose the Fed could try to make the circle slightly rounder here, but they may look at the hundreds of billions of dollars in such funds, which are by nature extremely "narrow" quasi-banking devices (because they only support a tiny form of maturity transformation, in asset type and term length), and decide "good enough, economic needs of this kind met"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rvnx 4y agoThis is called Digital Euro, it's coming this summer via the ECB