4 ms·
It’s worth pointing out that insofar as the failed subculture is failed, its failure was deliberate. Same thing happened with Native Americans. The playbooks fo
by ethanbond 4y ago
It’s worth pointing out that insofar as the failed subculture is failed, its failure was deliberate. Same thing happened with Native Americans. The playbooks for destroying cultures are centuries old and they’re intended to reap exactly the sort of dysfunction you still see generations down the road.
Doesn’t mean we shouldn’t be addressing the issue head on and talking about it openly, but it’s definitely more complex than the genetic argument that tends to emerge.
- nebula8804 4y agoKnow of any good books documenting these deliberate actions you talk about or are you speaking more generally?
- ethanbond 4y agoI’m sure there are plenty, but a few of the strategies that I’m pointing to: 1. Forbid people from speaking their own languages or practicing their own cultures/religions (slavery) 2. Relocate children to schools of the subjugating culture or prevent them from being educated (happened during slavery) 3. Make drugs and intoxicants widely available (CIA bringing drugs into black neighborhoods) 4. Enslave people 5. Post-slavery, give them fewer rights and a caste-stratified society (Dread Scott) 6. When/where these cultures build wealth, destroy it (Tulsa massacre)
- neurobama 4y agoThis history is important and relevant in the abstract, but what does it tell us about solutions for today's problems? I don't see what Dred Scott tells us about stopping rampant car thefts in Milwaukee. We are where we're at, now how do we improve?
- ethanbond 4y agoNot sure! But one important component of a solution is probably to avoid the thinking that generated or at least perpetuated many of the problems in the first place (i.e. intrinsic racial inferiority). Probably also not by acting like everything is all good or that there’s no agency within these communities.