3 ms·
> But so far this has seemed... pretty orderly? No depositors have been wiped out, no contagion has spread. Making disorder the enemy is something of a distrac
by roenxi 4y ago
> But so far this has seemed... pretty orderly? No depositors have been wiped out, no contagion has spread.
Making disorder the enemy is something of a distraction tactic. General rate of growth matters a lot more and much has been sacrificed in the name of trying to make the market look pretty at the cost of keeping the incentives properly aligned. Disorder is more of a code word for the wealthy and powerful being at risk of losing their social standing. The rest of us should be worried about general wealth and prosperity. Which, I might add, is maximised by the occasional dose of collapse in badly designed systems. Joseph Gentile has been given 2 goes now at wiping out his creditors; there was no need for that - the 2008 bailouts just gave him cover to go and get people wiped out a 2nd time.
The real question now is who is actually eating these losses? Is it old people with pensions? Because while it would be karmic justice to start wiping out elderly investors because they were the ones with political control ignoring all the problems building over the decades, but that would still be a huge problem.
They should have let 2000 or 2008 play out to their natural conclusions to minimise the overall damage. This one is a bunch of people going bankrupt in ways that could easily be predicted a decade ago. These losses have been created by Fed policy. And we'll probably find when the dust settles that they have once again stuffed everything up, there is no reason to believe this time is different. There have been bank crisises to safely assume that this time will not be different unless, miraculously, hindsight shows they changed tack.
- avoutthere 4y ago> it would be karmic justice to start wiping out elderly investors because they were the ones with political control ignoring all the problems building over the decades Are you "ignoring all the problems" of today? Or do you just not have the "political control" to change things? What makes you think that "elderly investors" had more control during their lifetimes?
- mandmandam 4y agoMillenials hold 4.36% of US wealth. Boomers hold 53.2%. Those figures are from 2020 - it's probably gotten worse since. ... And those wealth holders aren't just ignoring the problems of today; they're exacerbating them. Ageism won't solve our problems - all of this is still very much a class issue. But let's not pretend that as a generation, the Boomers didn't fail like no generation has ever failed. And let's not pretend they aren't still blaming the victim.
- astrange 4y ago> Those figures are from 2020 - it's probably gotten worse since. It's gotten better, because boomers are retiring and spending down their assets. …or, of course, dying of covid. Millenials are pretty much on track actually: https://www.stlouisfed.org/institute-for-economic-equity/the-real-state-of-family-wealth/generational-and-age-household-wealth-trends-and-wealth-inequality https://www.stlouisfed.org/institute-for-economic-equity/the... Wealth inequality in the US is also down since 2019 because of wage growth at the low end.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 4y agohttps://arc-anglerfish-washpost-prod-washpost.s3.amazonaws.com/public/ZQ2CUAWWCJD3XHI4B6PDJIURN4.png https://arc-anglerfish-washpost-prod-washpost.s3.amazonaws.c... Baby boomers outnumber other generations, and they successfully used their numbers to bend our political systems to benefit themselves at as they progressed through life. Which I suppose is fine, that's democracy. But as they reach their twilight years and reflect upon the world they're leaving behind, I do hope they take some responsibility for the plights they've created for the younger generations.
- SilverBirch 4y agoI don't buy the argument that allowing maximal loss in 2008 would have been good in a practical sense. Yes, it would have been edifying to watch those bankers who screwed up face their comeuppance. But firstly, the bankers already got the bonuses during the good times and they don't personally own the assets that would go to zero. And secondly the process of unwinding all of that debt and those complex financial instruments in an uncontrolled open market would likely have seen plenty of perfectly good investments go to the wall simply because the market wasn't able to fairly value them. You can't just put the entire economy on hold for 12 months whilst an army of PhDs go through and re-value every single marketable instrument. It's perfectly reasonable for the government to step in and say "We'll back stop this now, but we're going to examine this and put in rules to make sure this can't happen again"- and that's what happened here. The reason JPMorgan can step in is because they have stronger regulations on them that have made them safer than last time.
- roenxi 4y ago> It's perfectly reasonable for the government to step in and say "We'll back stop this now, but we're going to examine this and put in rules to make sure this can't happen again"- and that's what happened here We've just witnessed several of the largest bank failures in history happening this year. In an unexpected turn of events, Bitcoin is proving to be more stable than institutions like First Republic Bank (and Credit Suisse). We'll probably see a few more interesting names before this is through. Run me through this "can't happen again" part. We've had banks for 300 years now and there is a financial crisis every decade or so these days. What is "this"? It seems to be happening quite regularly for something that can't happen again. The government has been all but force-feeding credit into markets for the last decade, that is hardly a strategy to build strong institutions. The US is at serious risk of being overshadowed by nominal Communists. My money is on the pension system bearing the brunt of this crisis. What are the signs of regulatory success that we're supposed to be looking at? They seem to have taken an era of unprecedented prosperity and technological progress and done their best to bring that back to neutral.
- SilverBirch 4y agoWhat are you comparing to though? Are you comparing bitcoin to an equity investment in a single regional bank? Because if so, yeah if you just so happened to pick First Republic Bank and compared it to Bitcoin, Bitcoin has been more stable in the last 6 months. But that's only because you've looked at what happened now, then gone back in time 6 months to select the worst outcome and compared that to bitcoin. If you picked a random regional bank or took an average of banks, they've been more stable than bitcoin - and even then you're talking about an equity investment that is known to have real risk. If you're comparing to the depositors in FRB or CS or whichever bank, their money has been absolutely safe, way more stable than bitcoin - and government guaranteed. >What are the signs of regulatory success that we're supposed to be looking at? That in capitalism, individual companies are going to succeed or fail, and those that invest in them will take the gains or losses, but that the broader system still works. And that's basically what is happening so far. To take your bitcoin example, whenever a crypto company fails, the question is always "Will retail customers get their deposits back" and the answer is... basically always no. That's not how we expect companies to work - the customer deposits are meant to be protected.
- FormerBandmate 4y agoThis is incredibly stupid. Letting just Lehman fail sparked 08 and bankrupted millions of middle class Americans, and banks are always sold after bank failures. The Fed had an extremely similar approach to what you propose in the late 20s, it was called liquidationism. It sparked the Great Depression, which was a terrible tragedy that destroyed millions of people’s lives, and through global aftereffects is arguably one of the main causes of Hitler’s rise to power. Destroying the economy is very bad
- effingwewt 4y ago[flagged]
- selimthegrim 4y agoRich industrialists literally put Hitler in power and you’re sitting around saying he was making war on the banks
- rendall 4y ago> through global aftereffects is arguably one of the main causes of Hitler’s rise to power By the time of Hitler's rise, hyper inflation was over and German economy was stable and beginning to prosper. Here is one paper covering it https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/businessreview/2021/10/19/debunking-the-idea-that-interwar-hyperinflation-in-germany-led-to-the-rise-of-the-nazi-party/ https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/businessreview/2021/10/19/debunking-...
- javanissen 4y agoHyperinflation isn’t the cited issue above - it’s the deflationary period from 1929-1932, which aligns quite well with the rise of the Nazi party. Both the GFC and Great Depression were deflationary.
- Rury 4y agoYes, it correlates, but deflation is not really the cause behind the rise of the Nazi party. Did you ever wonder why Hitler hated jews so much? Why antisemitism became very popular? Let me give you a hint, it had to do with banks, who ran them, and who owned almost all the wealth, along with a decade of economic woes for most folks. According to Arthur Bryant the British court historian writing in Unfinished Victory (1940 pp. 136-144): "even in November 1938, after five years of anti-Semitic legislation and persecution, they still owned, according to the Times correspondent in Berlin, something like a third of the real property in the Reich. Most of it came into their hands during the inflation.."