3 ms·
Sorites paradox; in complex systems - especially ones with feedback - knowing the tipping point trigger isn't very useful. Traffic jams can be caused by densit
by barrkel 15y ago
Sorites paradox; in complex systems - especially ones with feedback - knowing the tipping point trigger isn't very useful.
Traffic jams can be caused by density of traffic. A slight variation in speeds cascades through human delay in reaction, causing a longitudinal wave to ripple backwards through the traffic. If the amplitude of the wave gets high enough, sections of traffic will periodically reach a standstill while the wave works its way through.
There's no meaningful trigger here. Decomposing the whole into parts won't solve the problem. If you didn't know that traffic density causes jams, looking into the root cause would seem mysterious, because the chaotic behaviour that gives rise to the initial perturbation is essentially unimportant. It's the interaction between the parts that matters, not the "trigger".
And even when you've "solved" this by building more and wider roads to spread the density, you find a different level of homeostasis; better transport infrastructure like roads encourages people to take more journeys, live further apart with more space, further away from work and play, leading to more traffic again.
Sometimes, when solving a problem, looking inwards, to parts, to triggers, to root causes, isn't the right approach; looking outwards, to the holistic whole, running experiments and simulations, creating new theories, is better. But this is a synthetic approach, not an analytic one driven by 5 Whys.