4 ms·
> "Tribler" is a peer-to-peer file-sharing client that is completely decentralized. "The only way to take it down is to take the Internet down," the software’s
by Silhouette 15y ago
> "Tribler" is a peer-to-peer file-sharing client that is completely decentralized. "The only way to take it down is to take the Internet down," the software’s creator says.
Which is a pretty f--king stupid thing to say at a time when we are trying to avoid draconian, Big-Media-backed legal shenanigans like SOPA/PIPA and ACTA.
Are they trying to demonstrate that the only way to enforce copyright law really is to monitor everyone's communications 24/7, assume that anyone who uses encryption to an unrecognised/unauthorised host an infringer, and ruthlessly cut off Internet access to any such person? Because anyone who thinks such a scenario is unrealistic hasn't been paying attention.
People who make and advertise file sharing tools for the obvious purpose of conducting illegal activity are the enemy of those of us who want to have such tools for legitimate purposes and of those of us who want to have the content we honestly pay for in unrestricted formats that don't get in the way of us enjoying them.
<skeptic>Also, with my technical hat on, how exactly does this work? I'm betting you aren't really as isolated and decentralised as you think you are, because, well, you can't be off the network and yet still be on the network. The article says it's a BitTorrent client, so surely someone is seeding something somewhere.</skeptic>
- Karunamon 15y ago>People who make and advertise file sharing tools for the obvious purpose of conducting illegal activity Except that's not what Tribler is. If you can't think of legitimate reasons for a decentralized, censorship-proof file sharing network that don't violate the law, I daresay your imagination is broken...
- skymt 15y agoGo right ahead. Name some uses for a censorship-resistant network that doesn't violate the law of the country in question. (It doesn't count if the use merely breaks a law you dislike, as in Chinese or Iranian suppression of dissidents.)
- icebraining 15y agoDistributing personal files without being subjected to fraudulent DMCA takedowns, like the ones that Warner Bros sent to any file containing the string "the box".
- Karunamon 15y ago>Name some uses for a censorship-resistant network that doesn't violate the law of the country in question. Anything and everything that isn't otherwise proven beyond a shadow of a doubt to be illegal in a court of law.
- Silhouette 15y ago> Except that's not what Tribler is. Perhaps not, but this story is running under the headline "Unstoppable file-sharing network 'Tribler' spells trouble for copyright holders". What is the guy about to vote on ACTA going to think?
- praptak 15y agoYou cannot have such tools and have people only use them for legitimate purposes. Copyright and privacy of communication are mutually exclusive; if not now then soon. The copyright lobby knows this and they won't stop because of our promise to be nice.
- Silhouette 15y ago> The copyright lobby knows this and they won't stop because of our promise to be nice. The copyright lobby aren't the problem here. We pretty much know where they stand. However, for the first time in several years, there is enough debate about this area for politicians who actually make laws to sit up and take notice. Right now, Big Media are losing the debate. As long as that continues to be the case and the politicans won't pass their lobbyist-led draconian laws, they can bleat as much as they like and no-one needs to care. If that changes, if the politicians see obvious piracy advocacy as the reason these tools exist (and let's be honest, most of them wouldn't look for or possibly even understand the more legitimate uses of the same technologies) then the political winds could change and all those crazy laws will be going back on the agenda. I don't know about you, but if that happens, I for one won't be grateful to the people who've been promoting censorship-proof P2P tech as a piracy tool.
- sp332 15y agoAre they trying to demonstrate that the only way to enforce copyright law really is to monitor everyone's communications 24/7, assume that anyone who uses encryption to an unrecognised/unauthorised host an infringer, and ruthlessly cut off Internet access to any such person? Yes. Because it's true. You can't legislate morality, and you can't prop up business models that require people to behave contrary to their nature. Even if you take the internet away, people will still trade CDs full of MP3s. If you take away all digital technology, people will trade mixtapes. If you cut people's hands off, they'll still sing "Happy Birthday" to each other. You can't stop it. Copyright enforcement is completely infeasible.
- Silhouette 15y ago> You can't legislate morality, and you can't prop up business models that require people to behave contrary to their nature. That cuts both ways. Expecting the same quantity and quality of work to enjoy without a system that compensates the people who worked hard to produce it is also expecting something contrary to human nature. You can get so far with volunteer works, but ultimately we've all got rent to pay/kids to feed/etc. > Copyright enforcement is completely infeasible. Of course it's not. Sure, there will always be a few people who know enough to work around it. And sure, you can always exploit the analogue hole by literally recording poor quality video off your computer screen with an old camcorder or something similar if you've got such kit lying around. But you could block the overwhelming majority of copyright infringement pretty easily if you were willing to impose severe enough restrictions and to make examples of those who tried to work around those restrictions. It's just that most of us really wouldn't like the collateral damage that such policies would cause.
- icebraining 15y agoThat cuts both ways. Expecting the same quantity and quality of work to enjoy without a system that compensates the people who worked hard to produce it is also expecting something contrary to human nature. You can get so far with volunteer works, but ultimately we've all got rent to pay/kids to feed/etc. Oh, the same old fallacy. How does that fit in with the studies that shows that "pirates" buy a lot[1], with the year over year MPAA record profits[2] or with a game company getting $1000000 before the game was even made? [1]: http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20110727/16233815292/another-day-another-study-that-says-pirates-are-best-customers-this-time-hadopi.shtml http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20110727/16233815292/anothe... http://news.cnet.com/2100-1023-898813.html http://news.cnet.com/2100-1023-898813.html [2]: http://www.zeropaid.com/news/92692/piracy-who-mpaa-celebrates-5th-consecutive-year-of-record-profits/ http://www.zeropaid.com/news/92692/piracy-who-mpaa-celebrate...