5 ms·
Advanced Amiga Architecture (1992)
- transfire 4y agoShame.
- scheeseman486 4y agoNot really. It might have had some relevance for a year if released in 93, but 94-95 saw a rapid increase in CPU power which obsoleted the use of 2D accelerated graphics for PC games. This chip wouldn't have saved Amiga, it's just another choice that sealed their fate.
- rasz 4y ago1993 with bitplane graphics and Doom around the corner, dead in the water.
- Aleklart 4y agoamiga could have 3d accelerator at that point and much more cpu performance
- scheeseman486 4y agoThere's a lot of reasons Amiga/Commodore failed, but I think the core issue is that they were creating computers, but not ecosystems. No one wanted to do a full reset on their software again, something 80s computing was rife with. PCs insulated themselves from this with hardware variability being baked in the moment PC clones appeared on the market forcing the software market to bake compatibility in by design (the bet on x86 was also a smart one). Macintosh managed to survive the transition by forcing developers to use abstractions, making a 68k>PPC emulation layer more viable. There was no pathway for Amiga to accomplish this. So much software is direct to metal that the only feasible way to achieve performant backwards compatibility would be to include a whole OG Amiga in whatever PPC Amiga they could cook up. Expensive in an environment of 486+VGA IBM PC compatible clones that work with existing software but even faster. Not to say this was the thing that killed them, but it would have been even if everything else was going great.
- actionfromafar 4y agoThis is just layers on layers of hypothetical. One could just as easily argue that since they controlled the architecture vertically, they could have virtualized the whole platform. (Exactly like how Sony made PS2 compatible with with PS1, and PS3 compatible with PS2.)
- fredoralive 4y agoSony's backwards comparability was nearer to the "include the old chips in the new system" approach that a hypothetical next Amiga would probably have to use, at least for the immediate previous generation (PS1 on PS3 is emulation AFAIK[1]). It's not a good sign for that approach that the PS2 chips (and compatibility) were dropped pretty much immediately once Sony realised they needed to get PS3 costs down. [1] I think some download games use a PS2 emulator on PS3, but that's not available in a general purpose "put any disc in console" mode.
- actionfromafar 4y agoYes sure whatever, I’m just saying Amiga had an insane fanbase willing to throw money around, but Commodore declined.
- scheeseman486 4y agoSony could pull that off due to their licensing model allowing hardware sold at a loss, being a massive conglomerate sitting in many different industry also helped. There was no pathway for Amiga to do this, they had vertical integration but not the control over developers Apple had nor the licensing income console manufacturers had. Commodore had it's fans (well, not of Commodore so much as the Amiga itself) and a bunch of niche use cases in the video production industry, but that wouldn't have been enough to sustain the R&D required to be competitive with the rest of the industry. By 1993 a lot of the industry was working on consumer targeted 3D acceleration and here's Commodore making some 2D chip.
- flohofwoe 4y agoThat new chipset would have a chunky pixel format similar to mode13h (1 byte per pixel, indexing a color palette - and a lot of other chunky pixel formats from 4 pixels per byte up to 3 bytes per pixel). There are even hardware-compressed pixel formats mentioned (on page 6) which provide 6x and 12x data compression, which looks quite similar to today's block-compressed texture formats (more details are on page 123). (also 68030 and 68040 CPUs were still competitive with 386 and 486)
- doener 4y agoVia http://amiga-news.de/en/news/AN-2023-04-00114-EN.html http://amiga-news.de/en/news/AN-2023-04-00114-EN.html
- rodgerd 4y agoIt's interesting to me that one of the big ideas that made the Amiga different was having a unified memory (the chip memory) where the specialised processors and CPU had equal access; it's now very mainstream in the gaming arena, with the XBox and PlayStation both using AMD processors that do just that.
- Veliladon 4y agoIt's pretty different compared to the Amiga. The Amiga flipped the bus between CPU and chipset every cycle and the CPU could only access chip RAM every 1/2 cycles. No matter how little the chipset was doing, the CPU could only access RAM half the time. The Xbox/PS5 SoCs have both the CPU and GPU behind the memory controller so even under load the CPU will still have access to its full amount of memory bandwidth.
- snvzz 4y ago>No matter how little the chipset was doing, the CPU could only access RAM half the time. Only applicable to CHIP RAM. CPU could access FAST RAM, the default allocation target, all the time. It also was not as simple as odd/even, although there's sense to the simplification. 68000's design meant it could ultimately only access RAM every other cycle, thus it was sensible to aim for that as the default. Higher 68000 models did not have that restriction. And even the original chipset also wasn't limited to half the cycles. This was only true of the default video mode (4 color "hires", 640 pixels wide). The blitter also had a flag (BITHOG) that allowed it to use full DMA, stealing cycles from the CPU.
- rasz 4y ago>Only applicable to CHIP RAM. CPU could access FAST RAM, the default allocation target, all the time. "default" haha. Afaik the only Amiga that ever shipping with fast ram was A4000. It was introduced at $4600 in 1992. In 1993 it was down to $2500, same price ARL was selling Pentium 60MHz system with 8MB ram.
- 4y ago
- AndrewStephens 4y agoI would have killed to have access to this document at the time. Amiga documentation was very hard to come by in New Zealand.
- 13of40 4y agoPlus one for this. It was easier to get people to mail me computer books from Europe than to buy them in 1990s rural Oregon.
- jerrysievert 4y agodon't worry, it was almost just as difficult in non-rural areas in Oregon as well at the time. eventually, there was one amiga dealership in clackamas, which is I guess one more than, say, bend had, but I still never managed to make it there before they eventually closed.
- OnlyMortal 4y agoIt was in the UK too. I mostly ended up disassembling demos and using ST books for source code - non-GEM - like “how to do vector graphics with pre-made sin/tan tables”
- jdswain 4y agoI used to get Byte magazine back then. The cover date was three months in the past by the time I got it. Before the internet the News section was still relevant even after three months. Some books I ordered took 6 months if they arrived at all. This was Invercargill, New Zealand in the 80's.
- mjg59 4y agoFor context: this document describes the design goals for the successor chipset to the AGA chipset shipped in the Amiga 1200 and 4000. If you watch the Deathbed Vigil video of the last day at Commodore there's a brief shot of a prototype, but this never made it to production before Commodore folded.
- gbraad 4y agoThe document was published by Dave Haynie himself, who worked on the design and is also the producer of the Deathbed Vigil video. Haynie was one of the main hardware engineers for later models of the Amiga.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoIt's my understanding that AAA was supposed to be the successor to ECS, but business problems forced the creation of AGA, a stop-gap (so they thought) successor since ECS was rapidly becoming too out-of-date to compete with PCs. Commodore never resolved its business problems and the rest is history.
- snvzz 4y agoFurthermore, Ranger, not ECS, was supposed to be the successor of OCS, with much higher specs. Ranger was even finished and ready to go, but CBM management decided against it. It would have shipped around 1988. Management culture of overruling architects was one of many reasons CBM went to hell.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoIn Commodore's defense, Ranger needed (at the time) very expensive VRAM to work, and would have made Ranger-equipped Amigas prohibitively expensive.
- snvzz 4y agoThat was CBM's argument line. CBM didn't see value in having the best machine, or being first to market.
- natas 4y agoI never owned an amiga until very recently, I owned an Atari back in the days, 30 years later now I understood one thing: Amiga/Commodore had the best engineers Atari had the best business folks.
- selcuka 4y ago> Amiga/Commodore had the best engineers Atari had the best business folks. It's debatable as it was different in the 8-bit area. A total of ~2 million Atari 8-bit computers [1] were sold as compared to the 12.5 - 17 million figure for the Commodore 64 [2] only. Arguably Atari 800XL was engineered better [3] (faster, better graphics, worse sound). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atari_8-bit_family https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atari_8-bit_family [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodore_64 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodore_64 [3] https://dfarq.homeip.net/atari-800-vs-commodore-64/ https://dfarq.homeip.net/atari-800-vs-commodore-64/
- pkaye 4y agoI feel like Commodore 64 had better sprites than the Atari 8-bit.
- ihatepython 4y agoThe Commodore 64 also had better sprites than the Amiga. Jay Miner didn't really like hardware sprites. I think he was wrong about this.
- tuukkah 4y agoOn the other hand, you had a lot of flexibility and options both with what you did with the available hardware sprites (e.g. some games drew backgrounds using sprite hardware!) and how you could manage without them (using blitter objects instead).
- ihatepython 4y ago
- richrichardsson 4y agoWould this document be enough to be able to create an AAA Amiga in FPGA?
- icedchai 4y agoTake a look at the Vampire: http://www.apollo-computer.com/v4standalone.php http://www.apollo-computer.com/v4standalone.php
- bb88 4y agoHere's a youtube video review. If I were going to retro game on the Amiga I would seriously take a look at buying one. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YRr74v2tPzM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YRr74v2tPzM
- snvzz 4y agoI'd suggest a miSTer instead. Minimig is open hardware, which is the way to go.
- mdfboxes001 4y ago[flagged]
- flohofwoe 4y agoThe pixel format description on page 6 still makes my mouth water: - bitmapped formats up to 16 bitplanes - paletted chunky formats for 2/4/8 bits per pixel, and 16/24 bits per pixel without color palette - block-compressed pixel formats with 12x and 6x compression ratio (looks quite similar to modern hardware-compressed texture formats used in 3D rendering - more details on page 123)