3 ms·
We already seen a lot of AI generated art recently. But these were just pictures. What about AI generated music? There are substantial differences between music
by cubefox 4y ago
We already seen a lot of AI generated art recently. But these were just pictures. What about AI generated music? There are substantial differences between music and pictures:
- For artistic pictures there is no pop. They do not have nearly the same popularity as music.
- Music follows changing fashions and even progress of some sort. Each time period (e.g. decade) comes with distinctive music styles, and while there are some revivals, usually they do not repeat. Artistic pictures are much more static in comparison, at least in the last few decades. Pictures are influenced by available tools (e.g. Photoshop and graphic tablets), but a painting today doesn't look markedly different from a painting 30 years ago.
Since music follows fashions, just imitating past music genres may not be as popular as it is popular to imitate existing art styles with Stable Diffusion and Midjourney. But imitation is exactly what current generative models do. Which may ultimately limit the popularity of fully AI generated songs created by amateurs. Musicians may still have an edge by using AI tools to create new music styles.
- bazeblackwood 4y agoWhile I agree that art has become more static since the dawn of the internet, the same can definitely be said about music, particularly pop music, which hasn't advanced significantly since the 2000s. However in various corners, sampling and synthesis have advanced by leaps and strides over the past decade. Also if you're just limiting visual art to painting, I think you're skipping over an entire era of installation-based and generative art (not necessarily machine learning-based) that has only recently flourished. And just to touch on your first point, "pop art" has been a term since the 50s. It overlaps pretty significantly with the visual style of comic books, which are most prominent in animated features and video games today. Corporate art similarly has its own style (think those flat diverse figures with bright colors). I'm not even sure how one would start to compare the relative "popularity" of these two domains, let alone determine that "music" is more popular than "art".
- cubefox 4y agoHm... Regarding the last sentence: Many people pay for Spotify, and in the past they paid even more for records and CDs, but people rarely pay for pictures, if ever. Maybe once to decorate their new flat. People also go to concerts of their favorite musicians, while they basically never visit art exhibitions.