3 ms·
We already see a lot of this "rise of the long tail", even without AI. Through the rise of individualized music streaming and the demise of the relatively few r
by cubefox 4y ago
We already see a lot of this "rise of the long tail", even without AI. Through the rise of individualized music streaming and the demise of the relatively few radio and music TV stations, there is much more fragmentation now than before the Web.
This trend will only be further amplified by a surge of AI enhanced music, as Seth Godin argues. And after that, fully AI generated music will be the final nail in the coffin of Pop. Everything will be highly individualized.
We may still occasionally have songs going viral, but those will be only short flashes of popularity, nothing that lasts for weeks or even months, and they will be forgotten quickly, lost in the flood.
- Thlom 4y agoIn this future, what is the point of music at all? Music used to be a communal thing. First it was songs around the camp fire, slave music, clubs. We have always experienced music together. Even after Spotify we have shared our favorite songs and playlists. We still go to concerts. But if no one has the same frame of reference anymore and all music is atomized and personalized. And nothing means anything anymore. What’s the point? Just background noise?
- cubefox 4y agoYeah, I think increased fragmentation already has significantly moved music from the communal aspect to the pleasant noise aspect.
- HKH2 4y ago> We have always experienced music together. That hasn't been true since at least gramophones. > And nothing means anything anymore. What’s the point? Just background noise? I'm gathering that you generally don't listen to purely instrumental music. Ultimately the beauty in harmonies or a certain rhythm etc. is ineffable (you judge words and lyrics with another part of your brain). Can you enjoy visual art without sharing it? Can you enjoy food without sharing it?
- HKH2 4y ago> We may still occasionally have songs going viral, but those will be only short flashes of popularity, nothing that lasts for weeks or even months, and they will be forgotten quickly, lost in the flood. Good. The latest is not necessarily the best, and there is plenty of lost treasure just waiting to be found.
- cubefox 4y agoOnly you will consider it a treasure. Other people will not care. Everyone will have their own personal favorites, at which point they can't even be called treasures.
- HKH2 4y agoI doubt that taste is that arbitrary. Regardless, do you think our value systems are that dependent on what other people think? Do I really need someone else to confirm that something tastes great or looks great? I guess in the future extraverts won't listen to music.
- cubefox 4y agoFamous songs have been very important culturally. They provide some common ground, a shared experience, something which creates a sense of community. This may go away with AI, and arguably already has, to some extent, due to individualized streaming.
- HKH2 4y agoYes, that dictatorial approach to music has already begun to disappear. Our appreciation for music will not disappear. It is time for democratised music.