4 ms·
When did republicans succeed in doing any of those things? The filibuster prevents any of these things from being more than rhetoric.
by rayiner 4y ago
When did republicans succeed in doing any of those things? The filibuster prevents any of these things from being more than rhetoric.
- roflyear 4y agoThey succeeded in preventing judges from being appointed. Trump weakened regulatory authorities more than any other president.
- rayiner 4y agoObama appointed more federal judges than Bush: https://www.politico.com/story/2014/04/barack-obama-george-w-bush-judge-confirmations-105388 https://www.politico.com/story/2014/04/barack-obama-george-w... (As of April 2014: “Over the course of his presidency so far, Obama has nominated 301 judges and gotten 237 confirmed. By this point in his presidency, Bush had nominated 267 judges and had 234 of them confirmed.”). Remember that Democrats controlled the Senate for all but the last two years of the Obama presidency. Republicans weren’t in much of a position to block his judicial appointments. There is of course Garland, a rare show of GOP competence. But even for the Supreme Court judicial appointments are contentious. Kennedy was Reagan’s third pick for that seat. He went on to be a liberal squish that voted to uphold Roe, etc.
- ethanbond 4y agoI would bet that if the filibuster could be depended on to prevent movement on these issues, you wouldn’t see close to $15 billion going into federal election campaigns. Anyway, McConnell successfully blocked pretty much all Obama lower court judge appointments, causing huge huge backlogs in the justice system nationwide and allowing GOP to later install people who are e.g. trying to make the abortion pill illegal. Our government HAS been changing pretty radically deep down in the bureaucracy. The justice system and election boards are extremely ripe for non-filibuster-able overhaul.
- rayiner 4y agoYou don’t have to make things up. You can just look at agency budgets to see if any GOP president was able to make meaningful cuts in the federal bureaucracy. Remember that democrats controlled the House through Reagan’s entire presidency. The GOP did succeed in overturning Roe. Overturning a precedent that was baseless to begin with and which by the end Democrats wouldn’t even defend on the merits isn’t exactly what I’d call a major victory.
- ethanbond 4y agoIs budget size the singular metric by which government power and capability is measured? Lack of success (and, frankly, probably authentic desire) in one dimension is not evidence of lack of success or desire in another dimension. Government power is not as simple as “more dollar = more powerful.” https://youtu.be/mtPgUrVPXeI https://youtu.be/mtPgUrVPXeI
- rayiner 4y agoWhy would they have a “lack of authentic desire?” Over 90% of federal employees are democrats: https://www.govexec.com/pay-benefits/2016/10/federal-employees-are-donating-almost-exclusively-hillary-clinton/132667 https://www.govexec.com/pay-benefits/2016/10/federal-employe.... These are people who (deeply) believe in the missions of these agencies. If democrats continue to control agencies whose budgets are undiminished, what explains the “lack of success” that you assert exists? It’s like blaming crime waves on “defund the police.” There are discrete measures you can point to that were adopted, like bail reform, that has had some effect. But in general, it was more rhetoric than something which actually happened.
- ethanbond 4y ago“Lack of authentic desire” is referring to the GOP’s lack of authentic desire to reduce government spending. They wish to disrupt Dem agendas and to prevent money from going to Dem areas (made abhorrently obvious every single time a disaster strikes a blue area), but they’re not all that interested in reducing spending itself beyond paying lip service — so no, you wouldn’t expect to see budgets to go down. This doesn’t mean govt capability is left untouched though, because capability is not derived monocausally from budget.