4 ms·
Are Blue Checks Uncool Now?
- renewiltord 4y agoElon is now trying the classic trick that big universities do: mix the rich and the notable in a way that the former can claim to be the latter. It'll be interesting to see. For my part, the most embarrassing thing is watching people fall over themselves claiming they didn't pay for their checkmark. But it is quite clear that among the set of people who cared about blue checks, they're no longer valuable.
- engineer_22 4y agoBlue check costs less than a subscription to the NYT. Hardly a marker of wealth?
- tehbeard 4y agoYou seem to be taking the analogy literally. It's more the muddying of blue checks of "notable people" with "paid so you can hear their weird terminally online rants".
- engineer_22 4y agoWhat?
- phailhaus 4y ago> the most embarrassing thing is watching people fall over themselves claiming they didn't pay for their checkmark This hasn't made sense to me. Isn't it more embarrassing that Musk is forcing the blue checkmark on people in order to make it seem more popular? Users aren't buying, and he's trying to astroturf support for it.
- renewiltord 4y agoNah, the endless stuff like this https://twitter.com/mattyglesias/status/1652784194232414209?s=20 https://twitter.com/mattyglesias/status/1652784194232414209?... just diminishes people so much. By comparison, I don't actively choose to follow Twitter product changes so I don't care about them in that way.
- hgsgm 4y agoHow does correcting a lie diminish the person making the correction?
- renewiltord 4y agoWhen the lie is one of no consequence and it is given disproportionate reaction, I think lesser of the person who is spending their time on it. That's just how it is with me. I think it's probably the common view.
- phailhaus 4y agoWhat's the "disproportionate reaction"? He literally says "Not a huge deal, but dishonest". And it's true: Twitter lied. Are you saying that pointing it out is unreasonable? There's this weird narrative going around that people are "freaking out" about Musk paying for their blue check, and it's totally made up. The real reaction is just confusion. Who's ever heard of a CEO so desperate that he pays to make his subscription service look more popular?
- renewiltord 4y agoAh you have to follow Matt Yglesias to know. He's been on this for weeks. It's fine. Fortunately, Twitter is exactly the technology for me: I unfollowed him and we're both rid of each other.
- barnabee 4y agoThey were always uncool. At best the blue check was useful at times (“this really is the CEO of BigCo”), but people who think they have “status” on Twitter have always been the worst of it. However, now, the conflation of paid features and the blue check makes me reticent to pay Twitter for features I want because it’s bundled with so-called status I don’t.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoWas it? It certainly seemed cool for many years. You only had to look at how much fanbases loved to see their favourite x get verified "at last". Not every community drags rising stars down by their ankles and instead celebrates success. Especially when you consider that their favourite x would now see supposedly well-deserved placement in the algorithm without spending on ads, and what's good for their favourite x is good for them as a trickledown effect, whether that's content, better products, or more art. Success definitely seemed cool to consumers at the time rather than the old mentality of calling them "sellouts" in years prior. It usually meant decent press coverage, notability in some way (thus impersonation was damaging), or you'd hit 50 IMDb credits. I do however agree that the current implementation of blue checks is absolutely meaningless and lends credibility to random people, as such, I don't browse Twitter anymore as the replies to tweets are full of "experts" claiming x without sources, but the blue check seems to convince a lot of people in terms of the weight of their argument if the stats on their tweets are anything to go by.
- ecshafer 4y agoBlue checks were definitely uncool. Maybe people felt it showed they were serious or famous, but that’s always been uncool as well. “Twitter blue check” is used in a derogatory manner for someone that is self important and not a free thinker, and has been for years now.
- phailhaus 4y ago> I do however agree that the current implementation of blue checks is absolutely meaningless and lends credibility to random people This is the crux of it: anyone get get one now. It no longer means you are verified or a notable person, it now only means you bought the Twitter Blue subscription!
- bbstats 4y agoYes
- nitwit005 4y agoThe rare question mark headline where the answer is yes.
- rayiner 4y ago“Uncool?” Are the folks at the New York Times teenagers?
- ridgitdigit 4y ago[flagged]
- tptacek 4y agoSocial status is literally the stated premise of the new blue check.
- humanpotato 4y agoYes. Obviously. A more insightful question is "were they ever cool?" It's hard to think of any company or figure, before or after the Twitter purchase, where them gaining a blue check made them "cool", or even fractionally moreso.
- prepend 4y agoTwitter could have attempted a true reputation system that would help me (I want to see people who people I follow have endorsed, that would be useful). Instead they did something that was kind of confusing and not helpful. Twitter didn’t have a systematic way of being “significant” so it would just kind of be haphazardly applied. Lebron James is famous, but he is known already so doesn’t need a blue check. (Just have an ama verification image somewhere in profile) It was all the other seemingly random people that had blue check marks that meant nothing to me.
- kevinmchugh 4y agoThe check mark was useful for differentiating LeBron from fake, parody LeBron accounts. I don't click through to every account retweeted onto my feed, so having a piece of UI on every tweet makes it easy to see that it's not a parody. That's very useful. Subreddits often attach flair to notable posters.
- prepend 4y agoI never found it useful though as I have other means for authenticating accounts. I would unfollow people who are dumb enough to retweet a fake lebron so it’s very unlikely fake lebron would end up in my feed.
- kevinmchugh 4y agoThe people I follow were not fooled, they were laughing at parody accounts. The risk is that 1) I'm not verifying every account that gets retweeted onto my feed and 2) I have an imperfect overlap of knowledge with the people I follow. So a subtle parody could go right over my head.
- rchaud 4y agoBlue checks for accounts that aren't public figures/corporate accounts, were effectively medals awarded for playing the Twitter game well. Paying for that medal dilutes its value to almost nothing. It also changes the incentives for those that pay, vs those who received the status from Twitter directly. The fact that Stephen King and Lebron James were 'gifted' paid blue checks after publicly rejecting them kinda says it all: it's not about democratizing reach, it's a pay-to-play scheme, but the actual popular kids aren't paying a cent. If you want some evidence, take a look at the types of accounts that have the "paid for" checkmark. The majority of them are shilling courses, AI, crypto, MLMs or conspiracies.
- iamnotamouse 4y agoJournalists were always the most annoying proponents of the old blue check system. Where it worked well was letting people check someone claiming to be a public figure really did represent that figure. But then journalists, who got the check as a matter of course by their employment, started treating it as a mark of credibility and demanding people they didn't like be stripped of their check. I never trusted blue checks. I would regularly see fake accounts in the pre-Musk days and I regularly see fake accounts today. But I do take pleasure in the wounded egos caused by the new system.
- viraptor 4y ago> [journalists started] demanding people they didn't like be stripped of their check. Got some examples?
- d23 4y ago> But then journalists, who got the check as a matter of course by their employment, started treating it as a mark of credibility and demanding people they didn't like be stripped of their check. Never once saw any of this.
- pornel 4y agoIt's hilarious that Twitter's blue checkmarks drama is playing out exactly like Dr. Seuss' Sneetches: https://youtu.be/qPhOZzsi_6Q https://youtu.be/qPhOZzsi_6Q
- bavell 4y agoBrilliant. Thank you. Now get off my beach!
- jdkee 4y agoObligatory. https://twitter.com/paulkrugman/status/1649926598479544321 https://twitter.com/paulkrugman/status/1649926598479544321
- i-use-nixos-btw 4y agoThey’ve changed meaning, but companies do that all the time - especially under new leadership. Twitter has a huge user base and huge financial problems. If the plan is to FINALLY leverage the former to solve the latter then good on them. Turning blue check into a paid service with features seems reasonable to me. I have no incentive to be prioritised in threads or be seen by more people: I’m not trying to sell services, or bring people to my platform to make some ad revenue, etc. For those that do, it makes sense, and I feel sorry for the people that are torn between a cheap way of getting exposure and a crowd of bullies who mock them for it. It also makes sense that people with large followings get it for free, because they’re contributing to the platform. I saw people comparing their free subscription without consent to “r*pe” and, well, there’s no reasoning with that kind of lunatic. OTOH it’s extremely funny to see blue check accounts with 12 followers, especially ones that have been active for years and just post photos of their dog every few days. WHAT WERE THEY THINKING? WHY ARE THEY PAYING IT MAKES NO SENSE
- whoknowswhat11 4y agoAs someone who initially paid for a blue check the idea was appealing to increase signal vs noise, I detested all the scam / spam comments and posts. I didn’t understand the rush to remove checks for existing notable accounts - and then forcing checks on folks and claiming they were paying is absolutely pathetic. I share this because I was part of target market and was open to paying. If I cancelled mine I’ve got to imagine others will too - be interesting to get some data
- blueboo 4y agoNot only are they uncool but paid-checks should be (and often are) blocked on sight if you want a much improved Twitter experience. Sorry if you convinced yourself your good-faith self-promotion could use a boost. (@BlockTheBlue had twice the followers that Blue had paying subscribers when it was blocked.)