4 ms·
When I saw the reference to conic sections right from the start I felt a familiar cloud settling over my mind. Without telling me how orbiting bodies (or the So
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
When I saw the reference to conic sections right from the start I felt a familiar cloud settling over my mind. Without telling me how orbiting bodies (or the Solar System as an example) are like a cone, I find even the mention of conic sections to be tangential at best (perhaps distracting at worst?).
I got off the rails a bit staring at the diagram. A circle is of course a very specific case of an ellipse — seems off-topic to even include that specificity except for the fact that everyone does include it in a conic section diagram.
A parabola looks like another very-much edge case where the slice has to be exactly parallel to a line running the length of the cone. Not as steep and it is instead a very long ellipse. Steeper and it stays within the cone all the way down to infinity — a hyperbola, I guess. Or is it only a hyperbola when the slice is exactly vertical? (The diagram has no response.)
It looks like if I read the text some of these are explained. Maybe I'm a picture-book kind of guy.
But then there are all the edge cases one can imagine if the slice goes through the very vertex of the cone. Leaving those possibilities on the table without explanation also leaves my mind wandering, probably derailed from the original intent of the discussion....
Maybe I'm overthinking it, ha ha.
- adastra22 4y agoYou are overthinking it. Conic sections are critical to the math here, and the difference between elliptical and hyperbolic orbits is the difference between capture and slingshot.
- PaulHoule 4y agoPersonally I’ve seen a privileging of geometry over algebra that leads people in the wrong direction. Who cares what you can do with a straightedge and compasss? Based on what we know now the ‘conic sections’ would better be called the ‘gravitational curves’ or something like that.
- adastra22 4y agoPeople learn in different ways. Abstract equations make no sense to me, but if I see a little picture of conic sections, it makes perfect sense to me. Because I'm a visual thinker with a strong geometric intuition. The pieces are there for the people who need it.
- tonyarkles 4y agoIt's funny... I'm almost 40, and I'm pretty sure I must have missed the day in high school math where Conic Sections were described this way. A couple of months ago I saw an almost identical diagram and had this "aha!!!" moment. I've worked with the abstract equations my entire career and have had no problem with it, but the visual aid really helped understand why they're called that and where they come from. More likely, though, than it being useful for understanding the nature of the different conic sections, it'll be more useful for understanding trajectories on a cone at some point :)
- robinsord 4y ago[dead]
- lamontcg 4y ago> I got off the rails a bit staring at the diagram. A circle is of course a very specific case of an ellipse — seems off-topic to even include that specificity except for the fact that everyone does include it in a conic section diagram. Circles are mathematically special and horrible and can cause real singularities in the mathematics. Normally you measure Keplerian elements relative to the Periapsis which is the closest approach of the orbit. A perfectly circular orbit has no closest approach, it is all closest. Circular, equatorial, polar and parabolic orbits often need to be treated specially. For any algorithm those are often corner cases, they definitely need testing. I've found division by zero errors in a professionally written implementation of Shepperd's method of orbit propagation in a circular retrograde orbit. That same method of orbit propagation has fairly horrible problems with near-parabolic orbits, intrinsically.