10 ms·
I grew up being told I could do anything I put my mind to. That I was responsible, to a very large degree, for my own path and making my dreams come true. I do
by echelon 4y ago
I grew up being told I could do anything I put my mind to. That I was responsible, to a very large degree, for my own path and making my dreams come true.
I don't understand how those told that they're disadvantaged can persevere and succeed. Especially when they're told that it's the system's fault.
It takes seeking out adversity, embracing and enjoying it to push ahead. If you're uncomfortable at your basal level, grinding even harder must be unbearable.
To make it ahead in any fitness landscape, you have to undergo hardship to lower the activation energy of your path forward. If it was easy, everyone would do it. You have to seek out discomfort where others will not. That seems especially challenging if you don't have the right mindset.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- prohobo 4y agoLeftists argue your mindset is a symptom of the toxic mantras of neoliberalism. It's basically a Protestant work ethic: Highly individualistic, and little sense of commonality or cooperation. Thats the reasonable argument against your ethics, in that a community or team can do things that are impossible for any individual. It's absolutely true, and can't be refuted. But that's also the trap that modern society is falling into. We do not operate in nuance. We *could* combine ethics such as yours with community efforts and empower everyone, but instead we're trying to squash individuality, and enforce toxic mantras of community! The modern left eschews nuance and reacts with self-destructive vengeance, and that's the core problem with their politics. They equate liberals with neoliberals, neoliberals with conservatives, conservatives with Nazis, and Nazis with the boogeyman. To them the individual is absolute evil. So, I think the best thing to do is attempt to assuage their fears: show them that individuals can work together to improve society for everyone, without destroying individual values.
- zmgsabst 4y agoI view their politics as a meme prion: perhaps there’s some reasonable interpretation — as you’ve outlined here — but that’s not what they’re arguing. For example, despite saying that they’re staunchly against bigotry, they’re defining commonality by race and sex — rather than common circumstance. That’s inherently toxic because it foments the very bigotry they (pretend to) decry: look at their proud anti-Asian racism at Harvard, using 1950s style arguments there’s “too many Asians”. They absolutely detest the people who when viewing things through the lens of individualism, conclude that they should form partnerships with people that have aligned values, principles, and goals. After all, they’d have to admit their beliefs were a return to racial and sexual essentialism to have that realization — and they’re Good People (TM) who would never do such a thing. One of the most important choices an individual makes is who to have “on your team” — and their entire world view is built on assigning those roles based on protected class. I don’t think your attempt to “assuage their fears” will be met with anything but rabid anger — because we already did that and it already produced superior results. They’ve intentionally destroyed that system, as anathema.
- hotpotamus 4y agoWhat if you were born with an IQ of 85?
- zmgsabst 4y agoThat sucks. But the problems of that are not due to skin pigmentation or genital structure — it’s the fact intelligence is necessary for many tasks. And you’re still best served by focusing on how to improve your individual circumstance, especially compared to blaming those unrelated factors.
- hotpotamus 4y agoDo you think such a person can do anything they put their mind to? Also I don't know where skin pigmentation came into this though I'll admit I didn't read the article - does it say something about differential racial effects?
- zmgsabst 4y agoThat’s within the context of my comment. Also, extremely unlikely. But they’ll be better served by the mentality that they can than worrying about a victim narrative about how they’ll never be able to succeed. Eg, this. https://www.clickorlando.com/news/local/2021/10/12/after-becoming-first-ironman-with-down-syndrome-chris-nikic-conquers-boston-marathon/ https://www.clickorlando.com/news/local/2021/10/12/after-bec...
- hotpotamus 4y agoDo you think repeatedly failing to achieve a goal that you may never have been able to in the first place is good for mental health? Getting people to believe some lie about how they can achieve anything might make you feel better, but it seems fundamentally dishonest; despite what we may wish, not all the children can be above average. I'm glad the person in your example has the support required to spend his time doing non-productive sports that he enjoys, that's very nice and I wish more people had that opportunity, but do you think he'll ever be able to live independently?