3 ms·
Interesting that the SpaceX rockets have the same behaviour when landing. I read somewhere that was because they have no throttle control and are on/off, but I'
by renewiltord 4y ago
Interesting that the SpaceX rockets have the same behaviour when landing. I read somewhere that was because they have no throttle control and are on/off, but I'm no authority.
- Galxeagle 4y agoThe key reason is that an extra second of time spent hovering or close it is another second of resisting gravity, which takes fuel, so the most efficient hypothetical ‘burn’ is one big bang ‘hoverslam’ right at the end and 0 seconds spent fighting gravity The SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket does have throttle control, but at minimum thrust the thrust-to-weight ratio is still greater than 1, which means they have to hit 0m/s at exactly 0 feet of altitude or they start going up again. I’d imagine they time their ‘hoverslam’ to take 2x minimum thrust (or some other multiplier) and then adjust up or down through the manoeuvre.
- sbierwagen 4y agoThey have throttle, but not enough throttle range. Merlin is a 845 kN engine that can throttle down to 338 kN. When the rocket is mostly empty, that's too much thrust to hover. So they have a very short window to start the landing burn, and also not enough fuel to abort and try again. Given the constraints, it's surprising they don't lose more rockets during the landing phase.