3 ms·
Quebec man who created AI-generated child pornography sentenced to prison
- tekla 4y agoOk, so even with the slightly click-baity title, looks like the important part is this > Canadian law bans any visual representation of someone depicted as being under the age of 18 engaged in explicit sexual activity. Media in question copy-pasted real kids faces into sex videos, which seems to be illegal as read. This ruling probably doesn't cover 100% fully artificially generated stuff. Still wondering when that will hit the courts. Also the guy had plenty of the real stuff apparently.
- cperciva 4y agoThis ruling probably doesn't cover 100% fully artificially generated stuff. Not this ruling but others do. In 2008 an Australian man was convicted of possessing child pornography for having sexually explicit depictions of characters from The Simpsons; Canada and the UK have seen a few convictions involving erotica based on (entirely fictional) anime characters.
- prepend 4y ago> He also pleaded guilty to possessing hundreds of thousands of computer files of child pornography, for which he was sentenced an additional four and a half years. Seems like hundreds of thousands of child porn images should be more than 4.5 years in prison. Is child porn not a serious offense in Canada? Also, he used deepfake so the videos were childporn before he replaced the faces. So I think these are AI-augmented rather than AI-generated. If he has made whole cloth videos that never involved children I wonder what his sentence would be.
- DangitBobby 4y ago4.5 years is a really long time. Ridiculous US sentencing habits might be affecting your calibration for how seriously this offense is being taken.
- igetspam 4y ago4.5 years for child abuse feels like a very short period of time. Multiply that by the volume and it feels laughable. Child pornography is not a victimless crime. These children were abused and the people who possess this material are party to it. How is 4.5 years "serious," considering the extent of the crime?
- DangitBobby 4y agoAgain, 4.5 years is a long time. Nothing else to it. I tried doing research on average sentence lengths in Canada to see how serious this sentence is relatively speaking and couldn't find much easily so I gave up. You could try yourself and see what you find.
- nickthegreek 4y agoDo inmates in Canada regularly serve their full sentence? If 4.5 turns into 3, are we still going to say that is long time?
- igetspam 4y agoI don't have to research sentencing to feel that 4.5 years is out of line with the amount of victimization being discussed. What would you think was justified for someone who abused children for profit? Someone who forced kids to do lewd things, so they could sell photos of it? Is possessing the material different? Or do think causing lifelong harm to children, in general, is only worth a handful of years to the abuser? Is 1/25 of a life really the just outcome for an entire life in therapy? A lifetime of trust issues? What if one of those kids committed suicide because they couldn't cope? So 4.5 years, huh? The US has plenty of examples of light sentencing. Rapists who get "time served" is common. Victim blaming is part of what we do. Serious crimes deserve serious punishment or the ROI on crime becomes worth it.
- mablopoule 4y ago"Is possessing the material different?" I mean...yes? of course it is? It's like pretending to watch a football match on tv to be materially the same as being in the field. There is of course the question of whether he shared it or not, or if it was just for personal use, but still, as horrible that subject might be, I'm more than a bit mystified at the idea of the act vs. watching the video of the act considered as being even remotely in the same ballpark.
- teststuff 4y agoAs other have said, this is more like AI augmented, not generated. So that is one factor against the guy. Also, the way current models work is that they need to be trained on real data. It is really questionable if someone can make this kind of stuff with, say Stable Diffusion, entirely without any offensive material as training. If they can actually do it and make these things without using any abusive material, then I think it is fair game. Nobody was harmed, nobody should care. What a person does in their private is none of anyone business if it doesn't affect anyone else.
- dogma1138 4y agoEven if it was fully AI generated if the model was trained on proscribed materials the distribution of the model itself and what it generates can be also soldiered illegal.
- nickthegreek 4y agoSD is known to easily be able to generate this type of thing in the 1.5 model without being trained on explicit images of children. I imagine we will see a court case in the next few years.
- DiabloD3 4y agoIf you read the article, the headline is a confused mess. He was putting other kid's faces on existing child porn using common face swap software, and distributed the modified stuff as if it was real, including details of the kids who the faces come from. So, hes a pedophile who engaged in harming children within the definition of the law, not some guy who produced whole-cloth fictional victimless works using some sort of GPT model (ie, things we actually call AI; we do not call face swapping software AI).
- 1letterunixname 4y agoEffectively "revenge porn"/deep fakes of actual children. That's gross and humiliating because there's a real victim to point to. There are monsters in the world, no doubt. Although, I'm apprehensive at the thought for the potential of this sort of underground taboo material to include generative AI creating fully synthetic biographies, videos, social media trails, chat bots, video conferences and such that appear real enough to pass Turing tests. In realpolitik terms, it may be a relief in disguise if it meant less targeting of real human beings. I'm also wondering if the 4chan types, terrorists, and violent sociopaths will use generative technologies to simulate scenes and events they wish to transpire. If so, then where does one draw the line between that and say shoot 'em up games? Do their so-called fictional plans and expressions become crimes? (Sigh. It's confusing, uneasy, and brain-breaking.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]