9 ms·
The curious side effects of medical transparency
- sbr464 4y agoIs there a video archive of complete surgical procedures available?
- cprayingmantis 4y agoProbably not very many. Fun anecdote: When the Google Glass first came out I wanted to use it to record procedures so that we could create an annotated video dataset of medical procedures to see if we could match outcomes to actions. When I talked to medical professionals about it though they told me no Doctor would wear it for fear of malpractice lawsuits so it never really got off the ground. I guess you could go the opposite way and talk to the insurance companies about forcing surgeons to wear it but that didn’t sit well with me.
- rhco 4y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20230429202757/https://www.newyorker.com/news/essay/the-curious-side-effects-of-medical-transparency https://web.archive.org/web/20230429202757/https://www.newyo...
- flybrand 4y ago2023: Articles about transparency hidden behind a paywall.
- doodlesdev 4y agoDisable JavaScript
- wcerfgba 4y agoPerhaps the opposite virtue of transparency is confidentiality: either or both can be good depending on the context, but sometimes they are mutually exclusive.
- areoform 4y ago> Historically, the medical profession has had little use for transparency. Grave diagnoses were routinely withheld, on the assumption that they would further patient suffering. The Black men who participated in the infamous syphilis study at Tuskegee, in 1932, were not told that the trial aimed to study untreated syphilis, nor were they made aware of—or offered—penicillin, which became widely available the following decade. Generations of patients with mental illness were often institutionalized with little or no information released to them or their families. > There are strong ethical reasons, therefore, to pursue transparency in the medical record. But, as Pozen points out, we should not be lulled into treating transparency as a first-order good, like compassion, respect, avoiding harm, or putting the patient first. In a recent survey of more than eight thousand patients conducted by OpenNotes, nearly all the respondents said that they preferred immediate access to their test results, even if their doctors hadn’t yet reviewed those results. This was true even for the vast majority of people who said that they’d experienced increased worry in the face of results that were abnormal. It’s an understandable preference—one that every patient has the right to hold. But simply throwing open the medical record and calling it a day allows us to rest on our laurels without doing the hard work of fixing what’s inside. Police departments often point to body cameras as evidence of accountability without actually addressing the problem of police violence. Lawmakers can laud themselves for their transparency via C-span without having to engage in the gritty compromise needed to move legislation forward. Transparency might better be viewed as one possible means to desirable ends—not an end in and of itself. Yes, patients need to be educated, but we shouldn't mince words. The real reason for this protest by the broader field (and not this particular author) is that most doctors are terrible at their jobs. An example of this is Cystic Fibrosis research. For decades, CF was the only field with any concrete data on patient outcomes, mostly due to efforts by the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation. This data is fairly conclusive. Specialists aren't all alike. The difference between the best doctors and the below average/average ones is measured in decades. > It is distressing for doctors to have to acknowledge the bell curve. It belies the promise that we make to patients who become seriously ill: that they can count on the medical system to give them their very best chance at life. It also contradicts the belief nearly all of us have that we are doing our job as well as it can be done. But evidence of the bell curve is starting to trickle out, to doctors and patients alike, and we are only beginning to find out what happens when it does. http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2004/12/06/the-bell-curve http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2004/12/06/the-bell-curve The medical field as a whole is poorly designed. For example, it has been known and acknowledged for decades (longer than my lifetime) that the medical residency system doesn't work. It was designed by a doctor who was high on several grams of cocaine at a time and required other people to keep up with his frenzied addiction (and death toll). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7828946/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7828946/ https://magazine.columbia.edu/article/cocaine-addict-who-changed-medicine-forever https://magazine.columbia.edu/article/cocaine-addict-who-cha... We've known for several decades that the current residency system kills people, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_resident_work_hours#Effects_of_resident_sleep_deprivation_on_patients https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_resident_work_hours#Ef... Asking overworked, tired, barely functional students to make life and death decisions on the fly after being awake for 16 hours has been a recipe for disaster for decades. But despite laws, nothing much has changed. Much of the medical field is like this. We know that checklists reduce mortality and medical errors — https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3069616/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3069616/, but the field refuses to implement them broadly; viewing it as a waste of time, https://qualitysafety.bmj.com/content/21/3/191.short https://qualitysafety.bmj.com/content/21/3/191.short , https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Joseph-Keebler/publication/330561453_Checklists_A_Review_of_Their_Origins_Benefits_and_Current_Uses_as_a_Cognitive_Aid_in_Medicine/links/5ddd6d9b299bf10bc329509e/Checklists-A-Review-of-Their-Origins-Benefits-and-Current-Uses-as-a-Cognitive-Aid-in-Medicine.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Joseph-Keebler/publicat... > Zeeni et al. (2014) cited a number of reasons why clinicians may resist the use of checklists, including the perception or fear of the loss of independence associated with read-do checklists that renders them subservient to the checklist and does not leverage their skill and knowledge (Catchpole & Russ, 2015). Other concerns cited by medical professionals regarding checklists include that checklists are often thrust on them by administrative fait accompli, checklists do not consider the unique challenges of their individual circumstances, their use may complicate an already complex task (Catchpole & Russ, 2015), and their use may be seen as a sign of weakness or lack of competency (Gaba, 2013). Being a physician was a socially powerful role. That's not true anymore. The hierarchy has changed, but the field hasn't changed in response. Broadly speaking, a physician's discomfort is given more importance than a patient's life. It shouldn't be a surprise that medical error is a leading cause of accidental death. > Death by medical error or accident is the nation’s leading cause of accidental death, exceeding all other causes of accidental death combined. Medical error and accidents kill approximately as many people each month in the U.S. as Covid-19 did before vaccines became available. https://www.statnews.com/2021/08/04/medical-errors-accidents-ongoing-preventable-health-threat/ https://www.statnews.com/2021/08/04/medical-errors-accidents... https://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/17/business/17quality.html https://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/17/business/17quality.html Transparency may be painful and it is definitely not a cure all, but it is self-evidently better than the current status quo. Every time there has been the slightest degree of transparency in the field, it has lifted the veil on just how terrible most doctors are. Even these small efforts in transparency have helped shift the field towards better outcomes for patients through social pressure and patients voting with their feet.
- doodlesdev 4y ago> Furthermore, simplified metrics frequently distort incentives. If graduation rates are the metric by which funding is determined, then a school might do whatever it takes to bolster them. Although some of these efforts might add value to students’ learning, it’s also possible to game the system in ways that are counterproductive to actual education. I thought this part of the article particularly interesting. The problem is not just the access to data, but the obsession to optimize the numbers shown. The solution is to understand that: whenever a metric becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure Which is known as Goodhart's Law [0]. The problem with transparency and any kind of data is that you should be very careful when choosing your metrics and targets, as statistics can be deceiving. Unfortunately, this is probably too complicated to institutionalize in large groups of people who might not get the point, so ultimately a balance has to be chosen between transparency and confidentiality. In the case of medical records, I believe doctors should have the option to write two notes: One accessible to the patients and the other for medical staff, without the option of sharing it. I fear the consequences of their work being so transparent could ultimately lead to bad communication and in the worst case leading to the wrong treatment. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart's_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart's_law
- jameslevy 4y agoIt's amazing to me how often Goodhart's Law can be observed in the wild, and I've come to believe it is an important enough concept that it should probably be something (along with logical fallacies and other concepts related to critical thinking) that should be prioritized above a lot of other things taught in high schools.
- novok 4y agoSo when you tell execs goodhart's law, they ask, ok what can we do about it when managing large organizations? Be it a 200 person department of a 30'000 person organization or even more?
- onos 4y agoThe usual argument is you need a metric and a check metric that can catch gaming the first. Eg unit sales and mean price per sale — the latter preventing a race to the bottom on price point.
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y agoHere is an thought for you: Think of your profession. Count the number of people that are not qualified for the job, or that are actively doing drugs while on the job. Now count how many of those get fired and pushed out of the profession, via judge, customer reviews, bad industry rep, or loss of license. Now doctors. Do you think there are doctors not qualified for the job ? Or on drugs ? Because, there are exactly zero doctors pushed out of the practice of medicine. That should answer a few questions about whether you can implement transparency.
- watwut 4y ago> Because, there are exactly zero doctors pushed out of the practice of medicine. This is exactly not true. You might argue too little doctors are pushed out, but you did not. A doctor loosing ability to practice medicine is an actual real world thing.
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y agoYes, and its so rare that it may be deemed not to exist. Are we arguing about semantics ?
- ksaun 4y agoOpinions may vary, but to me the difference between "so rare that it may be deemed not to exist" and "exactly zero" is not about semantics. (I see "exactly zero" as an absolute statement that therefore precludes such subtleties.)
- theoldlove 4y ago“state medical boards nationwide took away 692 doctors' licenses, or seven per 10,000 physicians, in 2015, the most recent year for which data is available.” https://www.newyorkupstate.com/news/2018/10/new_york_bending_over_backwards_to_let_unfit_docs_keep_medical_licenses.html https://www.newyorkupstate.com/news/2018/10/new_york_bending... Looks like doctors lose their licenses slightly more frequently than lawyers are disbarred
- 4y ago
- derbOac 4y agoMy experience is in psychiatry and behavioral health, where this issue becomes particularly acute. So much of this field depends on notes and reports — it's not that there aren't test results and so forth but so much of it depends on behavioral observations and the content of what clients and their loved ones and others are saying. The fundamental issue is one of audience. You always have an audience in any writing, and with healthcare notes this is especially true. The problem arises when you try to deny this, and in the process make everyone your audience, as what writing you need for one reader is very different from the writing you need for another reader. In psychiatry this is especially problematic because you're essentially always trying to maintain rapport and a relationship with a client, and there are times when the most tactful and therapeutic thing to do is to withhold information at a moment, or even more often, present that information in a very specific way. The way you communicate with a patient is part of your job. You wouldn't behave toward a colleague in the same way you would a patient, but that's essentially what you're asked to do with open notes. I can imagine the criticisms this might invite — that what I'm saying is an example of how patronizing psychiatry can be at times — but I think there's no way around this. I highly doubt you want your therapist talking to you like you like they would a close friend or colleague, for example, and no professional therapist would do that. Open notes are this sort of weird wormhole through the provider-patient relationship boundaries that typically exist, and in my experience they just lead to this odd coded language in notes, or pushing discussions offline into verbal discussions between colleagues, or something. I do think patient records should be available to them, but I agree with others that it might be better to have certain levels of firewall for different types of notes. Some a patient might get immediately; others they might have to make a request for, or something. It's a difficult needle to thread, but I'm not sure radical record transparency always everywhere is quite optimal.
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoPsychiatry as a pseudo-science often relies heavily on unscientific and non-empirical methods of diagnosis. There is no brain scan or blood test to detect or even rule out bipolar disorder or schizophrenia, you just go with whatever the doctor feels like when the patient comes in off the street. Psychiatry is worse than veterinary medicine: a dog can't talk to you and tell you what's wrong; neither can a dog lie to you or be a deranged, unreliable narrator. Psychiatrists often ask questions which have a specific context or particular technical meaning to them, and the mentally ill will answer out of ignorance, or with a non sequitir, that seems counter-productive to the process. I have often obtained medical records (it's interesting to see how difficult this can be, and the bureaucratic tricks that can be played to avoid complying with laws that allow us that access.) I've been incensed to see inaccuracies and often dismayed to see the state of things from the provider's perspective when I came to them in crisis. For example, there was one note that just indicated I'd been a chronic, habitual daily user of marijuana for years upon years. Nothing could be further from the truth. But there it is in my medical record, proof against any legal challenge, their word against mine, and God forbid I attempt to challenge it in a followup session, because I'm a crazy, unreliable narrator with a reputation for denying the truth. It is dismaying that so-called "medical" professionals should withhold the truth from patients and are perfectly allowed to obscure anything in the chart that they judge to be detrimental to treatment. My psychiatrist is consistently unwilling or unable to describe the first-order effects of my medication, what benefits I should hope to enjoy from them, or just in a general sense why am I taking this toxic crap. My psychiatrist freely admits to diagnosing me solely on affect. If I am sociable and pleasantly greeting people in the clinic, then I'm having a good day and I'm near baseline. If I'm reserved and sensitive, and have difficulty answering her questions, then I'm a good candidate for hospitalization! I was literally steps away from being forcibly committed after one video appointment that went poorly. A video appointment! I try to read everything I sign, but it's fruitless to try to stay ahead of any medical bureacracy. One day I came in to file a request for my complete chart. The condescending jerk who filled it out put in my name instead of the clinic's, so I was requesting records from myself. Guess how long that took to fulfil.
- sour-taste 4y agoI thought this article somewhat buried the interesting part with lots of only tangentially-related anecdotes. I loved the doctors nuanced takes on what transparency can mean for medical professionals, and thought the other examples were misplaced (focusing not so much on transparency, but on other things like measurement difficulty, process adherence, etc). I was a little surprised that the section on transparency in government didn't touch at all on executive privilege which is obviously a big topic right now. I thought one point in particular was very well made: transparency in and of itself should not be a goal. We should have a specific outcome we're trying to achieve, and transparency should be an option, but not the only option considered. For the medical case, maybe the goal is improving portability of medical records (critical!) but we need to think about what mandating transparency does to all the things the doctor mentions (people using Dr Google, oversharing to family members, etc).
- tsimionescu 4y ago> I thought one point in particular was very well made: transparency in and of itself should not be a goal That is indeed a point that the article makes, but it ignores a significant problem. Good medical practice relies on the patient's informed consent. I'm not the doctor's plaything, their problem to solve, the doctor is there to help me make good decisions on my own health. If the doctor has private thoughts about me and my condition, thoughts that they don't think they should share with me, those should not be part of the treatment decisions, since I should be given all relevant information about my treatment before consenting to it. So, I would say transparency of records is actually a good in itself, insofar as it is almost equivalent to informed consent, which is a basic human right. Of course, things are not so simple in cases like psychiatry, where coercive treatment is sometimes necessary.
- bobsmooth 4y agoThe bit at the end with the old man is the most poignant.
- gsatic 4y ago[flagged]
- MrDrDr 4y agoSome interesting research in this area from the uk: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10410236.2020.1803553 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10410236.2020.1...