7 ms·
Germany will start one of the most affordable public transit offers in the world
- _Microft 4y agohttps://nitter.it/BloombergTV/status/1652342136363266055 https://nitter.it/BloombergTV/status/1652342136363266055
- marstall 4y agofor comparison: Boston's monthly LinkPass, providing unlimited travel on buses, subways, certain ferries and near-in commuter rail transit, is $90 (vs Germany's plan being $54). Would make sense for cities to accept each other's monthly transit cards in theory - little loss for the home city, and a nice perk for the pass holder that could increase appeal of that product. Technology hurdles would probably insurmountable though with the different card formats and such.
- newaccount74 4y agoThis is an example where the federal government can do something that is impossible for companies and local governments. All the transit companies in Germany have different systems, different cards, some don't accept digital tickets at all -- but now the government just said they have to accept this new common digital ticket and it's done. Similar thing happened in Austria with the Klimaticket. There are dozens of local transport authorities, and the government just decided that there should be a yearly ticket (Klimaticket) and everyone has to accept it.
- TulliusCicero 4y ago> but now the government just said they have to accept this new common digital ticket and it's done. This is exactly the power of higher level government. Everyone loves to talk about making decisions more locally, but the truth is that fundamentally, local decisionmaking is no better or worse than national decisionmaking; it's just different, at least overall. In some cases it's better, but you can see that in a case like this, just having coordination forced upon local agencies that otherwise have little incentive to cooperate is actually fantastic.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- em-bee 4y agoit's not that simple, there is of course the question of who is paying for this, since the respective transportation businesses do expect to be reimbursed. but, regional tickets that are valid in all transport businesses in an area already exist everywhere, so the technicalities of working out how to count and reimburse different businesses has already been worked out, and expanding this to an additional nationwide ticket is a small change. this is a very different approach and culture to for example japan where lots of independent companies providing transport exist, but as far as i can tell no collective ticket, but pay as you go everywhere.
- contingencies 4y agoAustralia (NSW): AUD$50/week cap. They also discount $2 when you change transport modes in one journey, halve prices after 8 journeys/week, cap weekdays at AUD$16.80, cap weekend days at AUD$8.40 and offer 30% off-peak discount - https://transportnsw.info/tickets-opal/opal/opal-benefits https://transportnsw.info/tickets-opal/opal/opal-benefits which works out to AUD$200/month = USD$132/month
- devoutsalsa 4y ago>> Would make sense for cities to accept each other's monthly transit cards in theory - little loss for the home city, and a nice perk for the pass holder that could increase appeal of that product. Like stamps!
- riku_iki 4y ago> providing unlimited travel on buses, subways, certain ferries and near-in commuter rail transit, is $90 (vs Germany's plan being $54). Boston likely has much smaller public transit population density, meaning they need to spend more per commuter on infra.
- morelisp 4y agoI don't know what "public transit population density" is, but there's probably no reasonable measure whereby Boston, a city, has a lower density of any human thing than Germany, a whole-ass farm-heavy country.
- riku_iki 4y agobut majority of population is likely driving cars in Boston area and not using public transportation, so they are not "public transit population".
- morelisp 4y agoBoston is one of the least car-dependent cities in America and Germany is one of the most car-dependent countries in Europe, so I suspect there's significant overlap. But this is also some deep begging of the question - if you charge more less people use it, no shit. It's not like this price is profitable anywhere in Germany.
- riku_iki 4y ago>Boston is one of the least car-dependent cities in America and Germany is one of the most car-dependent countries in Europe original comment covered Boston area, since it includes extra city transit. My expectation is that Boston area population still drive cars much more than Germans. > It's not like this price is profitable anywhere in Germany. the question how much unprofitable it will be in US. Say government invested billions in building top notch public transit in Boston area, but population will still prefer to drive cars, it will be huge waste of money. I think one of the reason why cars are preferred in US is higher wages and lower gasoline and car prices so population can afford driving cars more, and car is more convenient transportation in most of the time.
- tonfa 4y agoSwitzerland started getting unique ticket across public transport companies since 1857. Now it's enshrined in the law (and over 240 different transportation companies are participating, incl. train, bus, gondola, boats, etc.). (service direct in French, direkter Verkher in German) Prices are much higher than Germany though.
- notfried 4y agoIs this a new pass, or a reduction in price of an existing pass? Trying to understand how much more affordable this has become.
- quonn 4y agoNew. There was a brief experiment last year with a 9 Euro one.
- marcod 4y agoIt wasn't so much an experiment as a relief effort during the pandemic... and the people liked it so much that they demanded more.
- jacques-noris 4y agoIt’s new
- h4kor 4y agoThis is a new(ish) ticket. We had a 9€ ticket for three month (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9-Euro-Ticket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9-Euro-Ticket) which was a huge monetary relief. Sadly this is not continued, but as a consequence (due to high popularity of the 9 euro ticket) the 49€ ticket is introduced as a compromise. It generally is cheaper than most (virtually all) monthly tickets. Additionally this one is valid for all of Germany instead of just for a state or specific region. "Job Tickets" used to commute to and from work, subsidized by cities and/or companies, often cost ~90 € per month in my experience.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoWe need to realise that 9 euros or 49 euros makes no difference. Both are peanuts for the vast majority of people. Ultimately these schemes are based on the belief of the current people in charge to public transport should be free. Hence they pushing to get there. But trying to argue that 9 vs 49 is a huge difference feels rather immature.
- computatrum 4y agoBesides the mentioned possibilities, it also includes regional trains. It allows therefore to travel through whole Germany (of course usually slower than with the intercity trains that have less stops).
- dathinab 4y ago> travel through whole Germany theoretically yes but outside of going to close by cities it's very unpractical the moment you travel a longer distance it's not just "usually slower", it's most times way slower and you don't have the comfort of e.g. seat reservations and you tend to have to switch trains way more often meaning the chance of unexpected delays increases exponentially. E.g. Berlin => Munich with ICE 4 hours but with RE+RB 12 hours. (RE,RB are included in the Germany wide ticket but IC,ICE are not) Basically the ticket includes all metro transportation train networks across Germany as well as the trains which connect "regional" places (e.g. small cities, villages) with each other and the bigger hubs. This still can be a major money saving, especially for people which live slightly outside the transportation network of a metro area (which helps because housing prices have been kinda high in many metro areas in recent years). Or saves money e.g. in summer when taking a day trip to a lake or nice hiking place outside of the reach of the metro area (which also can be a big help for day trips for people earning just a bit about the limit under which you get social support). I.e. it will help the most people which are currently affect the most by the current inflation and other post-covid effects, while it still is a really convenient thing for everyone else.
- realworldperson 4y ago[dead]
- TrackerFF 4y agoI really, really wish we had this in Norway too. I'm quite often on business trips, and regularly visit the major cities here - I also love taking the public transit - so right now I have 6 different apps on my phone. Would be nice with only one, as well as tickets that can be used wherever.
- vinni2 4y agoYou can use Vy app they have started to sell local transport tickets too. But price wise ya it’s not exactly cheap.
- rsolva 4y agoCheck out the app "Entur", it consolidates all public transport into one app so you can order a trip across different regions without having to use several apps. As an aside, the Green Party in Norway wants to do the same as Germany: introduce a nation-wide monthly "travel as much as you want"-subscription for 499 NOK. It will probably only include the local and cross regional trains, and not the fastest and longest routes.
- opportune 4y agoThis is an amazing value, well done Germany! I think public transit has a marketing problem in the US. People don’t often realize how much more expensive the paradigm of “taxes pay for roads and individuals pay for vehicles, gas, and maintenance” can be than a paradigm of heavy public transit use. While this program for sure relies on taxpayer funding (just as road usage does, I might add), even if coupled with occasional car rentals or taxis, the all-in cost can be so much lower than having a car. The train system is one of my favorite parts of Germany and I really wish we had something comparable in the denser parts of the US.
- r00fus 4y agoNot to mention one of my most memorable travel meals was from a German rail station - just a sandwich of bread + meat but it was sooo good (note: I was living in France at the time). German rail travel was a great experience. Considering how most trains are electric/hybrid diesel it's clear the petroleum industry never allowed new (and even dismantled existing) rail networks. Just more profits for them.
- opportune 4y agoMost of the German train station food I’ve had was Panera Bread quality but I love that there’s typically good food options in walking distance. I personally have had better train station food in France, as in my limited exposure there were more small groceries, where I could get inexpensive high quality cheeses and bread.
- em-bee 4y agoin my experience you get good food at train stations when it comes from regular chains or franchises because they provide the same products and quality as in their other shops.
- rainsford 4y agoIn peoples' defense, I think the problem in the vast majority of the US is that public transit is legitimately terrible and most of the US has been built up so that good public transit is difficult to build. I agree that public transit can be a good alternative to car travel, but the problem of marketing it in the US is that the current version of the product being marketed is, to put it bluntly, completely garbage. What really needs to be sold to people is investing in making public transit better instead of just building more roads, but that's a more abstract sales pitch. I also think selling public transit as an alternative to having a car at all is perhaps too ambitious a target. But having to use a car less still has a lot of benefits for individuals and society as a whole without having to get public transit to the point where it can replace nearly all journeys.
- TacticalCoder 4y ago49 EUR a mont or about 600 EUR a year. I live in neighbouring Luxembourg now and here it's very simple: public transportation inside the country are free. No need to register or anything: you just hop in and it's free. For tourists, for expats/residents/natives: doesn't matter, it's all free. Income tax goes as high as 40% in Luxembourg (for the high earners) but it sure seems like people here do get a lot in return for their taxes.
- kitten_mittens_ 4y agoIncome tax when I lived in Germany ('17-'19) was 42%. The Soli tax was another 5%. Transit was relatively expensive compared to Boston, where I live now, but in much better shape. Transit coverage in the suburbs seemed much better too.
- gv83 4y agoisn't Luxembourg a notorious tax haven? more like people there get a lot in return for other people taxes...
- dathinab 4y agofor companies it's a tax haven for private people it isn't except it is because if you have a very high amount of money you can do all kind of tricks to reduce you personal income (on which you pay high tax) without actually losing out on much, e.g. by having a company have this income instead of you, and you just happen to have 100% control of the company ;=) for money you spend on private exp-endures of luxury there is often a limit on how much you can trick around so you still have to pay yourself out a not so small amount of money as income and in turn Luxembourg still get a nice amount of tax. (Edit: Legal tax avoidance of very wealthy people, works roughly like this pretty much everywhere, not just Luxembourg.)
- thefz 4y agoWe are talking 2000 square Km versus 357'000. You can understand that the costs would scale fast.
- sschueller 4y agoDid the conditions change? Just a week ago a German comedy show similar to the US daily show showed how much of a mess the system is and that this ticket isn't valid everywhere. One place you can take your dog for free and another you pay etc. Germany has a very heterogeneous public transport system from my understanding.
- marcod 4y agoLet's have the perfect be the enemy of the good!
- morelisp 4y agoIt's the equivalent of the basic ticket in each city so guests, children, bike, dog, etc. will all vary based on whatever that offering is. Regardless it guarantees the purchaser transit. It's still massively simpler than actually buying a ticket in each city.
- MrJohz 4y agoI think this has more to do with the natural desire to complain about things - perfect is the enemy of good and all that. There are definitely a lot of issues, ranging from, as you say, the heterogeneity of German public transport to the flat-rate-but-still-somehow-discounted-for-employees pricing structure. But I suspect a lot of this will get worked out over time. But the foundation does seem to be pretty clear and universal - if you have this ticket for 49€ a month, you will be allowed on all RE/RB/S trains, plus buses and trams. This alone is a fantastic deal for a lot of people. On top of that, some states will have some extra offers or additional forms of public transport with extra rules, but if you need to worry about that, then you needed to worry about that before the ticket anyway.
- fabian2k 4y agoIt's a ticket without any frills. So you don't get the kind of perks like adding another person you might in some other monthly or yearly tickets. Adding animals or bicycles is not part of the deal here, which makes the use of this ticket more complex for these cases. But those cases were usually a bit more complex before anyway. Apart from that the ticket is valid in essentially every regional train. There are some weird cases that might not be valid, but those are as far as I understand some unusual edge cases and some of them are being negotiated. But this doesn't affect the vast majority of users.
- poisonborz 4y agoGreat move, but as someone using it, it's also one of the most unreliable for its size. DB/German railway is infamous for large delays and breakdowns. There was an effort to make the lines more punctual within a decade or so, which was then, almost satirically, moved to 2070[1]. Suburban lines often come to standstill on rain or snow. Germany has a huge network of quality free highways, car ownership is cheap, so public transport has little respect even within cities. 1 https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/unternehmen/bahn-deutschlandtakt-101.html https://www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/unternehmen/bahn-deutsc...
- dathinab 4y agoIt really depends which standards you compare it, too. (and for local transportation also where in Germany you are) As German we love to complain about the trains and while it is way worse then e.g. Japan and in turn can improve by a lot it could be far far worse.
- lispm 4y ago> Inner city transports come to standstill on the first sign of any rain or snow. I live in Hamburg, an the public transport system is extensive and generally quite good.
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- haunter 4y agoHungary does something similar starting May 1. 50€ for a country-wide ticket on buses and trains, no local transport included though. Still it's really good deal. Also students get a 90% discount. https://www.orszagberlet.hu/ https://www.orszagberlet.hu/ (hungarian only)
- switch007 4y agoFor comparison, it costs 365 EUR/month to commute 25-30 mins (~43 km) on the train from Woking to London, on a suburban rail service. So, London, your turn? I jest, I jest
- qwefggggqwe 4y agoI will move out of Germany at the end of year. The country has insanely high taxes for singles. Also a court may ask you to pay life long support, paying 3/7 of the difference of your incomes, to your ex wife even if you don't have any children. Bureaucracy is one of the highest in the entire world and every process takes a lot of time. Many authorities will not even accept anything but paper letters for communication. May be some day I will write about all the drawbacks of living in Germany, but that book will be bigger than the entire Encyclopaedia Britannica.
- franczesko 4y agoLiving there has some advantages too, no?
- frodowtf 4y agoNo, everything is bad. That's why I'm about to migrate to the next country where I will eventually realize that everything is bad but it's now 10 years later.
- IdiocyInAction 4y agoI get your grievances about Germany, but alimony/child support laws can turn out much worse than that in many parts of the anglosphere. Bad bureaucracy is also hardly unique to Germany. The tax thing I do get. Especially if you are not a migrant it can be a tough ask to give away 40-50% of your money, a lot of which goes directly or indirectly to pensioners who probably hate your guts. Though again, while this is particularly bad in Germany, it's hardly unique in that regard.
- opportune 4y agoWhat other drawbacks are there and where will you go to? Alimony is going to be a thing in most Western countries. The weird low-tech bureaucracy (which culturally extends well into the business world and is related to things like high physical currency usage) is to me one of the worst parts of Germany. IMO the taxes are not bad because you get a lot of benefits from government spending living there, it’s the low wages that are the real problem.
- rrgok 4y agoWhat if they extended it so that all residents must pay it, wether they want to use or not public transport? This way, they can reduce the price even more and everybody can hop in a public transport anytime they want without thinking.
- gstipi 4y agoTechnically, every tax payer does pay, irrespective of whether they are using the ticket or not: the EUR 49/month ticket is heavily subsidised, to the tune of EUR 3 billion/year, and this is covered by the tax payer.
- _8j50 4y agoI am very much anti-car but the extreme also concerns me. If you're not rich and all your options for transportations are public shared transportation and payment methods are non-cash and traceable then your freedom of movement is regulated by the state. In China for example, your movement using public transportation and even your ability to rent a bike is regulated by social score. I need a constitutional amendement (US) that guarantees cash payments will alwayd be an option for any means of transportation, shopping for basic needs and communication methods. And that the 4th amendment's protections for search and seizure extend to public transportation and that the government must take an all or nothing approach to weapons on public transport, that is either allow all legal weapons or screen every single person using a public transport (like airports) for weapons. I would also like to add that the federal government should be granted powers that allow it to override local governments' push back against public transport infrastructure (e.g. california!). Allow it to purchase any land for fair market prices and use eminent domain to remove people and endsure things like the cali rail project where rich localities get a stop but poor ones have little say doesn't happen.
- superdeeda 4y agoIn Germany, most public transport is “barrier-free” and cash tickets are still available.
- _8j50 4y agoGermany gets a lot of stuff like this right. For example, I work in infosec and it is a nightmare to do anything that might identify a user, as it should be.