2 ms·
Removing that authority from the President would be a good step.[1] The Constitution says that the power to make and declare war belongs to Congress. The USSR
by Animats 4y ago
Removing that authority from the President would be a good step.[1] The Constitution says that the power to make and declare war belongs to Congress.
The USSR did not give the premier of the Soviet Union nuclear release authority. That belonged to the Politburo. The USSR, post-Stalin, did not have one all-powerful dictator. They'd tried that. This led to the famous Perimetr system. That's been said to have been a "doomsday machine", but it was really a constraint on the Premier. Perimetr was normally turned off, and could be activated by the Premier. The system had sensors which could detect the nuclear destruction of Moscow. That started timers. The system could be stopped from the General Staff bunker and the Premier's bunker. If there was no communication with either, after some number of hours, the codes to allow the release of nuclear weapons would be released to regional military commanders far outside Moscow. Those generals could then decide what to do. The system could not launch on its own. Nor could the Premier. All he could do was activate Perimitr, or convene the Poliburo and ask for war.
The regional commanders did not physically have the codes needed to launch on their own. Also,
the military controlled the launchers but the KGB controlled the warheads. Both had to cooperate to launch. The whole system was based on mutual mistrust.
This did not continue under Putin. The Russian foreign ministry has explicitly said that Putin has nuclear release authority.
The US system is that several regional commanders already have the codes needed for launch.
From at least 1956 to 1998, Chairman, Joint Chiefs of Staff [JCS], Commanders-in-Chief of the Atlantic Command [CINCLANT], European Command [CINCEUR], and the Strategic Air Command [CINCSAC] all had nuclear release authority for "grave emergencies".[2]
[1] https://www.markey.senate.gov/news/press-releases/sen-markey-and-rep-lieu-announce-legislation-to-limit-us-presidents-power-to-unilaterally-start-nuclear-war https://www.markey.senate.gov/news/press-releases/sen-markey...
[2] https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/news/19980319.htm https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu/news/19980319.htm