3 ms·

Can someone share even one story where sudo reporting these "incidents" was helpful? This feature seems to come from a world where elite hackers simply repeat

Can someone share even one story where sudo reporting these "incidents" was helpful? This feature seems to come from a world where elite hackers simply repeat the same sudo command over and over hoping it will eventually work.

gtirloni 4y ago
> Can someone share even one story where sudo reporting these "incidents" was helpful? No, not a single one.
- rbanffy 4y ago
  “And, if we did, we’d have to kill you.”
  - salawat 3y ago
    Fool, I have signal handlers defined for all signals! You won't be rid of me that easily!
- gtirloni 3y ago
  HN puzzles me with these downvotes. I have not a single story to share about sudo reporting the incidents and that being useful and I've managed *NIX systems for 2 decades now. Anyway, looks like there's some people out there there feel very strong about this.
hoodmane 4y ago
Yes. More or less the first time I used Linux was on a fedora workstation at my desk at MIT. The very nice sysadmin down the hall sent me an email just a bit later saying "We see you were trying to install x program. We installed it for you." I understand that this is a very rare experience but the first time I saw that message, a helpful person was actually looking at these reports.
- hutzlibu 4y ago
  Does this kind of sysadmin still exists? (or do they even still have the freedom to be so kind?) I cannot really imagine that happening today, at least not in "professional" context.
  - stcg 4y ago
    It still happens, a fellow student and friend of mine got this response ('installed it for you') about two years ago at Radboud University Nijmegen after entering `sudo apt install nasm`
    - hutzlibu 4y ago
      Glad to hear that. I really like that style and attitude. It shows competence, humor and willingness to help. My admins were sadly mostly of the grumpy type, who did not like change, or initiative to solve peoples problem.
  - NegativeK 4y ago
    Yes....? If I see info in logs and it could help a user (my userbase is internal), I reach out to them. I've coached a number of them through improving something on their end, even if it's not a critical change. And I'm by no means some sysadmin wizard.
    - hutzlibu 4y ago
      "And I'm by no means some sysadmin wizard. " It is more about the general attitude, so thank you, for being a helpful IT admin.
- antognini 4y ago
  It sounds like you were able to successfully run sudo, just with a somewhat longer latency.
vulcan01 4y ago
I have a small server that some of my friends have accounts on. When they accidentally (or not!) try to use sudo (often this happens with a "curl | sh" thing) I like to be informed.

gtirloni 4y ago

> Can someone share even one story where sudo reporting these "incidents" was helpful? No, not a single one.

rbanffy 4y ago
“And, if we did, we’d have to kill you.”
- salawat 3y ago
  Fool, I have signal handlers defined for all signals! You won't be rid of me that easily!
gtirloni 3y ago
HN puzzles me with these downvotes. I have not a single story to share about sudo reporting the incidents and that being useful and I've managed *NIX systems for 2 decades now. Anyway, looks like there's some people out there there feel very strong about this.

hoodmane 4y ago

Yes. More or less the first time I used Linux was on a fedora workstation at my desk at MIT. The very nice sysadmin down the hall sent me an email just a bit later saying "We see you were trying to install x program. We installed it for you." I understand that this is a very rare experience but the first time I saw that message, a helpful person was actually looking at these reports.

hutzlibu 4y ago
Does this kind of sysadmin still exists? (or do they even still have the freedom to be so kind?) I cannot really imagine that happening today, at least not in "professional" context.
- stcg 4y ago
  It still happens, a fellow student and friend of mine got this response ('installed it for you') about two years ago at Radboud University Nijmegen after entering `sudo apt install nasm`
  - hutzlibu 4y ago
    Glad to hear that. I really like that style and attitude. It shows competence, humor and willingness to help. My admins were sadly mostly of the grumpy type, who did not like change, or initiative to solve peoples problem.
- NegativeK 4y ago
  Yes....? If I see info in logs and it could help a user (my userbase is internal), I reach out to them. I've coached a number of them through improving something on their end, even if it's not a critical change. And I'm by no means some sysadmin wizard.
  - hutzlibu 4y ago
    "And I'm by no means some sysadmin wizard. " It is more about the general attitude, so thank you, for being a helpful IT admin.
antognini 4y ago
It sounds like you were able to successfully run sudo, just with a somewhat longer latency.

vulcan01 4y ago

I have a small server that some of my friends have accounts on. When they accidentally (or not!) try to use sudo (often this happens with a "curl | sh" thing) I like to be informed.