3 ms·
Abstractions like that are meaningless. Why is the large hadron collider so expensive it’s just throwing stuff at each other and looking at what happens? Rando
by Retric 4y ago
Abstractions like that are meaningless. Why is the large hadron collider so expensive it’s just throwing stuff at each other and looking at what happens? Random teens could do that…
The actual process of doing blood work is often surprisingly complicated.
- hef19898 4y agoI see a resurected Theranos on the horizon. This time powered by by ChatGPT. What could go wrong?
- alexb_ 4y agoFunny enough, I'm actually developing an AI-powered biomedical technological breakthrough that's about to disrupt the medical industry. It uses wearables to enable a blockchain-enabled data management system that also functions as a cloud based SaaS provider, linking with ChatGPT and NFTs to create value for those who are underprivileged, all with only 1 drop of blood. If you want to further this please give me a few billion dollars and I promise something might come :)
- snovv_crash 4y agoI'm only interested if the blood is delivered by drones.
- Firmwarrior 4y agoSounds like it's not very eco friendly..
- chaxor 4y agoTheranos wasn't a bad idea, and is actually possible. It is extremely unfortunate that it was so badly mismanaged.
- hef19898 4y agoTheranos was a fraud, selling a service based on technology that simply doesn't exist.
- chaxor 4y agoOf course... that's absolutely true, and I didn't say otherwise. However, the basic idea actually is possible, but only for a very select few of the tests they proposed (which they still unfortunately didn't really get right of course). My point is that, unfortunately, the tests that are possible to do now won't get a company to form out of it - simply because they ruined the scene for everyone. Anyone trying to get a company going in this area and raising money for it will be met with a complete block of resistance because of the precedent set, even if the technology is actually completely reliable.
- Retric 4y agoNo, the variability between individual drops of blood are too high for the precision needed to do most of the tests they were proposing even before you look at the tiny fraction of a drop you would be working with to preform multiple tests. Worse you get excessive contamination between blood and other substances from a finger prick. So, no very quickly people were calling Theranos either incompetent or fraudulent.
- chaxor 4y ago"the tests they were proposing" - yeah, I would agree that some (probably most towards the end) of the tests they were trying to make part of the product were a big part of why they were so fraudulent. I agree that it was a bad company. My point is that the general idea was not a bad idea, and because it was so badly mismanaged (trying to add too many products and run before walking, using other companies' tech illegally, etc, etc) we now are worse off because few people want to attempt doing the possible ideas in this space (because people think none of it is possible - which is simply not true). The company that could reliably be made is far less 'attractive' of course, but it would still be quite beneficial.
- 77pt77 4y agoChatgpt can't get pregnant when things go wrong in order to soften the blow.
- chaxor 4y agoThe last test someone I know had done cost $600 at the physician. We looked it up and it cost a little less to *buy the FDA approved equipment for your house, and run the test every day for an entire month*. It's absolutely heinously broken - almost completely due to insurance companies. Insurance should be made illegal and obsolete due to the insane hindrance it is to progress in humanity.
- Retric 4y agoThere’s often many tests for the same things with various levels of accuracy and cost. You really didn’t provide enough information for a more detailed analysis, but for example there’s a reason hospitals don’t just use the cheap COVID tests and call it good.
- chaxor 4y agoIt wasn't a viral test, and I didn't lay out details here because I don't want to put all my health information on display exactly, but I have several graduate degrees in both engineering and in biology related fields, so I'm quite certain that my analysis of the equipment and technical parameters is correct. It's the financial aspect of healthcare that is horribly wrong, not the science (only let down there is an academic one, as it's awfully basic and antiquated technology that makes it to the clinic, but that's not a bug - it's a feature for safety). There is a reason I mentioned FDA approved equipment though - it is substantially more expensive to have that label (despite being able to purchase items that claim similar parameters, those need to be exhaustively tested). Despite this, the statement that purchasing some types of equipment for your home and using it regularly, is still often far cheaper than going to the physicians office and getting a test once. I suppose I am a bit out of the typical demographic though, as I would rather use my own TEM made in my garage to do quick analyses of lab materials than take it to my colleagues across the hall and sign up for a slot on their more resolute EM. Being able to work independently and have your own data is a nice thing sometimes.