5 ms·
s/^Academic/American &/ Not that other economies tertiary education isn't similar. Some better, some worse for the ratio of tenured to non tenured.
by ggm 4y ago
s/^Academic/American &/
Not that other economies tertiary education isn't similar. Some better, some worse for the ratio of tenured to non tenured.
- skissane 4y agoIndeed, in the English-speaking world there are two main systems of academic ranks: the North American system (primarily US and Canada) and the traditional British system (most of the rest of it). This article is discussing the first system without acknowledging the second, or the differences between the two.
- jholman 4y agoThe scope of the article is in the first sentence.
- ggm 4y agoThe author is no stranger to reading and research about matters considerably more complex than the nature of tertiary educational organisation worldwide and has an extensive readership outside the USA. If this was about Roman era educational norms he'd have done a French metric tonne more work.
- jholman 4y agoAgain, who are you to determine what he chooses to write about? Your entire framing of what is going on is simply off-base, so the point you attempt to make about Devereaux's competence is beside the point. He is choosing to write about the American academic industry, incidentally speaking far more about the humanities than about other fields. The title of the article simplifies that, as all article titles do. That's just how titles work. He has researched his subject fairly extensively, as far as I can tell. If you want an article about non-American academy, perhaps including STEM fields, write the damn article yourself.
- ggm 4y agoNobody decides what he writes but himself. I read the blog frequently and they're well written and researched. I'm tired of Americentrism, and I think this piece would have been better for a wider sweep. I'm interested in how it differs from Japan, or Germany or the UK. I'd be interested in how an American academic understands this.
- jholman 4y agoThat makes sense to me.
- skissane 4y agoEven if you are going to limit your scope, a brief expression of awareness of things beyond it is called for-something absent here. Furthermore, the scope seems arbitrarily limited - it isn’t just the US system, the Canadian system is largely the same as far as ranks go - so why is the scope described as just “American”, as opposed to “US and Canada”?
- labster 4y agoThe author is a Roman military history PhD talking about his personal experience in academia for the most part. It’s not hard to see the current system is broken, after all, but only if you’re in the middle of it. There are other sources if you want an in-depth view; the target audience is people who don’t even know what an adjunct is.
- denton-scratch 4y agoThe author is also very much a teacher; his goal, I think, is to educate primarily his own students, firstly in how to do history, and secondly in how not to fail as a student. He's written more than one article along these lines. Perhaps the shortage of navigation is a problem if you're just dipping in, or skimming. I check out Devereaux's blog every Friday, and if the article is interesting, I plough through the whole thing, including the footnotes. If I wanted to do history at Uni, I'd like to have him as my teacher.
- mnky9800n 4y agoThe author says they only have worked in the American system. Having worked in the USA, Japan, and Europe in academia I find that American academics don't typically know the system in America isn't the same everywhere else.
- tough 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Americentrism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Americentrism Extends to anything really. Hard to know better when you never left your country. (Majority of Americans don't hold a Passport)
- ljlolel 4y agoMajority of Europeans haven’t left Europe. It’s true anywhere.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- skissane 4y ago> Majority of Europeans haven’t left Europe. That’s not an apples-to-apples comparison. The US is a country, and Europe is a continent containing almost 50 separate countries. And before anyone says “US states are like countries”-the states of the US are no more “like countries” than the states of Germany are Only 40% of Americans own a passport, compared to 76% of people in the UK - https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-42586638 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-42586638
- panda888888 4y agoOther countries also use different systems. For instance, Israel traditionally only has two ranks: "Professor" which is someone who has tenure, and "Lecturer" which is anyone without tenure.
- skissane 4y ago> Israel traditionally only has two ranks: "Professor" which is someone who has tenure, and "Lecturer" which is anyone without tenure. That’s not what Wikipedia says: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academic_ranks_in_Israel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academic_ranks_in_Israel According to Wikipedia, Israel traditionally uses a hybrid of the British and German systems, including the British rank of “senior lecturer”, albeit Technion has renamed that to the American “associate professor”
- mgaunard 4y agoIn my experience they're all pretty much the same. There is teaching-only/research-only and teaching-and-research. teaching-and-research is the standard, research-only the elite, and teaching-only is usually seen as "not real professors". Then for each of those the levels are student, temp, junior, senior. They all have different names for some reason instead of straightforward ones, because egos. Some of the combinations don't exist, in particular for teaching-only. In general due to limited junior/senior positions, there is a massive amount of people at temp level, sometimes indefinitely. The article above mostly rants about how the majority of the teaching is done by the teaching-only staff (as you would expect), and how they should be given more consideration. The truth is that the worth of a professor is measured by his research, not his teaching.
- kryptiskt 4y ago"The article above mostly rants about how the majority of the teaching is done by the teaching-only staff (as you would expect), and how they should be given more consideration." It's a rant about being slotted into a system where it's next to impossible to get into the "good" track, from the "bad" position. "The truth is that the worth of a professor is measured by his research, not his teaching." Which means it is pretty fucked up that two-thirds of the academic faculty is never given the opportunity to prove their worth. It's of course even worse than that, because there is only a minority of minted PhDs that can even secure such a position. All in all, it looks even worse than STEM, where there at least is temporary research roles for junior faculty.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoHumanities departments at universities in the US have been getting smaller, and more professorship slots are moving towards STEM, in general. However, this has come at the end of a tremendous growth cycle in the humanities if you zoom out to the last 50-100 years. It also seems like more "traditional" fields like History and English are being replaced by Psychology, Sociology, and [x] Studies, which seem to have a very different focus. Even in STEM, only about 10% of PhDs from top-tier universities go on to become professors. A small fraction of the rest end up adjuncting, but a much bigger fraction take the escape hatch into industry. A PhD in history basically only prepares you to be a history professor, though, so I imagine that the escape hatch is much more narrow in that field.