4 ms·
Bullshit. Space is definitely 3D and has 3D packing. Starlink is at about 550km. That has an orbital period of 1.5917hrs. Satellites are 7m (as suggested above,
by godelski 4y ago
Bullshit. Space is definitely 3D and has 3D packing. Starlink is at about 550km. That has an orbital period of 1.5917hrs. Satellites are 7m (as suggested above, but this sounds large). So let's space the next group by 10km. Now the orbital period is 1.5952hrs. We have to go to 580km (+30km) to get to 1.6hrs, which is a difference of 37 seconds. So you got 60km (520km-580km) where you have an error rate of under 1% (0.65%). That drift per day is easily accounted for and you're not going to have a destructive resonance event during the lifetime of the satellites.
For comparison, the ISS (~420km orbit) has a natural decay of 2km per year. It's safe to say that you can pack these satellites <1km in orbital height without realistic risk of them running into one another. The real problem is tracking everything and we often have large margins of safety. Sure, you won't pack them like you would oranges, but even several kms apart that can create a pretty dense coverage map. Gravitational orbits aren't electron orbits and don't need to be quantized (at least on the tens of km level).
- Veedrac 4y agoI'm not considering such concerns at all; my comment holds even considering perfect orbits followed by frictionless point objects of zero mass. You can of course pack into the height-dimension trivially when using circular orbits; the issue then is how many orbits you can pack into an orbital plane. I contend it scales with radius, not radius squared.
- about3fitty 4y agoAlso, it is kind of like an extreme version of the risks of flying cars. One hubcap/collision can mean catastrophic downstream effects.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoThe problem with your model is all orbits at a given altitude intersect. You can orbit at the equator, or orbit above and below the equator thus crossing the equator. There’s nothing special about the equator here. All polar orbits meet at the poles, and any non polar obit is forced to cross all polar orbits etc. In practice this is not be a significant problem because you can pack a great deal of satellites at a given altitude and moving to a slightly lower or higher orbit works just fine.
- godelski 4y ago> The problem with your model is all orbits at a given altitude intersect. > In practice this is not be a significant problem Which is really why I didn't bring it up. We didn't even talk about eccentricity. My model is simple but this is HN, so I added magnitudes of error.
- chaboud 4y agoHuh. I wasn’t worried before reading this thread. Now I’m a little more worried. 1. We don’t need to worry about Kessler syndrome, as the orbits of Starlink will decay in five years (from 550km). 2. ISS is at 420km. Has anyone else ever worked with something dangerous dangling over their heads? It’s kind of nerve wracking, even if you know that there’s very little chance of it falling and hitting you.
- sandworm101 4y agoThe moon seems pretty stable up there. Doesn't rattle my nerves on iota that it is overhead.
- chaboud 4y agoThe moon is slowly getting farther away. Starlink satellites are expected to relatively quickly return to earth.
- Retric 4y agoThe moon is gaining velocity from earth’s rotation which is a finite energy source, given a long enough timescales it would collide with earth. However, the sun is going to consume the earth before that happens.
- chaboud 4y agoI'll put $10 up against that bet. In a few billion years, one of us is going to look pretty stupid!
- gpm 4y agoThere's no real chance of starlink satellites falling and hitting you. They're designed to fall out of orbit at the end of their lifespan (or whenever something goes wrong), and fully burn up in the atmosphere before reaching the ground.
- 4y ago
- sandworm101 4y agoComparing our terrestrial notion of 2 or 3d space with orbital positions doesn't solve much. Low orbit is a very different area requiring we drop traditional notions of size and speed.
- Tepix 4y agoYou could just have left out the word bullshit, you know?