3 ms·
There is a valuable lesson here from WWII. Even the winners lose. It is remarkable to look back and see how the Germans lost the war, had their state destroyed
by roenxi 4y ago
There is a valuable lesson here from WWII. Even the winners lose. It is remarkable to look back and see how the Germans lost the war, had their state destroyed and still managed to take out the British Empire. If the British had lost WWII, they'd have ended suddenly and ignominiously. Being on the winning side, they've faced a relatively graceful decline into an international non-entity over 70 years. But at the end of the day their power was broken.
There are lessons here for the Americans - the US may reasonably expect to win any war it gets in to with Russia and China, but if it actually ends up fighting it could still end up shattered. There are no real winners if a fight escalates.
- Incipient 4y agoGenerally war is a net zero endeavour, sure. I'm not sure if WW2 necessarily 'broke' English power? They were in decline before they, as the US is in decline now. War or no, the outcomes seem to be the same?
- roenxi 4y agoEveryone everywhere is always in decline. Including the groups that go from strength to strength. The Byzantine Empire was in decline for more than a millennium. The UK came out of WWII looking at the bleak ruins of a country. It was quite a bit worse than net-zero, they lost a lot of real wealth. To the point where India immediately discovered it had enough power to go their own way (a net win for the world at large, but still the proximate cause was the collapse of British strength leading to an implosion of the empire). The lesson here is when you have a good thing going, provoking a big war will cause change and the good thing will go elsewhere. Keynes warned them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Economic_Consequences_of_the_Peace https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Economic_Consequences_of_t...
- skissane 4y agoWhen Alexander the Great conquered Persia, he encouraged his generals to marry wives from Persian aristocratic families. He also conquered a small part of northern India (now part of Pakistan); no doubt if he had conquered more of it he would have extended the same policy to India. Can you imagine the British in their rule of India ever encouraging the sons and daughters of their leading families to court the children of the leading families of India? Which I think was part of why the British Empire failed - many ancient empires, conqueror and conquered mingled to the point that people forgot who was which. The British viewed themselves as superior and apart from their conquests, which prevented their conquests from coming to identify as “British”, in same way as many peoples conquered by ancient Rome came to see themselves as “Roman”. In the end, there was nothing to hold the Empire together.
- neovialogistics 4y agoThis is ignoring the extensive efforts of the USA in the 40s-70s to empower Britain's colonies and enable their self-determination. The British Empire did not exist in a vacuum.
- skissane 4y agoI don’t think I was “ignoring” anything - I pointed out one causal factor, you point out another. All these historical events have multiple causes, and my suggestion and yours aren’t mutually exclusive.
- csomar 4y agoI agree with this too. Britain (or the ruler of the common wealth) draw lots of its power from its colonies (especially middle-east oil producing colonies). Britain lost the war, and the US forced its hands out of these colonies. I think, if the British were say Chinese or Japanese, the US would have probably cut it directly out of existence. But what happened was an overall "peaceful" transition of power from Britain to the US. It was also gradual as the British still have/had influence lately (ie: HSBC) but the decline has more to do with the US taking "their" place than the British failing to modernize.
- skissane 4y ago> Britain lost the war, and the US forced its hands out of these colonies. > the decline has more to do with the US taking "their" place than the British failing to modernize. Rather than the US replacing the UK as colonial power, the US pushed for the colonies to become independent - at which point many of them moved out of US control - such as by trying to play the Americans and Soviets off against each other through the Non-Aligned Movement > I think, if the British were say Chinese or Japanese, the US would have probably cut it directly out of existence. I wonder if the US really would have forced China to give up its control over Tibetans, Uyghurs, Mongols (in Inner Mongolia), Manchus, among others. Even though you can argue that China didn’t “lose” as such, I’m not sure the US would have treated them much differently if they had “lost” in the way the UK did (as an ally which had won a Pyrrhic victory)
- polotics 4y agoWar has been a net negative the world over for all time. Please find me an example of net zero!