3 ms·
I disagree with your conclusion that such a system is inherently not intelligent. If you accept that humans are intelligent, and that they can judge that anoth
by baddox 15y ago
I disagree with your conclusion that such a system is inherently not intelligent.
If you accept that humans are intelligent, and that they can judge that another human is intelligent by conversing with them across a text-only channel, then you run into a big problem by stating that a Turing-test-passing algorithm is unintelligent. To do so would expose the fact that your definition of "intelligence" secretly includes the class "...and is a human," which makes "intelligent machine" a contradiction of terms. It is essentially an example of the No True Scotsman fallacy, because you're revealing a new facet of your claim when faced with an apparent counterexample.
If you're defining "intelligence" to be a purely human trait, then come right out and say so, and everyone will agree that on your terms a machine cannot be intelligent. Of course, I would argue that such a definition isn't very useful, since it basically means that the adjectives "intelligent" and "humans" are synonyms.
- grannyg00se 15y ago"If you accept that humans are intelligent, and that they can judge that another human is intelligent by conversing with them across a text-only channel, then you run into a big problem by stating that a Turing-test-passing algorithm is unintelligent. " I would say that passing the Turing test is a necessary but insufficient measure of complete human intelligence. It would be astounding, and a major feat in the field, but there must be more to the definition of human intellect than simply carrying on a text conversation.
- baddox 15y agoIf humans can't recognize intelligence, then we won't be able come up with some other test to recognize intelligence.
- grannyg00se 15y agoAgreed. But we'd have to agree on what standard of intelligence we're considering. Turing is only one standard. And I would say not a very high one if being compared to human intelligence.
- burgerbrain 15y agoEh.. The Turing test (Turing was a man, and the Turing test is a concept posed by him) is restricted in the way that it is to eliminate irrelevant factors such as robotics. The concept itself that is presented is quite sound: If you cannot tell that it's not intelligent, how can you say that it is not? I cannot think of a better test. The only weak point as I see it does not say anything one way or the other about intelligence that is fundamentally different from our own (for example: doesn't happen to use natural language).
- wlievens 15y agoI would think it depends entirely on the subject matter of the text conversation. It's probably possible today to make a chat bot that can converse about (nothing other than) the weather.