3 ms·
> Rights to property, life and liberty need to be encoded in the legal constraints that restrict free markets in unobvious ways. These rights are not restricti
by WalterBright 4y ago
> Rights to property, life and liberty need to be encoded in the legal constraints that restrict free markets in unobvious ways.
These rights are not restrictions on the free market. They are fundamental to the free market.
> Your rights to life and liberty sometimes conflict with my rights to life and liberty.
They don't. Your right to life, for example, does not require me to give you food. It means I cannot take your life. Your right to liberty means I cannot enslave you. There is no right to enslave another, regardless of what the law says.
When I say "legal fiction" I mean writing laws that attempt to change reality. For example, a law that says π == 3 is a legal fiction. Your rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are not a legal fiction. The government frequently tries to create new "rights" that are not rights at all.
Put another way, the government enforces rights, or abrogates them. It cannot invent them.
Inalienable means it's an inherent property of being a human being. I.e. people still have a right to liberty, even if the government says it's ok to enslave them.
Evidence? Communism tries to deny the right to property. The result is communist countries cannot even feed themselves. Slavery tries to deny the right to liberty. The result is a also poorly performing economy. Countries that guarantee the rights to life, liberty, and property thrive.
One can sign a contract that enslaves you, but it is unenforceable in a free society. John Deere sells you a tractor but retains the "right" to remotely disable it? I'd say that would be unenforceable as they sold it to you, meaning it's yours to do with it as you please.
If they wanted to rent it to you, it should be a rental agreement, not a sales agreement.
- robocat 4y agoI apologise, but I find almost every point you make to be opaque and incomprehensible. Perhaps we have different axioms. Perhaps it is a language barrier. Perhaps we have different logical dependencies. I sincerely appreciate your efforts to enlighten me: it is a shame that it is so very difficult to communicate using only a few written sentences. Cheers