4 ms·
So someone explain this to me.. how is this "sexist"? That to me takes on an air of discrimination. I didn't see any undertones, nor would those (assumed by the
by Karunamon 15y ago
So someone explain this to me.. how is this "sexist"? That to me takes on an air of discrimination. I didn't see any undertones, nor would those (assumed by the author) undertones exist if the gender roles were reversed.
This "controversy" seems like a lot of bunkola, to me.
- rimantas 15y agoThe case is lost. Seems like people are not able to get the difference any more. If you mention skin color, you are racist, no matter that context. If you mention attractiveness or feminine side of someone you are sexist. If you talk to a child, you are a pedophile.
- arnnr 15y agoTotally agree. If you mind expanding on why, I'd love hearing your opinion. Remember for example when Sylvio Berlusconi made a mediocre joke about Obama's tan how the correctness cannibals went frantic. Funny thing that the racist card was pulled by the people who actually had a taboo with skin colors.
- rmc 15y agoSomething can be both a compliment and sexist. Especially if it's a compliment that has a lot of baggage and assumptions. There is a history women only being viewed as good for marriage and babies. It used to be seen as unusual & unnatural for a woman to not want babies and marriage. It was seen as weird for a woman to want to focus on carrer rather than marriage. Also they were viewed as "nice to look at, but unable to do any real work". Things have gotten a lot better, but there are still bits of this attitude around. If you compliment a woman based on (a) getting married and (b) physical attractiveness, you are slightly re-inforcing that meme. You are also signaling that you might be the sort of person who thinks the above, or that you support the above attitudes. After all, would you compliment a Jewish speaker about how much money they had? Or compliment an older man about how they haven't needed to go to the toilet in a while?
- Karunamon 15y ago>If you compliment a woman based on (a) getting married and (b) physical attractiveness, you are slightly re-inforcing that meme. You are also signaling that you might be the sort of person who thinks the above, or that you support the above attitudes. What utter rubbish. So getting married isn't something compliment worthy? A compliment based on physical attractiveness is always sexist? Absurd.
- rmc 15y agoSo getting married isn't something compliment worthy? A compliment based on physical attractiveness is always sexist? No, but you'll need to find a way to not imply that that's all a woman is good for. This is not easy, so it's easier to just not mention it. Maybe in a few generations when this isn't as much of a problem we can come back to it.
- Karunamon 15y ago>No, but you'll need to find a way to not imply that that's all a woman is good for. How in the hell do you read "All you're good for is having kids" into "Congratulations on getting married!"? Again. Absurd.
- rmc 15y agoBack in the day (i.e. when Mad Men is set and before), no-one said: "All you're good for is having kids". They didn't directly say that a lot. It was more like pointed reminders that someone was attractive. Or that someone wasn't married, or that someone is finally married (in the vein of "congrats on you finally graduating from college! you're a real person now!"). Or that someone "will make some man very happy", etc. There is a lot of tradition of impling that the most important thing for a woman is to be married. That's the whole thing. So when you mention, in a setting with few women (and hence more susceptible to sexism), that someone is married, it might sound half like the old ways.
- AlexandrB 15y ago
- ben0x539 15y agoIf you reversed the gender roles, it wouldn't be sexism because discrimination is when you're, get this, discriminating against an oppressed group and not just being a jerk in general.
- Karunamon 15y agoThat's only the legal description of discrimination, not the practical one.