6 ms·
More Young Adults Are Living Paycheck to Paycheck in the US
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rjbwork 4y agoHigh inflation and decades of disparity in productivity gains vs compensation combined with massive cost of living increases has led much of the younger generations to completely give up on building wealth. They don't think they'll ever own a house or retire, so why would they attempt to save?
- recursivedoubts 4y agoexactly why produce surplus value if you capture none of it?
- toomuchtodo 4y agoIn China, this started as “lie flat” and turned into “let it rot.” It’s also a contributing factor in driving down the fertility rate. https://www.scmp.com/yp/discover/lifestyle/article/3194858/lying-flat-letting-it-rot-why-chinas-frustrated-youth-are https://www.scmp.com/yp/discover/lifestyle/article/3194858/l... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/20/the-last-generation-young-chinese-people-vow-not-to-have-children https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/20/the-last-gener...
- twoheadedboy 4y agoCan't help but think this is a consequence of social media. People have dramatically unrealistic expectations on what life should be like.
- mrguyorama 4y agoAh yes, dramatically unrealistic, like functioning public transport, or affordable healthcare, or OWNING A PLACE TO LIVE
- dwmbt 4y agointeresting hypothesis, but my subjective rebuttal is that nearly all of my friends would readily admit that they'd be perfectly content with building a life similar to that of their parents. most kids just don't think it's possible. i asked in the parent comment if this is a normal thing? my parents were immigrants, so they don't have the experience of growing up here. it's always been an uphill battle. perhaps i've inherited that mentality but i wonder if americans of previous generations were also 23 and cynical, never thinking it possible to afford building a comfortable life?
- kitsunesoba 4y agoThat may be a component, but I think another thing that contributes is that unlike Gen X which still somewhat bought into the "American dream", many Millennials and Gen Z watched their parents struggle and ultimately burn out growing up and decided they don't want their lives to be like that. Why constantly stress and sacrifice enjoying today for the sake of an almost entirely fictional tomorrow?
- hellotomyrars 4y agoI think the FOMO and enhanced hyper consumerism it enables contributes, but the actual macroeconomic factors around wage growth, etc. are the real problem.
- AmericanChopper 4y agoGrowth in productivity is driven by technology, not quality of labor.
- ericjmorey 4y agoProductivity of what?
- AmericanChopper 4y agoThe productivity of labor. Which is simply revenue per hour of labor. When people talk about the increase in worker productivity, that measurement is simply GDP divided by number of hours worked in the economy. That number has gone up recently, and many people who don’t know what productivity is actually measuring like to comment on the fact that the increase is productivity hasn’t been met with an increase in wages. But that increase has been driven by technology, and the people who are responsible for that increase in productivity capture the value. The people who sell the technology, not the people who sell the labor.
- rurp 4y agoSkilled labor isn't more productive than unskilled?
- AmericanChopper 4y agoSkilled labor isn’t new, and it’s not what’s driven the increase in productivity. I can implement useful computer programs today far faster than Dennis Ritchie could in the 70s, even though he’s far more skilled than I am. That difference in productivity is entirely due to advancements in technology.
- recursivedoubts 4y agoTrue in general, but you'll be surprised how quickly things can fall apart when labor stops laboring.
- VoodooJuJu 4y agoI'd love to save and build wealth, and I'm doing just that, it's just the amount I have left over to save is very small. I won't be able to buy a house until I'm in my 40's or 50's, but it's better than never being able to afford a house, I guess. At least my kids can inherit it and start from a more prosperous place.
- Marsymars 4y ago> At least my kids can inherit it and start from a more prosperous place. How does that work, timing-wise? Like my partner and I are in our mid-30s and both have parents who own houses, and with good luck with their health there won't be anything to inherit for several more decades.
- VoodooJuJu 4y agoI might just retire to a humble shack in the backyard once my firstborn is ready to start a family. Early inheritance.
- mrguyorama 4y agoThe end of life care industry will take every single cent you have, and state paid end of life care doesn't kick in until you are destitute. Middle class people passing stuff down to their kids isn't a thing anymore.
- maxerickson 4y agoYou can transfer $12 million with no gift tax, so if you want to pass something down instead of reserving it for end of life care, it's no problem. https://www.schwab.com/learn/story/estate-tax-and-lifetime-gifting https://www.schwab.com/learn/story/estate-tax-and-lifetime-g... Obviously that's more beneficial to people with a lot of assets than to someone with less, but for instance, a parent might choose to gift the house they live in to their children well prior to end of life care being a consideration (of course that will be very situational; do they want to stay in that house, do they have a good relationship, etc., etc.). Medicaid won't consider the primary residence when examining assets to pay for care, but it may try to capture some of the estate after death.
- maxerickson 4y agoIs it true though? It's probably the case that the wealth gap inside generations is much larger than any wealth gap between generations. https://qz.com/millennials-are-just-as-wealthy-as-their-parents-1850149896 https://qz.com/millennials-are-just-as-wealthy-as-their-pare... So of course there are young people that are not doing well financially, just like there are people of other ages that are not doing well financially.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoLack of stable work is also an issue. I have the income to be building wealth, but every time I have to find a new job, it takes 5~6 months. I lose a lot of money in that time. Insurance costs two to three times my mortgage. On top of that, I'm not contributing to any retirement accounts while I'm out of work. I'm single with no children living in a cheap house in Ohio. I also don't have any debt beyond my mortgage. My 401k is maxed out. Roughly 25% of my net income goes into my savings, which I only touch for things like a new roof. And I still can't manage to secure my future retirement.
- armchairhacker 4y agoYou would save so things don't get worse. At least so that if you get laid off or your boss gets replaced with someone terrible, you can live off your savings until you find a new job.
- dwmbt 4y agoyoung adult here (23m) with a normal salary (not FAANG, definitely underpaid but still above the american average). sometimes, i'll find that i'm willing to save costs at the expense of sacrificing my health. among other doubts, i've reconciled with the idea that i'll likely never own property of my own. there's too much debt to take care of and over time, things continue to get more expensive. i grew up in a modest home. when my parents bought it, it was worth ~100k. not much has changed, we added some stone to the porch and an outdoor kitchen. it's worth nearly a million now. anecdotal? possibly, but certainly not a rare case. on average, how am i supposed to afford a home if the trajectory for a normal suburban life is that prices more than 2x every 20 years? [0] even so, i find that year after year, i'm losing trust in the future of this country. 23 and entirely jaded. i cannot find it in myself to invest any energy in building a future here. mostly, i'm cynical and scared. i find that most of my friends are the same. was it always like this? is losing faith in your country a rite of passage into adulthood? does it get better over time? will i ever make enough to feel safe? etc. [0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ASPUS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/ASPUS
- realce 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=thLgkQBFTPw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=thLgkQBFTPw It's the era, it's not you.
- antisthenes 4y agoHow do you know you're underpaid? I've literally never heard anyone say they are overpaid. Is it just ego?
- speakfreely 4y agoIt's not your imagination. Anyone who owned a house before the 2000s and held it simply won the lottery. 1950 Median home value (inflation-adjusted to 2020 dollars): $79,063 1960 Median home price (inflation-adjusted to 2020 dollars): $104,166 1970 Median home price (inflation-adjusted to 2020 dollars): $112,941 1980 Median home price (inflation-adjusted to 2020 dollars): $147,879 1990 Median home price (inflation-adjusted to 2020 dollars): $157,169 2000 Median home price (inflation-adjusted to 2020 dollars): $179,331 2010 Median home price (inflation-adjusted to 2020 dollars): $263,604 2020 Median home price (inflation-adjusted to 2020 dollars): $336,900 [0] https://better.com/content/how-much-home-prices-have-risen-since-1950/ https://better.com/content/how-much-home-prices-have-risen-s...
- Swizec 4y ago> They don't think they'll ever own a house or retire, so why would they attempt to save? That’s exactly what the winners of our class war want you to think. War of attrition. They want everyone to give up and stop trying. Spend all your money, stay dependent on their crumbs, perfection.
- Kylekramer 4y agoPaycheck to paycheck surveys are just vibes, last time these companies ran this survey 36% of people making over $250k said they were living paycheck to paycheck: https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/03/wealthier-americans-live-paycheck-to-paycheck-after-inflation-spike.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/03/wealthier-americans-live-pay... It is cool for young people to doom over money and spend all day looking at much richer people on on social media. Main character syndrome.
- endisneigh 4y agothe fact that this post is downvoted shows how much of a bubble HN is, lol.
- lbotos 4y agoSomeone could be Making 250k and absolutely be living paycheck to paycheck. Yes, I agree with your sentiment that its "different" than being "poor" but that's the media for ya.
- hellotomyrars 4y agoI understand the point though. Living paycheck to paycheck making 250K is either a gross mismanagement of finances, or a dishonest view of them. The guy making 250K a year isn’t worried about not being able to put food on the table. But maybe he has a monthly car payment that is more than the person making 28k a year pays per month in rent.
- cj 4y agoIf it’s just a survey, I would answer “yes” to living paycheck to paycheck. But that’s only because I’m automatically investing 70% of my paycheck so I never have more than a few weeks of expenses in cash. I can imagine getting very biased results depending on how to survey is worded. In my case, an unexpected expense just means I take a short term margin loan against my portfolio (at an insane interest rate) until my next paycheck.
- 4y ago
- mt-t 4y ago[flagged]
- _chu1 4y agoClearly the solution would be to stop dumping money where it doesn't need to be, like the war machines of various countries that serve no real purpose to us.
- liotier 4y agoThe USA benefits greatly from its international position. That position isn't borne from natural order, but from wielding the USA's strengths - including military strength. Arming allies is part of that, and it is especially smart when they fight those who threaten the USA or the USA's allies. Isolationism is a quick way to lose power so, even if all you see is budgetary accounting, the purpose of hard power should be clear to you.
- _chu1 4y agoWill Ukraine defeating Russia do anything to make my life better? Will Israel existing fix the gas prices?
- addisonl 4y agoThese are awfully similar to Russian propaganda taking points, relatively new account, reader beware.
- _chu1 4y agoLOL. This is an 8 month old account, but no I'm actually a KGB ultraspy warlord with golden AKs or whatever. All I want is for my country to stop pouring billions of dollars into fueling our imperialistic desires and doing the opposite of it's original job which was safeguarding our freedom and rights.
- jamesgill 4y agoMore of all age groups are living paycheck to paycheck. This isn't a generational thing, it's a disappearing-middle-class thing. And not just in the US.
- balderdash 4y agothis would be more concerning to me vs young people living paycheck to paycheck
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Random_Person 4y agoI'm 44 and have only achieved savings within the past year and a half. I live a very modest life and have always TRIED to live below my means, but living off of my government salary was challenging. I received a ~18k raise 2 years ago and I'm finally able to live "comfortably".
- boh 4y agoSurvey-based research is unrepresentative since it's exclusively completed by people who actually complete surveys (an idiosyncratic minority).
- balderdash 4y agoI would have thought young adults living paycheck to paycheck was the expected historical norm?
- MattPalmer1086 4y agoI certainly had no surplus at all until I was well into my 30s. And then the dot com crash caused me to take lower paid work and I burned through the savings I had. Wasn't until I was in my 40s before I could say I had some spare cash, then I had a kid! This is the UK, but I think it's fairly normal.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoI save around 100 a year liquid (very, very far from paycheck to paycheck). I have felt very wealthy relative to my desired lifestyle. And yeah, I can buy pretty much anything I want. But now, thinking about having kids at some point and thinking about college, I do not feel this way. Idk what to do about that. I'm not convinced I'm saving enough. But ffs, it feels grossly excessive for my current state.
- hellotomyrars 4y ago100K a year for a child (And possibly an additional dependent, not sure if you’ve already got the other half or want it) is a hell of a lot more than most people have for an entire family. If you’re really able to just hold on to that money and squirrel it away without spending it frivolously then it’s hard to imagine it not being enough.
- zackmorris 4y agoHas anyone asked young people how they would reform the system? Or created a tree of who the money funnels to for analysis? In my experience, workers know exactly what to do to improve their situations, but are denied that agency over their lives. And that's what poverty is - having no agency over your life. The smallest step above slavery. My experience has been one of endless struggle over a lifetime, starting in the late 90s when the Clinton administration lifted the separation between savings and investment banking with the Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act, turning the US into a giant game of Monopoly again like it was in the 1920s. The Dot Bomb, Housing Bubble popping, Great Recession, even our descent into global authoritarianism, is all theater. The real kicker is that it was by design, to rein in Gen X and the hippies before them to prop up moneyed elites in the capitalist class. Hurt people hurt people, down people stay down. Exploited people vote against their own self-interest. There's no money for workers because you invest and expect a return for doing nothing other than having money. Neither a borrower nor a lender be. The really sadistic part is that there's infinite money available for construction, or giving tax breaks to companies moving to a new city, pork barrel projects, etc. But no small business loans for 2 person startups. No Uber-like system for industry roles so that people can work at-will. No affordable health insurance, no retirement provided for jobs under about $50k, no affordable college, few worker-owned co-ops, etc etc etc. The answer is the same as it has always been: tax the rich. All other answers are platitudes.
- BigCryo 4y agoPeople appear to be working to live and not living to work! This is an outrage!! They need to be working harder and longer and improving our sacred GDP