3 ms·
Am I the only one who finds the language "C class talent" really distasteful? I feel like it's worse than referring to your employees as "human resources". I u
by erikpukinskis 15y ago
Am I the only one who finds the language "C class talent" really distasteful? I feel like it's worse than referring to your employees as "human resources".
I understand the importance of passing on people who are a close-but-in-the-end-imperfect fit for your organization. But using the concept of class and grading people from A to F just makes my skin crawl, and it makes me want to avoid any company or organization who things about people that way, YC included.
Am I the only one?
- gabaix 15y agoI am used to it. It is a terminology shortcut to qualify people's actions. You'll find that from a lot people coming from universities. They tend to compare themselves a lot and use statistical horizontal comparisons. If not from HR, it is mostly to imply they are part of the A group.
- kmfrk 15y agoI think it's fine as long as you don't think people are born ABC. You have to draw the line, and you have to be able to recognize talent - and the lack of such.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mahyarm 15y agoI feel the same. I think the original concept also came from what kind of GPA a person got in university, which makes it even more distasteful.
- justincormack 15y agoAh is that what it is. It makes no sense in other parts of the world.
- byrneseyeview 15y agoI would find it unpleasant to be called "C-class talent," but I'd also find it unpleasant to get a C. In both cases, that would prompt me to either step up my game or reconsider my priorities. People are unequal, and in a business context, that means some people are worth less than others. You can grade them on a curve, but that just means we'll all learn that a "B" means you're a failure, and that really good companies are only recruiting among As and A+s. Differences in ability can't be fixed through semantics.
- monsterix 15y agoOn the other hand we've have noticed people branded as C-class talent kicking ass of A and A+s too, haven't we?
- markerdmann 15y agoI think you're spot on. A fun game is to ask the person using this kind of language whether they consider themselves an A, B, or C player.