4 ms·
While this is interesting, we know that self-reported “how does X make you feel” effects can be inconsistent with the delta self-reported feeling while being ex
by dragonwriter 4y ago
While this is interesting, we know that self-reported “how does X make you feel” effects can be inconsistent with the delta self-reported feeling while being exposed to X and self-reported feeling when isolated from X, and there’s a very good reason to think that the former is the less-reliable because it requires not only assessment of feeling (which people are probably fairly reliable on) but assessment of causality (which they are less likely to be reliable on).
Particularly, things that people exposed to them perceive as relieving certain negative feelings (whether of disconnection, etc.) can sometimes be relieving them only compared to an elevated baseline that they create (for, e.g., cults, this create-and-then-be-seen-as-needed-through-partial-relief–for-problem effect is often a deliberate strategy, and it may be for social media either deliberate or just a commercial optimum locked into by A/B testing engagement (creating both an elevated feeling of social isolation and need for connection and then a partial relief for that need).
Or maybe the self-reported effect is correct, and the perception social media is problematic on those points is wrong. But there is at least a plausible way the user-perceived effect could be wrong that is consistent with effects seen elsewhere.