3 ms·
> That comic required significant work on the user's part to edit the images and re-synthesize portions of each frame repeatedly while doing things like inpaint
by AnthonyMouse 4y ago
> That comic required significant work on the user's part to edit the images and re-synthesize portions of each frame repeatedly while doing things like inpainting, outpainting, re-prompting, etc. And likely required use of some other tools like Photoshop or Indesign (midjourney absolutely did not generate the bubbles or comic book text).
The issue is that the AI's output is deterministic, and the prompts it uses are commonly too short to be eligible for copyright, not least because someone else could plausibly use the same prompt independently. With the same seed, the AI would then produce the same image. Or produce a similar image in response to a similar prompt.
If you could copyright that, you then have an enforcement problem, because the usual way to show copying is similarity, but you can then have two images that are similar yet independent. And some light Photoshop work is not going to eliminate the similarity.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoIf someone builds a device that sprays paint onto a canvas based on some parameters, and then a person use those parameters, writes a small controller that sprays the paint a specific way, manually adjusts the position of the device over multiple sessions, and does their own touchups to create a piece of art, would they not hold the copyright on the resulting piece? Yes, there is a deterministic component (although, to my knowledge, the AI tools aren't actually deterministic over their parameters). But the resulting work involves a lot of human creativity and intervention.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoSuppose you have a printer with a programmable head which can be used to print out arbitrary images. Can you copyright the pictures it can print, even though the printing is done by machine? Obviously. But then it's not the machine choosing what you want on the page.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoPerhaps my analogy wasn't clear. I meant, the painting device uses your parameters, but also supplies some modifications. Like a stenograph. At the end of the day, generative AI, Stenograph, and this painting device are all tools. If you shake a kaleidoscope and then take a picture through the lens, I'm pretty sure you have copyright on that photograph, even though someone else made the kaleidoscope
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoIt's not the presence of a machine which makes it ineligible for copyright. It's the absence of some independent creative expression. If you add significant creative expression to what the machine does, that's not the same thing as the output of a machine produced from a minimal input.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoWhat we're talking about here is definitely art where a human is providing independent creative expression, in combination with generative tools
- pmoriarty 4y ago"The issue is that the AI's output is deterministic" Point a digital camera at a still scene under controlled lighting conditions and it's pretty deterministic also. Anyway, it's easy enough to add randomness to the AI image generation process (and Midjourney does do that by default, as a matter of face), so the process need not be deterministic at all.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoIt's not about the physics of light, it's about what the artist chooses to have in the scene. And it's not randomness that fixes it. Do you even want to get into the information theory problems if you could copyright the output of a random number generator? What you need is for someone to be making creative choices with enough entropy to be considered original and not be reproducible by feeding a short sentence to an existing algorithm.
- IYasha 4y agoI really like how you put it. Good thought! But I don't quite agree that entropy is a criteria of originality. Because originality is not ranodmness, it's... distinctiveness.