3 ms·
> The Fourth Amendment, for example, protects more narrowly against search in the context of criminal prosecution: no prosecution, no rights violation. False.
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> The Fourth Amendment, for example, protects more narrowly against search in the context of criminal prosecution: no prosecution, no rights violation.
False.
Fourth Amendment violations can be the basis for civil liability (or in some cases criminal liability) for the offender, even if no prosecution occurs. Qualified immunity and other issues make this difficult sometimes, but that’s a separate issue from whether there is a violation of legal rights.
But the most familiar remedy for Fourth Amendment violations (the exclusionary rule) only applies to criminal prosecution, and only criminal prosecution of the party whose rights were violated (violating someone other than the defendant’s Fourth Amendment rights will not result in exclusion of the evidence from a criminal case.)