2 ms·
> Democracy, I think, is actually about losing gracefully and without having a revolution, not that you always get your way. If we actually lived in a true dem
by kelnos 4y ago
> Democracy, I think, is actually about losing gracefully and without having a revolution, not that you always get your way.
If we actually lived in a true democracy, then, yes, I would agree. But we don't. The US naturally degrades to an undemocratic two-party system, and apportionment gives minority citizens outsized influence. Sometimes it even gives the minority citizens a majority in governance.
> You want term limits on the current justices -- would you have been in favor of that for the justice that was giving you "yes" votes on cases?
Yes, absolutely. The problem is that the lifetime appointments cut both ways. For example, RBG fucked up: instead of doing the smart thing, stepping down years earlier (when she already had plenty of health problems), she was selfish, stayed on the bench, and was replaced by someone with views that would likely disgust her.
A term limit would make things more fair, and would have justices entering and leaving the court at predictable intervals. Of course, term limits would likely require a constitutional amendment, so that will never happen.
I was a fan of another proposal I read a couple years ago: every presidential term gets some fixed number of SCOTUS appointments (say, one or two), and the size of the court varies term-by-term based on who is or isn't retiring. When a justice retires, they aren't replaced. Presidents just get their one or two guaranteed appointments every four years, and that's it.
Of course, you still have the issue of Senate consent; we could certainly have another situation where when the Senate is controlled by a party different from the president's, they stonewall and refuse to confirm. Fixing that would of course require another constitutional amendment, so that wouldn't work. But when appointments aren't "precious", it's probably less likely that would be an issue.
> I am not in favor of suddenly finding / proposing all sorts of new rules just because a ruling didn't go your way.
This isn't sudden; people have been talking about SCOTUS reform for many years. It's just that incidents like the current one bring it back into the spotlight.