5 ms·
Forbes mocked as another '30 Under 30' honoree accused of fraud
- JCM9 4y agoThere are some good folks on these lists too but yes they do seem to attract a concentration of the narcissistic self-promotional hussle-culture types that are all hype and no substance. Folks more concerned with the appearance of doing something great than actually doing something great. Unfortunately the media falls for these types hook line and sinker hence all the magazine covers, big talks, puff media pieces and other nonsense leading up to their eventual downfall when people figure out what’s really been going on. Folks should be under no assumptions that some rigorous process goes into making up these lists. Much/most of getting on a list is the result of heavy targeted promotional efforts by folks or “their team” to get on the list hence the oddly high concentration of fraudsters and shysters. People are very serious these days when they say they’d triple check someone just because they appeared on one of these lists given the reputation for the above.
- toyg 4y agoMedia don't "fall for it", they have to fill columns / bait clicks. Do you ever get a day where news go "nothing really happened today, do something else"? No. If nothing happens, they'll make it happen. If there aren't decent candidates for "30 under 30" every year, they'll just wave in the first few hustlers pushing at the entrance.
- matthewaveryusa 4y agoThere's an assumption that 30 under 30 means "here are 30 vetted folks under 30" instead of "here are 30 people with less than 10 years experience lapping veterans, take note" -- and that note is either a techtnonic shift in an industry the old guard is asleep on, or... something else. Given the incident rate, maybe there's a more profound shift in our society. I hate the term post-truth, but maybe financiers are either more gullible, or more willing to look the other way? Nah, it's just the cheap money and the end of it will fix this up in a jiffy.
- oofta-boofta 4y agoMy old boss got written up in the local business journal's "40 under 40". To say that she's a miserable ass of a charlatan who made my work life (and pretty much anyone she's encountered) hell, this comment jives.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThe issue is not post-truth. By definition, you can't be a celebrated avant-gardiste. The people who will be lauded as precursors in the future are necessarily out of sync with what is fashionable today. That's why list aimed at celebrating promising people are doomed to be wrong more often than not. Amusingly, it also means that extremely fashionable people are less likely to be highly remembered in the far future than people marginally famous.
- neom 4y agoEarly in my career I thought it would be a cool thing to get, but as I started meeting people who touted it and so many of them were sketchy I realized... Forbes 30u30 just means I'm going to vet you extra hard.
- acyou 4y agoHow would one try to make it on one of these lists? No one said these people aren't smart or likely to succeed.
- xwdv 4y agoSince you’re aspiring to be on the list, you might already be a grifter. Might as well just put “Forbes 30 under 30” in a resume or LinkedIn profile with no context and you’ll get most of the benefit without actually being on the list. No one is going to check. If they ask just have some random placeholder website for a professional looking “tech consulting” business or something to direct people to, where the income is impossible to verify.
- acyou 4y agoAsking for a friend... In all seriousness, I was alluding to the likely way that people get on these lists. Success doesn't necessarily mean being a great technical person, it means knowing exactly where, when and how to grease the wheels. In life, being a "grifter" is often what it takes to be successful. It's a different kind of hard work. Not everyone really understands it, I wouldn't discount it.
- zachlatta 4y agoAs someone on this list, there’s an open secret that the way to get on is to get referrals from existing people and link to 1-2 articles about you. It’s not merit based and there is no rigorous evaluation. It’s also important to note that every year hundreds of people are put on Forbes 30 Under 30. They have categories like 30 Under 30 for Education, 30 Under 30 for Music, 30 Under 30 for Enterprise Software, and many many more. It’s a lot more than 30 people. Since there are so many people, there are many amazing people and inevitably scammers too. I am appreciative of the list because it helped some people take me more seriously as a young person who was trying to do something meaningful in the world, but who didn’t finish high school and wasn’t from a high net worth background.
- bloodyplonker22 4y agoThe Forbes 30 under 30 is a vanity list. People spend a lot of time marketing themselves, doing fake work, and virtue signaling in order to get on this list so they get publicity for their own vain self and their startups. The entrepreneurs under 30 that will create enduring companies are not doing this.
- fwlr 4y agoBetween investors, executives, media and the stock market, the economic dynamics of modern companies have become complex enough that not everyone loses money when fraud happens. The 30-under-30 reporting is in a weird spot where, by accident, their criteria happens to pick up those cases.
- emmelaich 4y agoForbes generally has been going downhill for a while. It often has dramatic stories about some security warning "issued" by Google or Apple or .. about their products. It doesn't help that they're 51% owned by a HongKong based company (since 2013) and have been accused by WSJ about editorial meddling in stories about China. At this point they're just parasitising the memory of the Forbes family. Hope it doesn't last too long.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoForbes has been a joke for 20 years at least.
- gnicholas 4y agoTheir reporting on Apple is uniquely bad clickbait. They want to stand out from the crowd so they manufacture bizarre takes that no one else would even think to make. I basically ignore all Forbes reporting on Apple now, after having been burned a few too many times.
- fakedang 4y agoThe Forbes family is part of the problem. The current scion (Steve Forbes) largely writes conservative drivel and attacks on social and liberal policies (such as same-sex marriage, marijuana usage, healthcare, etc.).
- selimthegrim 4y agoI can personally vouch for one of them drunkenly admitting at a college party to falsifying his HS transcripts to get into our college (years before the 30 under 30 obviously)
- UncleEntity 4y agoThey don’t require a certified transcript sent directly to the institution like every other college in the world? I never had to send HS transcripts because I started out at community college after the army but for the couple other times I did they were pretty strict on what they would accept. Humbolt State, some random private school that’s probably bankrupt now and Arizona State University (who decided I wasn’t a resident so I couldn’t take any classes there) were all this way.
- analog31 4y agoThey could have falsified falsifying their transcripts.
- selimthegrim 4y agoIIRC he snuck into the high school office and changed his grades at that point before the transcript was generated
- vxNsr 4y agoTbf most colleges these days are expensive diploma mills with a social element. I’m sure there are some degrees that are worth pursuing but apparently most students don’t take it seriously and instead try to cheat and bully their way through college.
- selimthegrim 4y agoThis was Caltech.
- ctur 4y agoTo be fair, for every one of these sub-30 wunderkinds there are dozens of 50+ year olds hoping to make a fortune by propping them up… who often avoid such public derision.
- chasing 4y agoWhat? Next you're going to tell me that Marilyn vos Savant isn't the smartest person alive.
- yowlingcat 4y agoHer last name is Savant! How could it mean that she is anything but! Yes, I have never been particularly impressed by any of the 30u30 I've met in real life, either.
- rendall 4y agoThis video by Patrick Boyle discusses it. https://youtu.be/V36kSqwjaaw https://youtu.be/V36kSqwjaaw I'm not sure it adds much information that's not already covered by the article, but it is funny.
- pshc 4y agoHere I was thinking it was merely a conduit to buying an O-1 visa.
- uptownfunk 4y agoIt’s like saying Amazon is the #1 place to work.
- enjeyw 4y agoAs someone on the list, here’s a moderating view against to the popular take of narcissists campaigning to get on the list (which definitely has some truth to it). I made no attempt to get on the list and didn’t even find out I was on the shortlist until I received a questionnaire asking for more information. Filled it out while commuting to work and forgot about it. Didn’t hear back from Forbes at any point and only found out I made it when someone messaged me to congratulate me the day it was published. Still don’t know who nominated me. Never bothered to ask. Similar to another commenter, it has been useful given I have a degree from a relatively unknown University in Australia. Maybe it’ll be more counterproductive now? Who knows…
- TwoNineFive 4y agoThere was once a CNN program named Pinnacle. I remembered watching it and then as the years went by I noticed that a large number of the executives on the program later got arrested, were accused of fraud, and other such nonsense. GM, Sunbeam, Tycho... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinnacle_(TV_program) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinnacle_(TV_program)
- TylerE 4y agoNot sure that tracks. For a show that ran for 20 years and apparently had basically every successful exec on it… odds are some percent will turn out to be frauds.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoPrevious discussion of topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35478675 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35478675 (32 comments)
- reso 4y agoI went to a birthday party once for a guy who just got on 30 under 30. The facebook event (made by him) was called "Mr. 30 under 30's Birthday". The whole event was presented with deliberate irony, as if to say "Wouldn't it be funny if I was such a narcissist that I couldn't stop telling people I'm on the Forbes 30 under 30?" And he was right.
- automatoney 4y agoIt's high level comedy, he's just on a level of irony you can't attain. You have to be one of the 30 under 30's to get it /s
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoIt's likely there are more criminals on these lists than only the ones who get caught.