4 ms·
Isn't this just an example of how the economy is a legitimized Ponzi scheme?
by dylan604 4y ago
Isn't this just an example of how the economy is a legitimized Ponzi scheme?
- acjohnson55 4y agoYeah, sort of. We're also counting on increases in productivity. Although these have also not been forthcoming.
- lofatdairy 4y agoNot really, insofar as that early buyers aren't paid out w the entry of new participants with the absence of any real productive usage of capital. It's more that firms invest in production with the expectation for demand to increase, and outside of increased per capita spending, the main contributor to that effect would be simply more participants in the market. The expectation is obviously somewhat self-serving, but there isn't the sort of hollowness as you would get in a Ponzi Scheme. The system itself would still work so long as population growth slowly came to a halt rather than collapsed and firms observed such trends.
- pyuser583 4y agoParents support their children, then when the parents are retired the children support them. Is publicly funded childcare and eldercare a Ponzi scheme?
- dylan604 4y agoin most families doing this kind of support, then it is typical for numChildren > numParents. So while this may not be the technical definition of Ponzi, the fact that the next generation needs to be larger to sustain the system just sounds like an unsustainable system.
- pyuser583 4y agoI’m not just talking about families, but societies. My parents who are retired are not adding value to the economy. I am. I’m not caring for them directly, but they are dependents. Their investments give them paper money that only has value because my generation works. I have one sister. So two children and two parents is perfectly sustainable.
- dylan604 4y agoUntil you have kids
- pyuser583 4y agoThat’s played itself out, and there’s only going to be one between my sister and myself. So 2 grandparents, two kids, and one grandchild. Definitely not a Ponzi scheme. Not a good one anyway.
- dylan604 4y agoright, that's why the system is failing
- pyuser583 4y agoI don’t think it’s “the system.” Common sense says: “Having a higher proportion of the population not working reduces economic output.” And economics is saying: “Modern economies grow so quickly and reliably, we can increase economic output while caring for an increasing number of dependent people.” For example, we have retirement communities and nursing homes instead of each offspring caring for their own parents. This reduces the downward pull on output. But the pull is still there. So common sense and economics say that more dependents reduces output. I can’t imagine a system where a high number of dependents doesn’t create a downward pull on economic output. Can you describe a system like that?
- carlosjobim 4y agoAny working person in our modern industrialized society can have a productive output that can support many people. Productivity has sky rocketed, as well as population.
- zsz 4y agoPopulation replacement rate is 2.1 children per woman--meaning, in order for a population's size to remain the same, on average child births have to come out to 2.1 for every woman. All Western countries have been well below replacement level, for many decades at this point. Taking the example of One brother and one sister, the sister would have to bear 2.1 children, while the brother would have to have 2.1 children with another woman, in order to merely keep the population size level. The reason for this is obvious: two sets of parents=4 people, the same number as the 2*2.1 children (minus premature deaths, etc.).
- carlosjobim 4y agoYes, but it's not the economy, it is human society at large. All those little laws, rules and customs are made for old people to exploit younger people. The old people bought in first, just as is the right thing to do when you participate in a Ponzi scheme. So it's only fair that they have have all capital, all entitlements, and all power politically and economically. Play along in the scam and maybe one day also you will get the benefit and pleasure of being old to the game and exploiting young people like suckers. That's what life is all about, and young people only have themselves to blame for not being born when the getting was good.
- Borrible 4y agoWell, at least Welfare states look like lifecycle redistribution machines between young and old: https://population-europe.eu/research/policy-briefs/welfare-states-lifecycle-redistribution-machines https://population-europe.eu/research/policy-briefs/welfare-...