3 ms·
> Whether the previous societies were barbaric according to our standards is utterly meaningless Why is that so? I find this completely inconsistent. It's som
by cyberax 4y ago
> Whether the previous societies were barbaric according to our standards is utterly meaningless
Why is that so? I find this completely inconsistent.
It's somehow OK to celebrate a culture that practiced genocidal wars, slavery, and human sacrifices. But it's not OK to celebrate a culture that practiced genocidal wars and slavery.
Moreover, you seem to claim the innate superiority by basically saying: "but they didn't know better, they were savages at the time".
> States are not judged based on whether or not they are net receivers of federal funds. Quite the opposite: several states that are net receivers today tried to secede in the past.
Colonialism assumed that the colonies send resources back to the metropolis country. As you can see, this is not happening at all with Hawaii.
- samus 4y ago> Why is that so? I provided the reasoning in the rest of that paragraph. It's pointless to judge the previous culture on those merits since it was not overthrown because of them. Christianity and "civilization" were not introduced to benefit the Hawaiians, but to control them. And similarly to how our culture cherry-picked from the cultures that came before, so should also the Hawaiians be able to retain elements of their culture and their heritage. > Colonialism assumed that the colonies send resources back to the metropolis country. As you can see, this is not happening at all with Hawaii. Actually, Hawaii was sending resources to the mainland US back then. Most importantly, sugar. However, in the US market Hawaii had trouble competing with other exporters because of tariffs. Already before annexation, Hawaii's business men (mostly of non-native or mixed origin) forced the kingdom to lease territory to the US in exchange for lower tariffs. Annexation was a definite solution for that problem. And nowadays it is still crucial to protect the interests of the USA in the Pacific.
- cyberax 4y ago> Christianity and "civilization" were not introduced to benefit the Hawaiians, but to control them. King Kamehameha was not Christian. > And similarly to how our culture cherry-picked from the cultures that came before, so should also the Hawaiians be able to retain elements of their culture and their heritage. Nope. This is not what was happening. Protestors basically invented nonsense about Mauna Kea being the most sacred something, even though there was no evidence that it was anything but utilitarian. There were no cultural sites at the top of the mountain, but there were sites of several stone-age quarries. > Actually, Hawaii was sending resources to the mainland US back then. In exchange for goods and money, just like any other trading country.