5 ms·
Meta Q1 2023 Earning Results
- HDThoreaun 4y ago> In the first quarter of 2023, ad impressions delivered across our Family of Apps increased by 26% year-over-year and the average price per ad decreased by 17% year-over-year. This seems like a huge problem. Revenue looks ok, but shoving more ads into the products has to come back and bite them eventually right? I'm pretty bullish on META compared to most of this website, but if Mark keeps giving in to wall st. concerns there might be spiralling issues.
- londons_explore 4y agoThose suggest no biting is happening yet... Imagine if they put 10% more ads in, and those ads made users reduce their usage of the apps by 10%... Overall impressions would be level. But that isn't what they see - the impressions number increasing says they are successfully sneaking more ads in, without making many users go elsewhere.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoDefinitely, but it does seem like they are making their product worse in order to stay flat on revenue. Eventually might they reach a tipping point where the product is no longer better than alternatives and everyone leaves in mass? This seems like an especially big concern for a social network where network effects are so big.
- londons_explore 4y agoI assume that if they detected they were near that tipping point, they could tweak a few configs and within hours dramatically scale back the amount of ads - thereby increasing user engagement and killing any competing networks growth opportunities. I do wonder if they practice and prepare for that case - because the Digg social network failed so quickly (within about 96 hours), I expect they want to avoid the same fate.
- baby 4y agoPersonally it hasn’t shocked me the way youtube has started shoving ads down our throats.
- mikedouglas 4y agoThis is likely impression expansion from Reels. Same thing happened when Stories was introduced.
- brewdad 4y agoFor whatever reason, my Facebook feed still isn't too bad. The few friends I follow on Instagram however.....damn if that platform is neigh unusable. I think my feed is 70% ads and if I scroll enough it turns into 90% ads.
- freyfogle 4y agoIt's very easy to measure revenue and how you are doing against the monthly or quarterly goal. It's very hard to measure whether you put so many ads on the page that people get fed up and don't come back. So the end result is you put more ads on the page, and month by month people drift away. Source: I worked at yahoo! way back in the day and lived through exactly this.
- iamnafets 4y agoYou can test this. Stratify users into groups with varying ad load and watch retention metrics. There's a bunch of 2nd-order effects that are hard to control, but you don't get to be a business doing billions in revenue without fine-grained understanding here.
- bombcar 4y agoOr you don’t do this on the downward side because the execs won’t like the answer it gives. Certain parts of a datalake are not for fishing in.
- freyfogle 4y agoOh of course. No doubt the techniques have advanced, but all that was possible even 20 years ago. The question is what do you do when you don't get the answer you want? - when it shows that you are losing audience, though perhaps slowly. It is very difficult/impossible for a manager to say "let's miss this month's revenue goal for the long term benefit of slowing audience loss". And so instead you come with other reasons to explain the audience loss and/or justify keeping the ads. And so the audience loss continues. You are the boiling frog.
- pedrosorio 4y agoThey do report active users and other metrics related to “users getting fed up and not coming back”.
- jstummbillig 4y agoAlso, as another small signal in that vein, WhatsApp cloud api, which used to be effectively free for SMBs, now jumped to 50$/month for us basically over night (ironically making it more expensive than sms). Granted, for most running businesses that's not enough to move the needle but I wonder how many other such levers meta has pulled now and how much it's gonna cost them down the line. When you are in super lean mode you might just not integrate it on day one now. And then some of those just won't, ever.
- vthallam 4y agoWe do have backtests that run over a long period of time to check the effects of the big changes that were introduced. Source: I work at Meta.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoThe other issue is scaling. Will price per ad continue to decrease? If so hwo long can meta continue to increase impressions per user without losing users? Otherwise revenue won't stay flat, it'll decrease.
- pricedeveloper 4y agoThat's been going on for long time. Lower price per ad is also being driven by more impressions from lower income countries and lower monetizing surfaces like reels
- htrp 4y ago> Meta expects revenue of between $29.5 billion and $32 billion, while analysts were expecting sales of $29.5 billion for Q2. looks like ad markets are recovering.
- scrum-treats 4y agoIf almost every post is an ad, then it makes sense. Like others have pointed out, 70-90% of content is an ad on Meta platforms. Additionally, user retention has dropped. At the same time, Meta blocked account deletion across its services (Instagram and FB), citing "technical issues." They also said that accounts wouldn't be deleted for 1-month from customer request. Convenient, eh? So how does Meta report such huge earnings? Well, one way could be that Meta is generating fake account traffic to drive those numbers. Companies paying for ads don't know any different, because you're paying for impressions, not engagement/convergence (e.g., clicks). The is why people say to delete your account, not just to delete the app. Meta need your account to be active to generate that fake traffic and rake in that ads $$. Meta isn't the only corporation that leverages this tactic (i.e., generating fake ads traffic using customer accounts). Any corporation reporting a surge in Ads revenue is likely leveraging this tactic.
- vkou 4y ago> Companies paying for ads don't know any different, because you're paying for impressions, not engagement/convergence (e.g., clicks). Companies are paying for impressions, but they will reduce their spending if the impressions do not result in conversions. It's trivial to tell if a visitor to your store came from Facebook, Google, or wherever.
- scrum-treats 4y ago[dead]
- lanza 4y ago> If almost every post is an ad, then it makes sense. Like others have pointed out, 70-90% of content is an ad on Meta platforms. If you start your statement with hyperbolic nonsense why would I care to read the rest of it? I just checked IG reels and I went through 36 reels before getting to my first ad. I admit that is way more than I even guessed it would be, but pretending 90% is reasonable is a joke.
- rvz 4y agoAnother great earnings beat. Unsuprisingly. Once again as I said before, the last earnings [0], the death of Meta Platforms Inc. (Formerly Facebook Inc.) has been greatly exaggerated. Ever since the low of $88 it is now over 120% up. and almost no-one bought it back then and was too busy screaming about META going to die, because of layoffs. It's over etc, etc, etc. [1] It's business as usual folks. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34618224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34618224 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31832221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31832221
- questime 4y agoTo be fair Zuckerberg has changed his messaging from "Metaverse not matter how much it costs" to "Year of Efficiency". He also has complete control of Meta so shareholders are need to take everything he says seriously.
- 650 4y agoFor now it's great. A recession is coming though which might put a fork in things.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Callmenorm 4y agoBut didn't net income go down by 24%. Isn't that the one of the main things that matters?
- samspenc 4y agoI think investors don't care about this and past results because they are forward-looking, it looks like the optimistic guidance for Q2 is helping with the stock price.
- almog 4y agoMetaverse division revenue: $339M vs est. $613.1M
- realce 4y agoHow do they even make 339m? I've never heard of a single person interacting with the Meta-brand metaverse.
- baby 4y agoThe Quest headsets are pretty popular. Not a billion dollar market yet though.
- dbg31415 4y agoReal estate sales of unused office space? I kid, I kid.
- tootie 4y agoI assume it's Quest sales. Devices and apps.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- smoldesu 4y agoThe Meta Quest has an install base of 10,000,000+ users, along with surprisingly high-profile software releases (I think Resident Evil 4's VR remake was this year). It's not a blockbuster industry quite yet, but something's happening. If nothing else, releasing a bunch of digital VR content isn't untenable for a FAANG business.
- dougmwne 4y agoIt’s at about 20 million now. I’ve seen estimates that about 1/3 are MAU.
- paulpauper 4y agoWhat a huge recovery from last year. Funny how people keep blaming the buybacks or layoffs. Those helped, but what is overlooked is just how insanely profitable and dominant Meta's core advertising business is, both Facebook and Instagram. The momentum is clearly bullish, and it looks like it's going back to $370. Wall St. no longer cares that the Metaverse is burning money. That was last year. I remember all those 2022-2023 YouTube 'mini documentaries' about the 'death of META' or about Metaverse losses. So much for that. Such as this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zuqBRN5SJZ8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zuqBRN5SJZ8 Mobile ad spending is insanely high, especially CPM and CPC rates. Huge multinationals spending so much money on ads, such as healthcare ads, retirement planning ads. Same for cloud, B2B..everything. When it comes to consistently high profit margins, cashflow, and market dominance and moats, Meta is close to unrivaled. It's hard to do better. Own FBL, which is 1.5x Meta.
- nostromo 4y agoI disagree. Increasing ad impressions to make up for waning user growth is what a late-stage tech company does. You can only increase impressions so much… it’s not a long term growth strategy. Ads declining in cost is another red flag about the value of the platform to advertisers. But they made up for the decline by showing more ads. Lastly, increasing profit with layoffs is another stop-gap solution, not a long-term strategy. Meta is moving from an innovative growth company to a stagnant mature company looking to extract maximum value before the party ends.
- zpeti 4y agoPerhaps read a bit about reels from the last earnings, they are eating tiktoks lunch and generating massive engagement. You are trying to fit the facts to your own narrative, which unfortunately isn’t correct.
- tootie 4y agoNot just TikTok. Instagram is starting to eat into Twitter now too. Twitter generates a substantial amount of low quality traffic but we're getting way more value from Instagram right now. And this is for high quality news which is theoretically Twitter's strength.
- belval 4y agoReality Lab (VR) revenue is down +50% YoY which seems surprising. I know VR is not doing great but 50% is a major drop.
- samspenc 4y agoMaybe poor sales? And why they cut prices so significantly on all their VR headsets.
- dougmwne 4y agoQuest 2 is actually up in price from 299 to 399. It’s not currently on sale. By all indications, it wildly exceeded initial sales expectations. Quest 1 is estimated to have sold 1 million units and Quest 2 did an estimated 20 million units, putting it up there with next gen console sales. The Quest Pro dropped from 1499 to 999, but that headset was a boondoggle without a clear target consumer. I believe it was always intended to be a low-volume headset to get user feedback on early AR features, not a legitimate attempt to profit on hardware sales. Some of the Quest Pro AR features are expected to be included in the Quest 3.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>Quest 2 is actually up in price from 299 to 399. I assume that a lot of the chips, and parts in the headset also went up in price since launch and it's not all just profiteering.
- dougmwne 4y agoI’m sure that’s the case and they were also widely reported to be selling each unit at a loss for 299.
- baby 4y agoOh wow, didn’t see the price cut > The price of the 256GB Meta Quest 2 will drop from $499.99 to $429.99, while the price of the higher-end Meta Quest Pro will be slashed to $999.99 from $1,499.99. My guess is that the Quest 3 is coming and they think the Quest Pro original pricing was a mistake that prevented it to find its market?
- baby 4y agoCongrats Meta! And I called it that all the fuss last quarter was just FUD :)
- CoastalCoder 4y agoI have such mixed feelings on this. I was laid off last month from a startup, and finding a new job is as difficult as you'd expect these days. So any signs of strength in the tech sector is encouraging. On the other hand, AFAICT Facebook really is bad for most people*, and I'd like that company in particular to fail. * I recognize that I could be wrong about this.
- pcurve 4y agoMETA... the only tech stock that I averaged down that has returned 50%, among sea of losers (Asana, Palantir, Paypal) :-(
- sakopov 4y agoI struggle to see Meta as a good investment. IG lost a significant market share to TikTok. Facebook seems to be floundering. I do have to say that Market Place is awesome and is probably a better product than anything else in its space. If I had to guess, I'd say a significant portion of new signups are probably folks trying to use Market Place app. I know it's anecdotal, but I really don't know anybody who actively uses Facebook anymore otherwise. As far as Metaverse goes, it just feels like it will never catch fire. I know the quality of graphics has historically been pretty bad, but the VR market has seen a pretty decent uptick in quality of devices, yet it just feels like it's serving a very niche space. Does anybody see a bright future for Meta?
- almog 4y agoIronically, when I signed up with a new user just to use the marketplace while preserving my marketplace history separated from my private user for privacy, I found out that I couldn't use the marketplace until I establish my identity or wait until I'm no longer considered a new user. I realize that it's probably to prevent spam but I ended up just not posting on marketplace.
- lanza 4y ago> Facebook seems to be floundering. The link that we're literally replying to just described that it's growing in all major metrics. Stop letting niche internet communities for clingey geeks over-influence your world views.
- baby 4y agoDisclaimer: Meta is my biggest bet. My thoughts: * they have a huge userbase throughout the world, which allow them to launch new products much more easily * they’re printing money and will be for a very long time. They also have a huge amount of cash. * they have whatsapp, which seems to have won the messaging war. I’m not sure why they still haven’t done much with it but the potential is huge (see weechat and all these types of super apps) * they have been trying to get into payments for a long time, and the outcome could be huge as well. They’ve failed so far (brazil, india, libra/diem) but there’s no reason why it shouldn’t work at some point * hardware is becoming bigger and bigger at Meta. That plus the massive investment into VR/AR and the fact that we still haven’t seen what AR product they’ve been working on * to me the biggest argument is the strong engineering culture. I think the way the rules were set early and the way the machine is running can achieve a lot. What remains to be seen though is how companies like that can create new successful products without acquiring another product. IMO Meta could be much more successful if they focused on: - spinning off new products based on the tech they have (why are they still not competing with cloud providers!) - spinning off new products based on the userbase they have (they need to launch a twitter competitor) - releasing hardware products more often. Why did they give up on Portal? Why didn’t they release more iterations of the glasses? - giving people what they want on FB. Turning it back into a useful tool. For example, chronological timeline as a setting
- loeg 4y ago$4B loss on Reality Labs vs $6B net income is just embarrassing. Increase your income almost 100% with this one weird trick! And they anticipate RL spending will continue to increase.