I agree with your points. However, I think we still have the problem that there is too much supply, and pushing more people into it does them a disservice. Y

I agree with your points. However, I think we still have the problem that there is too much supply, and pushing more people into it does them a disservice. Yes, it helps the scientific establishment re: points 1. and 2. As for 3., perhaps true, but I'm not sure it helps those individuals and thus conflicts with the next point that "Everybody in a society has a right to a good life." This may be colored with a US-centric point of view because social safety nets are not great, and if they existed to a greater extent maybe my criticism would be mitigated and it would be fine to push against the market. But without that I think many people are better off pursuing opportunities more appropriate for them.