3 ms·
> All of those “features” come with with a heavy price—responsibility. This is the issue with many of these types of services. Geeks love them; but no one else
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
> All of those “features” come with with a heavy price—responsibility.
This is the issue with many of these types of services. Geeks love them; but no one else does. I don't like running a VPS or an AWS instance, because of all the overhead, so I tend to use shared hosting. I'm quite capable of running a VPS, but I can't be arsed.
I suspect that we'll be seeing some fairly large corporate Mastodon servers (like...say...Twitter). These are likely to be popular.
- local_crmdgeon 4y agoI've said this before on my throwaways - this is the same logic as Bitcoin. I don't want more responsibility, I want to use a service that works. Also, like BTC, the whole thing is network effects, and barriers to entry dramatically curtail networks. People like Twitter because celebrities and journalists use it, not because of the data model.
- smoldesu 4y agoHN has an API and a search database connected to it, but it's also "a service that works". It's not as complicated as Bitcoin, everything is abstracted as a simple account/forum system. The non-user-facing complexity is high, but the user-facing complexity is minimum. That's what ActivityPub integration is going to look like, IMO. With companies like Flipboard and Tumblr adding integration, it's undeniable that the network is growing (even if it's not it's strong suit). For people who want an RSS-style feed with light interactive elements, it's a dream come true. Maybe that encompasses Twitter users, maybe it doesn't.
- hinkley 4y agoWe need some turnkey VPS hardware, and a lot of these problems would be greatly reduced.
- safety1st 4y agoNone of that was enough to stop email. Free is a very good price. Once it was obvious that emailing was a thing many people wanted to do, and a free server became available, servers started springing up all over the place, many more implementations of the underlying protocols were developed, businesses figured out various ways to monetize, the standards evolved (somewhat). Now let's do an inventory on ActivityPub... 1) It became obvious that tweeting was a thing many people wanted to do? Check 2) A free server became available? Check 3) Servers started springing up all over the place? Check https://www.similarweb.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/mastodon_herd_1.png https://www.similarweb.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/m... 4) More implementations were developed? That's where we are now 5, 6) Stay tuned
- FredPret 4y ago- With email, it was very easy to join and use. Get an email account, get an email address, send the email. Done. You can email anyone who has email. - With Mastodon, it's immediately more complicated than that. - Free isn't a factor in Mastodon's favour because Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram are also free. And it's simple to understand and join. - Everyone is on Twitter, so if you want to see their tweets, you have to join too.
- madeofpalk 4y ago> - With Mastodon, it's immediately more complicated than that. Is there something inherit in Mastodon that makes it more complicated, or is this an obstacle that can be overcome (like email did)
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI suspect that it's something that could be "skinned" with a simpler UX. I'm writing a very basic social media app, myself, right now, and have developed an appreciation for the complexity behind the façade.
- sunflowerfly 4y agoYes, having to find an instance to join. That hurdle alone stops a large percent of casual users.
- madeofpalk 4y agoHow did email solve this?
- rvz 4y agoCentralization of the biggest email providers. This is why we don't see normal users (non techies) themselves self-hosting their own email servers to send a email, even though the option is there. Even if they did, the biggest email providers deal with the spam problem better than self-hosted individuals, hence why it isn't a problem for users signing up to Gmail. Mastodon will naturally gear towards centralization once the larger instances open up their instances and add defaults, ruining the whole point of federation with the biggest instances being at risk of buyouts and takeovers offers.
- Hamuko 4y ago>I suspect that we'll be seeing some fairly large corporate Mastodon servers (like...say...Twitter). These are likely to be popular. Aren't the most popular ones already ran by companies? As far as I can see from the data, the most popular is mastodon.social (ran by Mastodon gGmbH), followed by Pawoo (Russell Co., Ltd / formerly Pixiv Co., Ltd), mstdn.jp (Sujitech, LLC), baraag.net (independent) and mastodon.cloud (Sujitech, LLC).
- Gareth321 4y agoThis is exactly the problem with Linux. For decades I've been seeing developers frothing at the mouth yelling at everyone else about how they should switch to Linux. Then they try Ubuntu and they can't even change the mouse acceleration without hunting down third party tools and they leave and never come back. Users need dead simple UX. Mastodon's signup process alone has been an absolute nightmare until mastodon.social enabled direct signup.
- coffeeling 4y agoI recently installed Linux on one of my devices. Turns out the touchpad library libinput was built by a spiritual gnome dev who decided to not give users options because that would've meant more tests. We're talking hardcoding what different taps on the touchpad do type stuff, and them all being either on or off.