3 ms·
This article is... nonsense? It's so badly written I can't even figure out what it's trying to say. But after the fourth time he talks about "enshittification"
by crazygringo 4y ago
This article is... nonsense? It's so badly written I can't even figure out what it's trying to say. But after the fourth time he talks about "enshittification" it's very hard to take seriously. As far as I can tell, it's just an unorganized, stream-of-consciousness "I hate Amazon" rant.
Maybe there's an actual main point in here somewhere, that's connected to the headline somehow, but this article is a shining example of how not to write if you want to actually convince people of a point you're trying to make.
- rektide 4y agoI'd love a vote on how hard or easy it is for people. I got it quick. I also understood the problems ahead of time reasonably well. I can't see how #enshittification is anything other than an apt world-consuming trend broadly outlining the predominamt trends of capitalism in the world today. And for the new phase of Amazon now that it has attained market capture. To you it seems like a huge turn off, tuned you out, but you've just heaped the term onto your pile of disdain. It's unclear to me what problems you have, why you disagree or what you find inaccurate about the term in general or it's application.
- Invictus0 4y agoThe article is crap. The main point is in the second half of the article: > Amazon binds its sellers over to something called Most Favored Nation status. That means that sellers can't offer their goods more cheaply than they do on Amazon – even if it costs them (lots) less to sell in Target or direct from their websites. This means that every time a seller adds a dollar to their Amazon sale price, they have to add a dollar to the price of their goods everywhere else, too.
- thayne 4y agoThe content leading up to it is explaining why Amazon is able to force sellers to accept that, and telling the story of how they got there. Most Favored Nation only works if you have no choice but to do business them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrewmutz 4y agoI agree it is nonsense. The closest I can come to a point is: Amazon locks consumers in with prepayment schemes (like Amazon Prime, where you've prepaid for shipping). Then all the sellers have to follow because thats where the consumers are. But it's an incredibly thin argument. I am a prime member and when I go to buy things online, the fact that I should choose amazon to get cheaper shipping absolutely never enters my mind.
- mock-possum 4y agoI mean I wouldn’t say it’s incoherent, its just a lot of anti-Amazon ranting. Not illdeserved in amazon’s case.
- Retric 4y agoThat’s a very long post to say “I don’t understand.” The argument is very simple, Amazon – like other platform businesses – externalizes its costs onto its suppliers by raising suppliers costs it raises the costs consumers pay. You can agree or disagree with that argument, but it’s not very complicated.
- andrewmutz 4y agoWhich costs? Externalities normally refer to parties not involved in the transaction, and the suppliers are involved in the transaction.
- Retric 4y agoMany costs are listed, but the requirement for items on Amazon to get the lowest retail price “Most Favored Nation status” means they are an external influence on transactions that don’t involve them. It’s common for small breweries for example to offer cheaper prices at the factory than anywhere else because that’s the lowest possible transaction costs. Much like how credit cards charge merchant fees and then require cash payments to be at the same rate.
- augment003 4y agoDoctorow was once a meaningful tech and corporate skeptic, but at some point he became a dogmatist and his takes have become increasingly ungrounded.