3 ms·
At least in the US it wasn't even about monopolies, but about whether or not a merger would negatively affect competition. [1] But at some point it feels like t
by somenameforme 4y ago
At least in the US it wasn't even about monopolies, but about whether or not a merger would negatively affect competition. [1] But at some point it feels like the FTC simply stopped enforcing its own guidelines, at least when large enough players were involved. Because it's somewhat self evident that the overwhelmingly majority of big corp mergers over the past couple of decades have completely crippled competition.
That said, I think this indirectly feeds off your core point - this 'new direction' of the FTC is almost certainly because these companies have become far too 'influential' owing to their size and power. I think one could even generalize a simple test: "Would the immediate collapse of this company meaningfully imperil the US economy, security, or other significant interests?" If so, that company needs to be split up until the answer is no.
[1] - https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/mergers https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/gui...
- fallingknife 4y agoLarge tech companies are nothing like banks and have no mechanism to immediately collapse. In fact, the fact that their collapse would imperil the US economy is a 100% guarantee that they won't collapse because it means people are dependent on buying their products. And if you did break them up, it wouldn't solve the problem at all. Whatever company is in charge of Windows is still going to be critical no matter the size. It depends on the importance of the software product in the tech industry, not the size of the company like it does in banking.
- vxNsr 4y agoThe difference is that if Windows corp isn’t part of the O365 corp then they’re both forced to work with competitors instead of forcing you into their walled garden. How nice would it be if all the features that you get from the windows/O365/Onedrive synergy were available to any cloud competitor? So I could pair word/excel sync with my own self-hosted cloud. I could back up all my files using the native tools to any cloud provider. That’s the sort of benefit you could theoretically have by breaking up Microsoft.