3 ms·
This photographer contacted the wrong person. LAION is a list of links to images. LAION itself does not store the images. Therefore they are claiming they h
by londons_explore 4y ago
This photographer contacted the wrong person.
LAION is a list of links to images.
LAION itself does not store the images. Therefore they are claiming they had no part in any AI use/misuse. They also committed no copyright infringement in what they did (which was to download an image, verify that it was in fact an image, and add it to their list).
However, since LAION had to retain a lawyer to deal with this (incorrect) request, they now want to be paid for that lawyers time - which seems reasonable.
Other parties used the LAION list to train AI models - and those parties are who the photographer should have made claims against in the first place.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoIn the law intent matters. LAION is aiding and abetting copyright infringement just as much as the Pirate Bay does. They very vigorously don’t want to be held responsible for this, but it’s their letters don’t have any specific legal weight.
- Kim_Bruning 4y agoPotentially it can be argued that LAION is aiding in copyright infringement, but there is a very strong argument that no copyright infringement is occurring at all. (With one of the many interesting twists being that AI output is considered PD in the US) My lawyer would say this is a "legally interesting situation": by which he means that the situation legally and ethically very unclear, and lawyers can earn a lot of money sorting it out.
- rubyron 4y agoSomething you never want to hear from your lawyer, or doctor, is that your case is interesting.
- SideQuark 4y ago>AI output is considered PD in the US) That's not what the court ruled. The particular case had no user input, so failed the creativity test. Even making simple prompts, a creative process, is enough to make the result copyrightable, in the same manner that using AI ni photoshop to teak things results in copyrightable, or using AI filters to adjust audio, or even write text, results in copyrightable content. The requirement is that a human drive any tool with some creative input, which does not have to be extensive at all. I can write a few words and it;s copyrightetd automatically. How can doing that to create a prompt which drives a tool not be copyrightable? They're both creative content.
- londons_explore 4y ago> some creative input, which does not have to be extensive at all. The US copyright office's statement suggests otherwise: > when an AI technology receives solely a prompt from a human and produces complex written, visual, or musical works in response, the “traditional elements of authorship” are determined and executed by the technology—not the human user. Based on the Office’s understanding of the generative AI technologies currently available, users do not exercise ultimate creative control over how such systems interpret prompts and generate material. Instead, these prompts function more like instructions to a commissioned artist—they identify what the prompter wishes to have depicted, but the machine determines how those instructions are implemented in its output. Obviously one could draw a parallel to someone painting using a spray can - where the individual droplets of ink land are mostly a matter of physics, so there is no creative control there. The human simply directs the can to give the general direction of where the ink should be put. A line must be drawn between these two cases, but it is unclear where it is. [1]: https://www.copyright.gov/ai/ai_policy_guidance.pdf https://www.copyright.gov/ai/ai_policy_guidance.pdf
- SideQuark 4y agoThat does not say they do not grant copyrights to such things, and they explicitly list mixtures of things they did grant copyrights to. The only place they did not grant copyright was the example with no human inputs. In the case I claimed, with human creative input to direct a tool, to quote: "In the case of works containing AI-generated material, the Office will consider whether the AI contributions are the result of “mechanical reproduction” or instead of an author’s “own original mental conception, to which [the author] gave visible form.” The answer will depend on the circumstances, particularly how the AI tool operates and how it was used to create the final work. This is necessarily a case-by-case inquiry." As I put it, prompt engineering, which is often iterative, directed by a human desiring a goal, will easily surpass the statement. The simple "all AI generated content is not copyrightable" simply isn't true as the OP claimed.
- chrisshroba 4y agoIf I threaten legal action against you and you hire a lawyer to respond to me, and I then take no further action, am I liable for your lawyer’s fees for the response? I believe the answer is no but I don’t know for sure.
- londons_explore 4y agoIn the EU, specifically for copyright cases, you are.
- throw101010 4y agoTotally agree, the cost of frivolous copyright claims cannot be 0 if we want such system to work. > Other parties used the LAION list to train AI models - and those parties are who the photographer should have made claims against in the first place. "Other parties" have not published a recognizable copy of his work either, only a list of weights that were computed based on his work. How was their copyrights infringed by these?
- throwaway290 4y agoSay I make an original work and hold all the copyright, I do not license it as "derivative commercial works allowed". LAION makes a dataset and says to everyone "you can use it to train your ML" without distinction and puts my work in it. Some guys like ClosedAI are 100% gonna use it to sell generative works for profit. LAION doesn't stop them. LAION basically took my work and tells everyone it's OK to use it, like if it were magically public domain now.