3 ms·
Google pushing malicious updates would leave forensic traces, not to mention it'd be difficult to establish a legal framework allowing a government to force Goo
by mschuster91 4y ago
Google pushing malicious updates would leave forensic traces, not to mention it'd be difficult to establish a legal framework allowing a government to force Google to do so.
In contrast, subpoena'ing data from the cloud is routine for police in countries all over the world.
- PradeetPatel 4y agoThis may sound like a naive question, but what stops countries with flexible ethical standards from abusing this power? For example, in the past I've worked with an AI company with presence in China, where the data of their Chinese clientele must be stored on a separate data centre operated by a local enterprise. Despite the provider being ISO compliant and holds internationally recognised certs, is there realistically a chance that those data could be accessed without the permission or consent of the users?
- v4dok 4y agoDepends on your threat model. Practically, the cloud admin would be able to dump that data in clear during processing even if that data is encrypted at rest and in transit.
- ddalex 4y agoSo your threat model is a sovereign state able to subpoena cloud data. Under this model, if Google gets a court order to root-break a specific phone (push malicious update), they will be forced to, and that's all the legal framework necessary, so end-to-end encryption doesn't protect you in this case either.
- xp84 4y agoIn the US at least, there’s not a lot of precedent for forcing a company to do something like that. (Yet.) Saying hand over your user’s files is demanding information. Compelling them to write and distribute malware is a lot closer to compelling speech. A 1st amendment problem.
- dtech 4y agoThat's a lot more detectable, and has a high risk of coming out, see e.g. Pegasus. Cloud access is nearly invisible.