6 ms·
Freud as Talmudist
- jb12 4y ago[flagged]
- TheFreim 4y ago> It frustrates me when Jewish people, especially very smart Jewish people like Freud, fail to understand that Judaism is more than just a religion, it's also an ethnic group. This is because the waters have been, seemingly intentionally, muddied. I have seen criticism of Judaism, oddly enough even criticism by ethnic Jews, as being considered "anti-Semitic" and similar terms. Furthermore, the distinction in my experience seems to be rejected by many Jews who consider "being Jewish" as being essentially and intrinsically related to the Jewish religion enshrined in cultural practice.
- jb12 4y agoIt is definitely possible for Jews to say antisemitic things, in the same way it is possible for people of colour to say racist things.
- entelechy0 4y ago[dead]
- svnt 4y agoThe conclusion doesn’t seem to follow. All people have race, and so can be externally racist, but you would not consider a white person aggressively critiquing white culture to be anti-white, would you?
- Minor49er 4y agoWhy not?
- barry-cotter 4y agoYes, you would. Whether speech is racist or not is a characteristic of the speech, not determined by the speaker’s skin colour.
- pfannkuchen 4y agoRight, was Luther anti-Christian? Such people are generally called “X reformers”, not “anti-X” as an outsider would be.
- wslh 4y agoI think the article itself failed to understand or counterpoint the issue about Judaism. Judaism as a religion and ethnic group is known by criticizing themselves, even in the extreme orthodox side. "Freud as Talmudist" could be more generally seen as "Freud as a Thinker".
- samstave 4y ago[flagged]
- jrumbut 4y agoIs this is a criticism of the article? Because it seems like the author takes great pains to distinguish between a person who is Jewish and a person who practices Judaism. I also don't think that ethnic group really captures it either. For me, being Jewish is just its own thing, sui generis, that only partially overlaps with these other concepts (religion, ethnicity, nationality, etc) but isn't any of those things.
- edgyquant 4y agoEh it’s and ethnoreligious group.
- fear_and_coffee 4y ago[dead]
- netbioserror 4y ago[flagged]
- valarauko 4y agoI think 'ethnicity' is a complicated term, since it's a catchall for all sorts of identities we can't quite assign to something easier to parse. In the example of the Australian Indigenous, that identity is a Venn diagram of overlapping ideas about lineage, culture, language, and tribal affiliation. Any one or more of those attributes could be potentially disrupted and yet maintain Indigenous identity and acceptance by the larger community - perhaps precariously. A counter example would be the American designation of 'Latino' as an ethnicity, independent of race, language, and culture, and based entirely on national origin.
- akiselev 4y ago“Latino” refers to the mixed descendants of Spanish or Portuguese ancestry as opposed to the indigenous Mayans, Guarani, Aymara, etc that still inhabit the continent, numbering in the millions.
- valarauko 4y agoSure, though you're using the community definition of the term, while the US government definition encompasses anybody from those countries, regardless of ancestry. So a Lebanese - Mexican or Chinese - Mexican with no Spanish ancestry could be considered latino by the government.
- andresgottlieb 4y agoI disagree. Judaism is not an ethnic group, it's many absolutely different and disjunct ethnic groups, that only have religion in common. A Jew from Yemen has nothing else in common with a Jew from Poland. Different language, different food,. different music, different physical resemblance, different interpretation of the Torah, etc. I recommend reading The Invention of the Jewish People, by Shlomo Sand. As a practical example. When my father (Ashkenazi) married my mother (Sephardic), my father's grandma was devastated, because he was marrying a non-jew.
- hersko 4y agoNot a great example. In the orthodox community it is very common to intermarry between religious Sephardi and Ashkenazi jews. > A Jew from Yemen has nothing else in common with a Jew from Poland 1) They descended from the same people 2) If they are religious, they have a tremendous amount in common
- jb12 4y ago> A Jew from Yemen has nothing else in common with a Jew from Poland Except for the genetics we share, distinct from non-Jews, statistically significantly. I recommend reading "Legacy: A Genetic History of the Jewish People" by Harry Ostrer. We really are the people of the book, aren't we?
- lo_zamoyski 4y agoI don't think it's that simple. From the Catholic perspective, it is primarily a theological identity, as evidenced by the way the New Testament uses the word. Jesus, his mother Mary, the Apostles, the first so-called Christians, were all "Jews", and so in some sense, we can speak of the Jews who accepted Christ as the Messiah, and those Jews who did not. The New Testament describes the latter as "the Jews", and since there is no ethnic difference between the former and the latter, it follows that "Jew" in this context is not an ethnic, but a theological concept[0]. This isn't to say there is no ethnic sense, but the theological concept is the real focus. Among Jews, Jewishness is taken to be communicated matrilineally, and the interpretation of such phrases as "children of Abraham" (or "seed of Abraham") is understood in carnal terms. Most Jews today are not observant, yet they still view themselves as Jews and are viewed as Jews even by observant Jews. Cultural Jewishness might seem like one way to be able to maintain Jewish identity without the theology, but because Jewish culture in the traditional sense is so theological (and frankly, all cult-ure ultimately is), one has to ask what kind of Jewish culture are we talking about? Once the underpinning and sustaining beliefs are gone, the culture loses its force and meaning, even if it takes a while for the old attachments to wither to completion. Some new theology would need to take the place of the old while maintaining the old name. Without the old theological basis, carnal identity begins to take on an even greater importance. I might also touch on the civilizational definition of "Jewish", though because civilization is ultimately determined by religion, the question is ultimately a question of theology. Koneczny's definition comes to mind. So the word is overloaded. But generally speaking, we are very much living in a period of identity crises. Some claim that the uptick in racial politics is the result of the decline of religious identity in the West. [0] Incidentally, this is why some of the accusations of antisemitism that are made of Catholicism are wrongheaded and involve some kind of modernist projection of categories alien to Catholicism. "Antisemitism" is a term coined in the 19th century (conventionally attributed to Wilhelm Marr) that has in mind a racial and ethnic meaning of "Jew", but the conflict between Catholicism and Judaism is not ethnic or racial, but theological. The Rabbinic Judaism that emerged after the Crucifixion, with the destruction of the Second Temple that left the Jews with no temple sacrifice and no priesthood, is taken to be defection from the Faith, something analogous to Protestantism (recall that the Old Testament is a history of such defections, and is the history of heretical Christian sects). Judaism is taken to have transformed from a faith centered on sacrifice to one centered on observing the law. The sacrifice and the priesthood are taken to continue in the Church--the New Israel--and in the mass, now bloodless and perfected[1]. [1] https://catholicexchange.com/church-new-israel/ https://catholicexchange.com/church-new-israel/
- culturthrowaway 4y agoA constant worldview-pervading awareness of Jewishness as an ethnicity is only really widespread in 4 groups of people: particularly ethnic-chauvinist Jews, the hardest-core antisemites, and their victims. Wishing for more Jews to become much more aware of their ethnicity would be one of those monkey's paw wishes.
- jb12 4y agoOut of interest, are there any other groups where you believe that it would be dangerous for members of that group to be "aware of their ethnicity"? Or is it only Jews?
- culturthrowaway 4y agoThis is a description, not a prescription. Also do note the adjectives. I'd say it is universal for any group, but given particular circumstances in the actual state of the world its salience varies widely.
- csdvrx 4y agoThe Talmud has many interesting logical "sanity checks": one of my favorites is the need for dissenting voices. Basically, if a decision has full agreement, jumping to the conclusion is wrong as it can mean some details were not properly investigated. https://www.jewishaz.com/religiouslife/the-importance-of-dissenting-views/article_1f3e2d16-9d0e-11e9-b00c-b79b84768527.html https://www.jewishaz.com/religiouslife/the-importance-of-dis...
- hammyhavoc 4y agoDisappointed this link isn't available in the UK due to GDPR according to the site.
- wslh 4y agoDoes it work with the following link: https://archive.is/gmpCf https://archive.is/gmpCf
- hammyhavoc 4y agoYes, thank you!
- vincent-manis 4y agoI subscribe to Piet Hein's insight: `Everything's either concave or -vex/So everything you dream will be something with sex'.
- 462436347 4y ago[flagged]
- bheadmaster 4y agoI didn't know that. Why are there so many psychologists practicing psychoanalysis today, then? Has modern psychoanalysis evolved so far beyond Freud's psychoanalysis that it became a serious branch of psychology? If so, why is it still called "psychoanalysis"?
- stronglikedan 4y agoI presume because it has a place, in a nonscientific way. A lot of issues can be merely talked through. For those that can't, the patient can be referred to a psychiatrist, who can further evaluate and identify the issues using scientific methods, and prescribe medicines if necessary (which a psychologist cannot do).
- abyssin 4y agoMany psychologists use psychoanalysis the same way many priests use religious stories to provide guidance. It’s a great source of allegories. It’s also prestigious and lets them charge a lot of money, while practicing “floating attention” ie. letting their mind wander while listening and not actually paying attention. Last is that in many countries anyone can pretend to be a psychoanalyst. Lacan famously said “Le psychanalyste ne s'autorise que de lui-même”.
- Gerard0 4y agoSurprised to read this quote here! This means nothing/no one can guarantee you being a psychoanalyst. Just like either you can code and be good at it or not. That's all this phrase means. Of course it gets tricky. A programmer can show the result and it either works or it doesn't. An analyst can't show anything, really. Even if the analysand claims his/her life has changed because of an analysis (people also claim Jesus changed them, for example). About the floating attention thing, that's a very strange generalization ("analysts don't pay attention"). It is about treating all the "material" equally (ie without preconceptions).
- barberpole 4y agoReading Freud, Wittgenstein said "now here is something new."
- jeffwass 4y agoFrom the article : "On this view, the fact that a Jew discovered psychoanalysis didn’t mean it was a 'Jewish science,' any more than Einstein’s e = mc2 was a Jewish equation." This is a strange statement to write because Einstein's relativity was indeed shrugged off as "Jewish Physics" by many antisemitic German physicists prior to WWII, in favour of German (or Aryan) Physics : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deutsche_Physik https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deutsche_Physik
- naniwaduni 4y agoIt shouldn't come as too much of a surprise that Freud was not in full agreement with the Nazis on the matter of his relationship with Judaism.
- nathan_compton 4y agoThe writer is alluding to this fact.
- RadixDLT 4y agoThe Horrors of Freud - Stefan Molyneux
- reducesuffering 4y agoYikes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan_Molyneux https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan_Molyneux
- detourdog 4y agoThe biggest problem the talmud has in my opinion is that most people have such a distorted view of religion that the talmud is out of reach. I find it very worthwhile for framing human interactions and worth more study.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoBasing one's philosophy on magic beliefs and unquestionable appeals to authority (book or person) is building a castle on reclaimed land. Religion is a fanciful prison of illusions, delusions, and oft able to rationalize suffering imposed on others as "good".
- detourdog 4y agoThis is my point illustrated. I can't decide if I should upvote you for helping me prove it. There are no magical beliefs and from a certain point of view the only authority is one's peace of mind. Obviously your thinking is why to sophisticated for thoughts on human existence evolved over thousands of years. The only people I see in prisoned by their minds have closed minds. They also like to insist others conform to their narrow view.
- lukas099 4y agoThe human struggle with authority or tradition is a part of the Hebrew Bible and Jewish scholarship itself. Off the top of my head, 'Israel' was the name given to Jacob after he wrestled with God. The Book of Job was a reaction to realization that good/evil did not necessarily correlated with prosperity/failure. These are things that the faithful openly talk about.
- marshmallow_12 4y agoIn the words of Gimli the dwarf; 'You speak evil of that which is fair beyond the reach of your thought, and only little wit can excuse you.'
- wubbert 4y ago[dead]
- atleastoptimal 4y agoCould the general success of Jewish people as an ethnic group be partly attributable to the Talmud and general tenets of Jewish culture helping adapt the mind to difficult circumstances and wrestling with complexity?
- lukas099 4y agoI think the accepted view is that persecution and diaspora pushed Jews into industries like finance that lead to wealth accumulation. However, I personally don't think that the persecution would be as severe if Jews did not have such an insular culture, organized around the Torah and tradition. Also, literacy and scholarship is promoted in Jewish culture due to the promotion of reading and debating the Torah and Talmud. This could have helped direct the results of their persecution. Compare the Jewish people to other persecuted peoples such as the gypsies. I am no sociologist, but I think at the very least we can agree that outcomes result from very complex interactions of culture, geography, history, language, religion, etc.
- wslh 4y agoDo you mean successful in many areas such as science, art, or business? Comparing to their population size. Genuinely asking.
- atleastoptimal 4y agoBoth, though in this case science in particular.
- wslh 4y agoIt is obviously impossible to generalize because there is also a lot of diversity in the community. You can see that very visually when you have jewish orthodox people and near them the pride parade. Also, when you see some religious people smoking pot before sabbath... or orthodox women movements. All these seems contradictory. I think the short answer is that there was and is a tradition for education and critical thinking. There is that joke about a jewish mother of a president that feels proud of his other son, which is a doctor. There are some variations [1]. [1] https://aish.com/51475757/ https://aish.com/51475757/
- boringuser2 4y agoSounds very similar to the conclusions reached by Dr. Kevin MacDonald from the complete opposite perspective.
- NoZebra120vClip 4y agoFreud emerged at a time in history when there was an extraordinary demand for a particular service that had been lost over the course of 300 years: auricular confession to a priest. Since most Protestant sects since 1517 had been consistently rejecting and deprecating the practice of auricular confession, men around the world, especially in Europe, were bursting with secrets. There is a basic human need to disclose our secrets to God, and to feel cleansed and regenerated and relieved of the burdens they've become. So Freud and his colleagues designed psychoanalysis as a comfortable, secular, drop-in replacement for auricular confession, and established a new priestly class among the Protestant laity. Now it's great to fill a void, but of course Catholics and Orthodox had never ceased the original practice, and so it was clear that psychoanalysis was explicitly designed to usurp and work at crossed-purposes to the religiously-branded type. In the past two centuries, the new priesthood has succeeded in establishing a secular church, even in disestablishmentarian jurisdictions such as these United States. By medicalizing defects of mind, and applying a "disease model" of diagnosis and treatment (but never cures) even to vices such as substance addiction, the new priesthood has established religious control over the populace in unprecedented ways (okay, maybe they are definitely precedented). The most recent expansion of this religion is from "mental" to "behavioral" health; i.e. not only your internal thoughts, but also your outward actions, are under scrutiny and subject to control. It is interesting that recent developments have seen Roman Catholicism take an approach of "if you can't beat 'em, join 'em" and wholly embrace psychoanalysis, psychology and psychiatry as their own, even going so far as to accept theories of homosexuality and "orientation" as givens and psychological facts. There are now explicitly branded Catholic practitioners of mental health, where you can go for drugs, psychoanalysis, and support groups, because two churches are better than one, I suppose.
- nathan_compton 4y agoInteresting, if weird, idea. Many things to take issue with, but I will take just one: ``The most recent expansion of this religion is from "mental" to "behavioral" health; i.e. not only your internal thoughts, but also your outward actions, are under scrutiny and subject to control.`` Behavioral health is arguably a shift _away_ from policing the internal state of the person to instead focus on specific behaviors that interfere with a patient's life. It is bizarre to suggest this places behavior under "scrutiny and control." You may have noticed that, in fact, all of our behaviors are already under personal, legal, and social scrutiny and control. The point of behavioral health is to help people cope with _that_ reality without engaging unnecessarily with psychological narratives which, as you and others have pointed out in this thread, may not be evidence based. Also, "In the past two centuries, the new priesthood has succeeded in establishing a secular church". This may be true in some sense, but psychoanalysis and its descendant practices have nothing like the cultural and political dominance of Catholicism in its heyday. I guess its possible to think of psychoanalysis as a church if you allow "church" to mean just any collection of ideas around which people organize and in which people believe without a level of scrutiny they apply to other kinds of ideas, but that covers quite a lot of ground. "psychoanalysis was explicitly designed to usurp and work at crossed-purposes to the religiously-branded type." I'm genuinely interested in whether Freud ever wrote anything that suggested that he was trying to usurp Catholic confession.
- ars 4y agoThe article misinterprets what the Talmud does, and the author does so in order to try to draw a parallel with Freud. Along with the written Torah there was also an oral tradition, that oral tradition would have included the info of 2,000 amaos that the article references. What does the Talmud do? It works under the principle that everything in the oral tradition is also hinted to in the written Torah, and then it goes looking for it. The article incorrectly claims that the Talmud derived this number from the written Torah - this is false and backwards. The people who wrote the Talmud already knew this number, their goal was to find where it was hinted to. They were able to do so for virtually every part of the oral Torah to the extent that they even recorded every time they were unable to do so with the term "Halacha mi Moshe be Sinai". (A law direct from Moshe on Sinai, i.e. as distinct from a law that could be derived from the written Torah.) This is such a fundamental misunderstanding of the Talmud that it kind of fails the entire point of the article.