3 ms·
> How about 0%(poverty line or below) - 18%(max for anyone) income tax and we forget all other taxes? How about no? How’d you pick those numbers and a two-tier
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> How about 0%(poverty line or below) - 18%(max for anyone) income tax and we forget all other taxes?
How about no? How’d you pick those numbers and a two-tier system? (“Let’s set the top marginal rate of our only tax to approximately the lowest tax-to-GDP ratio of the OECD” is, I suppose, a choice, but its a very odd one.)
> Income happens when it is realized or upon transfer.
In any progressive (including a two-tier like this, which, while far less progressive than the status quo, is still technically a progressive system) system that brings LTCG in line with general income taxation, you also want to allow advance recognition (for sure) and maybe deferment of income spikes, otherwise you end up taxing income that takes multiple years and is nonrepeatable the same as current and repeatable ongoing income, which is unfair to people with irregular income through capital. Doing this, and applying equally to regular income, also is more fair for people with irregular non-capital income, which may be a less-common pattern, but definitely happens.
> this is the fairest way I can think of supporting savers, supporting investing, supporting small businesses, and allowing the wealthy to be taxed at a reasonable rate.
It radically cuts taxes on the wealthy, and "supports" all those things by cutting taxes on the wealthy people doing them. Its just a giant downward shift of net tax burden that also is a massive cut in overall tax revenue.
> This also incentivizes congress to actually grow the GDP and work within a budget.
No, it doesn’t. (I mean, there are incentives to both of those, especially the first, that exist independently, but this doesn’t add to any of them.)