2 ms·
> Taxes were complicated before Intuit existed. [...] Blaming Intuit really seems to oversimplify the situation. Having a complicated tax code certainly makes
by kelnos 4y ago
> Taxes were complicated before Intuit existed. [...] Blaming Intuit really seems to oversimplify the situation.
Having a complicated tax code certainly makes things difficult in general, but has very little to do with the issue at hand.
The IRS could send you an email in March every year, where you click through to their tax portal. It would show you a list of all the income and deductions and other miscellaneous things they know about. If you have extras, or if any data is incorrect, you can click around and add and change things. It might also start with a short questionnaire to ask if any tax-relevant things have changed about your life (change in dependents, change in marital status, etc.).
For the vast majority of US taxpayers, they won't have to change a thing, and it would take them minutes to finish up.
Yes, there are a lot of rules in the US tax code that can make things complicated. But -- critically -- these things do not apply for the vast majority of taxpayers. For those for whom it does, yes, they will have more work. But it's still going to be less work than the current regime, and none of this precludes having a CPA take care of it for you if you'd prefer that.
I suspect even many of us tech-job types wouldn't have much extra to do. The main thing we'd have to fill in ourselves would be cost basis adjustments for RSU vests. (But really, law should be changed so that brokers are required to report that info to the IRS as well; so dumb that it isn't the case.) The IRS could easily keep track of capital loss carryover, AMT credits, etc., over many years if necessary.
It feels like the argument is often "this won't 100% work for 20% of taxpayers, so we should make the other 80% suffer... and make the 20% still do more work than they'd otherwise have to do".
There are still really just two main reasons we have to do our own taxes:
1. Companies like Intuit who lobby to make it illegal for the IRS to do it for us.
2. Buttholes like Grover Norquist who actively convince people that it's necessary to feel the pain of filing taxes, lest the government slip in new taxes that we don't notice (largest eye-roll in history).
- ghaff 4y ago>The main thing we'd have to fill in ourselves would be cost basis adjustments for RSU vests. The cost basis thing used to be a nightmare. At one point with some old stock that got converted to another company's stock with an acquisition, I just threw up my hands and put in a plausible number. (It wasn't a huge amount of money in the scheme of things.) But these days, the only time I've had to manually provide a cost basis to my accountant was when I was donating some stock.
- sgerenser 4y agoI’ve never had RSUs show up properly without needing cash basis adjustment. Same goes for ESPP shares.
- not2b 4y agoYes, for a taxpayer who has a salary, a bank account and a brokerage account, and no other income than salary, interest, and investments, the IRS already has every number needed to compute the tax bill. With the last round of tax changes, very few people will have enough deductions (charitable contributions, local taxes, etc.) to make itemized deductions worthwhile. So the IRS could just do what many other countries do, which is to present the taxpayer with a filled-out form, which the taxpayer can either just accept, or amend (perhaps add deductions or unreported income).