3 ms·
> You can band together with other people to make a down payment, but again, this is unattractive for most people because there is no good exit strategy to cash
by scotty79 4y ago
> You can band together with other people to make a down payment, but again, this is unattractive for most people because there is no good exit strategy to cash out.
Yea. It probably doesn't work if you are wanting to buy something as an investment that you are planning to cash out of. But if you buy to use (to live or to produce something) it is attractive to collectively buy to have larger bargaining power and better credit trustworthiness if the risk is shared.
> I don't see why society would want to incentivize people to join them beyond the benefits that those people would naturally see from working at one.
Because model of ownership that is most popular currently led us to very pathological situations. Like this:
https://money.cnn.com/2016/07/29/news/economy/top-1-income/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2016/07/29/news/economy/top-1-income/i...
It got worse since then.
Another thing is that working conditions and salaries got really ridiculous and a whole class of employed poor rose that borderline can't sustain themselves with their work.
It's hard to regulate this stuff in current ownership model. So I think our best bet is to promote alternate ownership models so we may end up in less insane place than the one towards which we are heading.
> on the flip side, why punish workers are aren't part of co-ops?
It's never actually punishing workers. Ultimately it's the employer who pays for it all. And it makes sense because todays employer on average doesn't invest into the education of the workers, in their health and development, in their safety net. So it's only fair he should be paying for those costs that he externalizes to society.
In case of worker co-ops it's reasonable to assume that workers in them will be taken care of better. So less burden on society from externalized costs.
> If it is a good deal for the workers, they should do it. If it is a bad deal for the workers they shouldn't.
Currently the deck is stacked against coops because being able to fuel your company by burning people is a real advantage so a company that does that more will nearly always win with the one that does that less. And losing company will eventually have to dissolve so workers are pretty much left without a choice.
- s1artibartfast 4y ago>Yea. It probably doesn't work if you are wanting to buy something as an investment that you are planning to cash out of. But if you buy to use (to live or to produce something) it is attractive to collectively buy to have larger bargaining power and better credit trustworthiness if the risk is shared. I think you are missing the point. Im talking about real barriers that prefent people from cooperative agreements, even when they just want to use it. In the real world, it is rarely attractive to collectively buy, because you are locked in. This is the challenge. If you want to start a cooperative house, you basically need to be willing to live there forever or walk away from your down payment. The same is true for starting a coop business. Im not interested in hearing the benefits of coops, Im already a fan of them. I was hoping for an intelegent conversation about how their major limitations can be overcome.
- scotty79 4y agoIf you invested someoney with the cooperative you can always sell your share (if there is somebody that wants to buy).
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThat is a big IF. It is much harder to find someone to buy 25% of a house to live in or 25% of an auto shop to work in. Joint ownership is hard and you need a high level of trust in your cooperative partners. Imagine what it would take to convince you to buy 1/4 of 4 unit apartment with strangers. You might be putting your financial life's work in their hands.