3 ms·
Because the people who (#)&#(#^^&% write Linux need money for things like houses, cars, food, health care, school, and so on. That's why money counts.
by davidw 15y ago
Because the people who (#)&#(#^^&% write Linux need money for things like houses, cars, food, health care, school, and so on. That's why money counts.
- moonchrome 15y agoAs opposed to people who produce food, or oil, or anything else ? But giving them artificial monopolies is bad - right ? People who wrote Linux found a model that works without forcing other people to pay for it. They do rely on copyright to prevent "free riders" but even without it the financial model is the same, eg. FreeBSD, or any other non copy-left licensed opensource project that has a commercial story. It turns out that without software, hardware is pretty much useless, so even if you can't profit on software directly, you can expect things like OS development to be driven by hardware manufacturers. Money they could earn if they had monopolies on OS kernels would be extremely higher - but market isn't about creating profit for the producers - it's about creating value for the consumer, and consumer would get the value even if he didn't pay for it - so they are getting screwed by rent seeking.
- davidw 15y ago> But giving them artificial monopolies is bad - right ? No, not in and of itself. It's a messy compromise. Things like software patents are pretty much just bad. Copyright, in a limited form, seems to be good. Patents on things like medicines can be good in that they pay for research. All of them should be more limited than they currently are, most likely. Linux works, but who's to say it's 'optimal'? Given the huge amount of value it creates, I think relatively little filters back into the development of the system. > consumer would get the value even if he didn't pay for it If no one pays for it, the consumer will not get the value because the developer will have to do something else to make money, and will therefore not produce the code. Luckily, in the case of Linux, some money is funneled back into development, so it's not impossible, it's just much, much more complex than with "intellectual property".
- moonchrome 15y ago>Linux works, but who's to say it's 'optimal'? Given the huge amount of value it creates, I think relatively little filters back into the development of the system. And that's the crux of the problem. You seem to think that it's optimal if it puts money in to developers pocket. I'm saying it's optimal it provides more value for less cost to the consumer. Market is about consumers not about producers. >If no one pays for it, the consumer will not get the value because the developer will have to do something else to make money, and will therefore not produce the code. Where did I say nobody pays for it ? If you want to develop software and charge for it you're still left with different options, you can deploy with contracts/NDA style to the Oracle type market, you can sell software as a service and keep the source private (you can do this even with games by streaming them), or you can do ad-based apps like Zynga and mobile guys, you have major copying in that space and very little copyright enforcement - it sucks for the developers but it works for the consumers. And there's doing on demand stuff, where the customers pay in advanced, and can subsequently opensource it to distribute costs of maintenance or even split the costs by forming alliances (I've seen this in energy sector where three big companies decided to standardize and share some data exchange software), regular consulting/maintenance approach, etc. And there are probably many other ways to make money without IP. Demand still exists, you just need to find a way to profit from that demand without IP. All I'm trying to say is that intellectual property is a legal monopoly on non-rivalrous non-excludable good, it violates the nature of innovation (incremental improvement and copying are essential) and copying as creating new value for free instead of stealing.
- davidw 15y ago> You seem to think that it's optimal if it puts money in to developers pocket. No, I'm saying that if no money flows to developers, it's suboptimal because consumers lose out too. It has to be a balance, and IP has been a pretty good, if imperfect, way of achieving that balance. That's not to say I don't think IP needs an overhaul. I do, however, think that IP is part of the solution and not just 'bad'.
- moonchrome 15y ago